| JUSTICE | FROM | TO |
| Alfred Moore | 4-29-1802 | 1-26-1804 |
| William Johnson, Jr. | 3-29-1804 | 8-4-1834 |
| James Moore Wayne | 2-4-1835 | 10-28-1862 |
| John Catron | 10-29-1862 | 5-30-1865 |
| Noah Haynes Swayne | 4-8-1867 | 1-24-1881 |
| Joseph P. Bradley | 5-2-1881 | 5-17-1881 |
| Stanley Matthews | 5-17-1881 | 3-22-1889 |
| John Marshall Harlan | 5-13-1889 | 3-9-1890 |
| David Josiah Brewer | 3-10-1890 | 1-18-1891 |
| Henry Billings Brown | 1-19-1891 | 4-1-1894 |
| Howell Edmunds Jackson | 4-2-1894 | 8-8-1895 |
| Henry Billings Brown | 8-19-1895 | 2-2-1896 |
| John Marshall Harlan | 2-3-1896 | 10-14-1911 |
| William Rufus Day | 3-18-1912 | 11-13-1922 |
| James Clark McReynolds | 11-15-1922 | 1-31-1941 |
| Frank Murphy | 6-2-1941 | 10-13-1941 |
| Stanley Forman Reed | 10-14-1941 | 2-25-1957 |
| Harold Hitz Burton | 3-4-1957 | 10-13-1958 |
| William Joseph Brennan, Jr. | 6-24-1957 | 7-18-1958 |
| Felix Frankfurter | 7-19-1958 | 9-1-1958 |
| Potter Stewart | 10-14-1958 | 7-3-1981 |
| Earl Warren | 2-6-1968 | 6-23-1969 |
| Byron Raymond White | 7-4-1981 | 9-30-1981 |
| Sandra Day O'Connor | 10-1-1981 | 9-25-1986 |
| Antonin Scalia | 9-26-1986 | 10-8-1990 |
| John Paul Stevens | 10-9-1990 | 6-28-2010 |
| Clarence Thomas | 6-29-2010 | 9-27-2010 |
| Elena Kagan | 9-28-2010 | 10-18-2018 |
| Sonia Sotomayor | 10-19-2018 | 11-19-2020 |
| Brett M. Kavanaugh | 11-20-2020 | present |