You are here

Unsuccessful Nominations and Recess Appointments

Notations:
(1) Subsequently confirmed to the same vacancy
(2) Received a recess appointment to the same vacancy

George Washington (1789-1797)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
1st (1789-1791) Harrison, Robert H. Supreme Court September 24, 1789 confirmed September 26, 1789; nominee declined
  Johnson, Thomas District of Maryland September 24, 1789 confirmed September 26, 1789; nominee declined
  Pendleton, Edmund District of Virginia September 24, 1789 confirmed September 26, 1789; nominee declined
  Pinckney, Thomas District of South Carolina September 24, 1789 confirmed September 26, 1789; nominee declined
  Davie, William R. District of North Carolina June 7, 1790 confirmed June 8, 1790; nominee declined
2nd (1791-1793) Paterson, William (1) Supreme Court February 27, 1793 withdrawn by president February 28, 1793
3rd (1793-1795) Harrison, Richard District of New York April 16, 1794 withdrawn by president May 5, 1794
4th (1795-1797) Rutledge, John (2) Chief Justice, Supreme Court December 10, 1795 rejected by Senate December 15, 1795
  Cushing, William Chief Justice, Supreme Court January 26, 1796 confirmed January 27, 1796; nominee declined

 

John Adams (1797-1801)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
6th (1799-1801) Jay, John Chief Justice, Supreme Court December 18, 1800 confirmed December 19, 1800; nominee declined
  Greene, Ray District of Rhode Island February 18, 1801 confirmed February 20, 1801; no commission issued
  Ingersoll, Jared Chief Judge, Third Circuit February 18, 1801 confirmed February 20, 1801; nominee declined
  Lee, Charles Chief Judge, Fourth Circuit February 18, 1801 confirmed February 20, 1801; nominee declined
  Bee, Thomas Chief Judge, Fifth Circuit February 21, 1801 confirmed February 24, 1801; nominee declined
  Clay, Joseph, Jr. Fifth Circuit February 21, 1801 confirmed February 24, 1801; nominee declined
  Hill, William H. Albemarle, Cape Fear and Pamptico Districts of North Carolina February 21, 1801 confirmed February 24, 1801; vacancy did not occur
  Read, Jacob District of South Carolina February 21, 1801 confirmed February 24, 1801; vacancy did not occur
  Sitgreaves, John Fifth Circuit February 21, 1801 confirmed February 24, 1801; nominee declined
  Gibbons, Thomas District of Georgia February 24, 1801 confirmed February 25, 1801; vacancy did not occur
  Johnson, Thomas Chief Judge, Circuit Court of the District of Columbia February 28, 1801 confirmed March 3, 1801; nominee declined

 

Thomas Jefferson (1801-1809)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
7th (1801-1803) Gaillard, Theodore Chief Judge, Fifth Circuit May 30, 1801 (recess appointment) appointee declined
8th (1803-1805) Tompkins, Daniel D. District of New York March 1, 1805 confirmed March 2, 1805; nominee declined
9th (1805-1807) Livingston, Henry B. District of New York May 16, 1805 (recess appointment) appointee declined

 

James Madison (1809-1817)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
11th (1809-1811) Lincoln, Levi Supreme Court January 2, 1811 confirmed January 3, 1811; nominee declined
  Wolcott, Alexander Supreme Court February 4, 1811 rejected by Senate February 13, 1811
  Adams, John Quincy Supreme Court February 21, 1811 confirmed February 22, 1811; nominee declined
12th (1811-1813) Parker, Thomas District of South Carolina March 13, 1812 confirmed March 17, 1812; nominee declined
13th (1813-1815) Gaillard, Theodore District of Louisiana April 13, 1813 (recess appointment) appointee declined
14th (1815-1817) Parke, Benjamin (1) District of Indiana January 28, 1817 no Senate vote

 

James Monroe (1817-1825)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
17th (1821-1823) Charlton, Thomas U.P. District of Georgia May 15, 1821 (recess appointment) appointee declined

 

John Quincy Adams (1825-1829)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
19th (1825-1827) Smith, Daniel Western District of Virginia August 27, 1825 (recess appointment) appointee declined
  Pickens, Israel Northern and Southern Districts of Alabama February 17, 1826 confirmed March 9, 1826; nominee declined
20th (1827-1829) Creighton, William, Jr. (2) District of Ohio December 11, 1828 no Senate vote
  Crittenden, John J. Supreme Court December 17, 1828 no Senate vote
  Gurley, Henry H. Eastern and Western Districts of Louisiana January 6, 1829 no Senate vote

 

Andrew Jackson (1829-1837)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
23rd (1833-1835) Tappan, Benjamin (2) District of Ohio January 20, 1834 rejected by Senate May 29, 1834
  Taney, Roger B. Supreme Court January 15, 1835 no Senate vote
24th (1835-1837) Smith, William Supreme Court March 3, 1837 confirmed March 8, 1837; nominee declined

 

Martin Van Buren (1837-1841)
None

 

William Henry Harrison (1841)
None

 

John Tyler (1841-1845)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
27th (1841-1843) Ogden, Abner Nash Eastern and Western Districts of Louisiana July 15, 1841 confirmed July 15, 1841; nominee declined
  Crawford, Bennet A. Eastern and Western Districts of Lousiana October 19, 1841 (recess appointment) appointment invalid; vacancy did not occur
  Binney, Horace Eastern District of Pennsylvania January 18, 1842 confirmed January 25, 1842; nominee declined
  Bradford, Thomas Eastern District of Pennsylvania February 5, 1842 rejected by Senate February 21, 1842
  Dewey, Charles District of Indiana April 4, 1842 confirmed April 6, 1842; nominee declined
28th (1843-1845) Spencer, John C. Supreme Court January 8, 1844 rejected by Senate January 31, 1844
  Walworth, Reuben H. Supreme Court March 13, 1844 withdrawn by president June 17, 1844
  Christian, John B. Eastern District of Virginia April 2, 1844 rejected by Senate June 15, 1844
  King, Edward Supreme Court June 5, 1844 no Senate vote
  Collier, R.R. Eastern District of Virginia June 15, 1844 rejected by Senate June 15, 1844
  Spencer, John C. Supreme Court June 17, 1844 withdrawn by president June 17, 1844
  Walworth, Reuben H. Supreme Court June 17, 1844 no Senate vote
  King, Edward Supreme Court December 4, 1844 withdrawn by president February 7, 1845
  Walworth, Reuben H. Supreme Court December 4, 1844 withdrawn by president February 4, 1845
  Read, John M. Supreme Court February 7, 1845 no Senate vote

 

James K. Polk (1845-1849)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
29th (1845-1847) Woodward, George W. Supreme Court December 23, 1845 rejected by Senate January 22, 1846

 

Zachary Taylor (1849-1850)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
31st (1849-1851) Campbell, James G. Western District of Louisiana March 16, 1849 confirmed March 19, 1849; nominee declined
  Elgee, John K. Western District of Louisiana April 26, 1849 (recess appointment) appointee declined

 

Millard Fillmore (1850-1853)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
31st (1849-1851) Benjamin, Judah P. Northern District of California September 28, 1850 confirmed September 28, 1850; nominee declined
  Healey, John P. Southern District of California September 28, 1850 confirmed September 28, 1850; nominee declined
  Currey, John Northern District of California December 23, 1850 rejected by Senate January 25, 1851
32nd (1851-1853) Currey, John Southern District of California February 26, 1852 no Senate vote
  Bradford, E.A. Supreme Court August 16, 1852 no Senate vote
  Badger, George E. Supreme Court January 3, 1853 withdrawn by president February 14, 1853
  Micou, William C. Supreme Court February 14, 1853 no Senate vote

 

Franklin Pierce (1853-1857)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
33rd (1853-1855) Lumpkin, Joseph H. Court of Claims March 3, 1855 confirmed March 3, 1855; nominee declined
34th (1855-1857) Hopkins, George W. Chief Judge, Circuit Court of the District of Columbia October 5, 1855 (recess appointment) appointee declined

 

James Buchanan (1857-1861)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
36th (1859-1861) Pettit, John District of Kansas January 31, 1861 no Senate vote
  Black, Jeremiah S. Supreme Court February 5, 1861 no Senate vote

 

Abraham Lincoln (1861-1865)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
37th (1861-1863) Field, Stephen J. California Circuit February 25, 1863 no Senate vote
  Withey, Solomon L. (1) Western District of Michigan February 26, 1863 no Senate vote
38th (1863-1865) Wylie, Andrew (1), (2) Supreme Court of the District of Columbia March 10, 1863 confirmed March 12, 1863; Senate voted to reconsider confirmation March 13, 1863; no subsequent Senate vote
  Bingham, John Southern District of Florida June 4, 1863 (recess appointment) appointee declined
  Lawrence, William Southern District of Florida September 9, 1863 (recess appointment) appointee declined
  Durell, Edward H. (1), (2) Eastern District of Louisiana January 5, 1864 returned to president by Senate vote February 3, 1864
  Thompson, Richard W. Court of Claims February 10, 1865 withdrawn by president February 21, 1865

 

Andrew Johnson (1865-1869)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
39th (1865-1867) Dick, Robert P. Albemarle, Cape Fear and Pamptico Districts of North Carolina May 29, 1865 (recess appointment) appointee declined
  Stanberry, Henry Supreme Court April 16, 1866 no Senate vote
40th (1867-1869) Lockwood, William F. District of Nebraska March 15, 1867 rejected by Senate April 20, 1867
  Wilkinson, Ira O. District of Nebraska July 20, 1867 no Senate vote
  Worthington, Henry G. District of Nebraska January 28, 1868 withdrawn by president March 18, 1868

 

Ulysses Grant (1869-1877)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
41st (1869-1871) Clarke, James M. District of Rhode Island September 15, 1869 (recess appointment) appointee declined
  Pearre, George A. Fourth Circuit December 8, 1869 withdrawn by president April 6, 1870
  Yeaman, George H. Sixth Circuit December 8, 1869 withdrawn by president December 17, 1869
  Hoar, Ebenezer R. Supreme Court December 14, 1869 rejected by Senate February 3, 1870
  Withey, Solomon L. Sixth Circuit December 17, 1869 confirmed December 22, 1869; nominee declined
  Stanton, Edwin M. Supreme Court December 20, 1869 confirmed December 20, 1869; nominee died prior to appointment
  Gobin, John P.S. Southern District of Florida February 4, 1870 no Senate vote
  Appleton, John F. Eastern District of Texas April 26, 1870 confirmed May 16, 1870; nominee declined
  Conant, Sherman Southern District of Florida June 29, 1870 withdrawn by president July 7, 1870
  Oliver, John M. Supreme Court of the District of Columbia June 29, 1870 withdrawn by president July 14, 1870
  Hopkins, James C. (1) Western District of Wisconsin July 1, 1870 no Senate vote
  Winch, Joel C.C. (2) Eastern District of Texas December 15, 1870 no Senate vote
  Bruce, John Eastern District of Texas February 14, 1871 no Senate vote
42nd (1871-1873) Gray, Bird W. Eastern District of Texas March 10, 1871 confirmed March 10, 1871; Senate voted to reconsider confirmation March 20, 1871; no subsequent Senate vote
  Gray, Bird W. Eastern District of Texas May 15, 1871 no Senate vote
  Goddard, William H. Eastern District of Texas December 18, 1871 withdrawn by president January 18, 1872
  Busteed, Richard Supreme Court of the District of Columbia January 13, 1873 returned to president by Senate vote February 13, 1873
  Humphreys, David C. Middle, Northern and Southern Districts of Alabama January 13, 1873 returned to president by Senate vote February 13, 1873
43rd (1873-1875) Williams, George H. Chief Justice, Supreme Court December 1, 1873 withdrawn by president January 8, 1874
  Cushing, Caleb Chief Justice, Supreme Court January 9, 1874 withdrawn by president January 13, 1874
  Pardee, Don A. District of Louisiana December 14, 1874 no Senate vote
  Parsons, Lewis E. Middle, Northern and Southern Districts of Alabama December 18, 1874 withdrawn by president February 23, 1875
44th (1875-1877) Pardee, Don A. District of Louisiana March 9, 1875 no Senate vote
  Kinsman, J. Burnham Western District of Arkansas March 10, 1875 withdrawn by president March 18, 1875
  Griswold, Elias Northern District of Florida January 11, 1877 withdrawn by president January 12, 1877
  Griswold, Elias Northern District of Florida January 18, 1877 withdrawn by president January 23, 1877

 

Rutherford B. Hayes (1877-1881)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
45th (1877-1879) Baxter, John (1) Sixth Circuit October 25, 1877 no Senate vote
  Turner, Ezekiel B. Northern District of Texas March 1, 1879 no Senate vote
46th (1879-1881) Turner, Ezekiel B. Northern District of Texas March 19, 1879 rejected by Senate April 2, 1879
  Matthews, R. Stockett District of Maryland April 9, 1879 withdrawn by president July 1, 1879
  McCrary, George W. Eighth Circuit June 3, 1879 withdrawn by president June 21, 1879
  Billings, Edward C. Fifth Circuit January 24, 1881 no Senate vote
  Matthews, Stanley (1) Supreme Court January 26, 1881 no Senate vote

 

James A. Garfield (1881)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
47th (1881-1883) Phillips, Samuel F. Court of Claims March 23, 1881 withdrawn by president May 19, 1881

 

Chester A. Arthur (1881-1885)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
47th (1881-1883) Conkling, Roscoe Supreme Court February 24, 1882 confirmed March 2, 1882; nominee declined
  Atkins, James Northern District of Georgia July 3, 1882 withdrawn by president August 3, 1882

 

Grover Cleveland (1885-1889)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
50th (1887-1889) Lacombe, Emile H. (1), (2) Second Circuit December 20, 1887 withdrawn by president February 27, 1888
  Hartridge, John E. Northern District of Florida December 18, 1888 no Senate vote
  Stevenson, Adlai E. Supreme Court of the District of Columbia February 11, 1889 no Senate vote

 

Benjamin Harrison (1889-1893)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
51st (1889-1891) Day, William R. Northern District of Ohio May 24, 1889 (recess appointment) appointee declined
  Beatty, James H. (1), (2) District of Idaho February 10, 1891 no Senate vote
52nd (1891-1893) Hanchett, Benton Sixth Circuit February 23, 1893 no Senate vote

 

Grover Cleveland (1893-1897)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
53rd (1893-1895) Hornblower, William B. Supreme Court September 19, 1893 no Senate vote
  Hornblower, William B. Supreme Court December 5, 1893 rejected by Senate January 15, 1894
  Peckham, Wheeler H. Supreme Court January 22, 1894 rejected by Senate February 19, 1894
  Porter, James D. Eastern and Middle Districts of Tennessee August 6, 1894 no Senate vote
54th (1895-1897) McHugh, William D. (2) District of Nebraska December 8, 1896 withdrawn by president February 1, 1897
  Wolcott, James L. District of Delaware February 20, 1897 no Senate vote
  Clark, William W. Eastern District of North Carolina February 25, 1897 no Senate vote

 

William McKinley (1897-1901)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
55th (1897-1899) Ewart, Hamilton G. (2) Western District of North Carolina January 27, 1898 no Senate vote
  Meek, Edward R. (1), (2) Northern District of Texas March 10, 1898 no Senate vote
  Ewart, Hamilton G. (2) Western District of North Carolina December 13, 1898 no Senate vote
56th (1899-1901) Ewart, Hamilton G. (2) Western District of North Carolina December 19, 1899 no Senate vote

 

Theodore Roosevelt (1901-1909)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
57th (1901-1903) Holmes, Oliver W., Jr. (1) Supreme Court August 11, 1902 (recess appointment) appointment cancelled by president
  Morris, Page (1) District of Minnesota February 19, 1903 no Senate vote
58th (1903-1905) Quarles, Joseph V. (1) Eastern District of Wisconsin February 25, 1905 no Senate vote
59th (1905-1907) Chatfield, Thomas (1) Eastern District of New York December 10, 1906 withdrawn by president December 17, 1906
60th (1907-1909) Van Fleet, William C. (1), (2) Northern District of California March 4, 1907 (recess appointment) appointment cancelled by president
  Hundley, Oscar R. (2) Northern District of Alabama December 3, 1907 no Senate vote
  Sater, John E. (1), (2) Southern District of Ohio December 3, 1907 no Senate vote
  Purdy, Milton D. (2) District of Minnesota April 23, 1908 no Senate vote
  Hundley, Oscar R. (2) Northern District of Alabama December 8, 1908 no Senate vote
  Purdy, Milton D. (2) District of Minnesota December 8, 1908 no Senate vote
  Seawell, Herbert F. Eastern District of North Carolina January 18, 1909 no Senate vote

 

William H. Taft (1909-1913)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
61st (1909-1911) Barber, Orion M. (1) Court of Customs Appeals January 5, 1910 withdrawn by president February 22, 1910
  Coxe, Alfred C., Sr. Presiding Judge, Court of Customs Appeals January 5, 1910 withdrawn by president February 22, 1910
  De Vries, Marion (1) Court of Customs Appeals January 5, 1910 withdrawn by president February 22, 1910
  Hunt, William H. (1) Court of Customs Appeals January 5, 1910 withdrawn by president February 22, 1910
  Smith, James F. (1) Court of Customs Appeals January 5, 1910 withdrawn by president February 22, 1910
62nd (1911-1913) Sloan, Richard E. (2) District of Arizona March 1, 1912 no Senate vote
  Cheney, John M. (2) Southern District of Florida July 25, 1912 no Senate vote
  Howard, Clinton W. (2) Western District of Washington August 19, 1912 no Senate vote
  Cheney, John M. (2) Southern District of Florida December 3, 1912 no Senate vote
  Howard, Clinton W. (2) Western District of Washington December 3, 1912 no Senate vote
  Sloan, Richard E. (2) District of Arizona December 3, 1912 no Senate vote
  Carpenter, George A. Seventh Circuit December 17, 1912 no Senate vote
  Cutting, Charles C. Northern District of Illinois December 17, 1912 no Senate vote
  Booth, Fenton W. Chief Justice, Court of Claims January 2, 1913 no Senate vote
  Boutell, Henry S. Court of Claims January 2, 1913 no Senate vote
  Brown, Arthur L. First Circuit February 10, 1913 no Senate vote
  Mumford, Charles C. District of Rhode Island February 10, 1913 no Senate vote
  Fisher, Samuel H. District of Connecticut February 20, 1913 no Senate vote

 

Woodrow Wilson (1913-1921)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
63rd (1913-1915) Siddons, Frederick L. (1) Supreme Court of the District of Columbia October 21, 1914 no Senate vote
64th (1915-1917) Palmer, A. Mitchell Court of Claims March 16, 1915 (recess appointment) appointee declined
  Westenhaver, David C. (1) Northern District of Ohio February 19, 1917 no Senate vote
65th (1917-1919) Whipple, U.V. Southern District of Georgia April 9, 1917 rejected by Senate April 24, 1917
  Thomas, W.E. Southern District of Georgia July 11, 1917 rejected by Senate July 12, 1917
  Haight, Thomas G. (1), (2) Third Circuit March 1, 1919 no Senate vote
66th (1919-1921) Garrett, Finis J. Western District of Tennessee November 22, 1920 (recess appointment) appointee declined
  Garrett, Finis J. Western District of Tennessee December 10, 1920 no Senate vote
  Ryan, William Western District of Wisconsin January 7, 1921 no Senate vote

 

Warren G. Harding (1921-1923)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
67th (1921-1923) Butler, Pierce (1) Supreme Court November 21, 1922 no Senate vote
  Rose, John C. (1) Fourth Circuit November 27, 1922 no Senate vote
  Hoffheimer, Harry M. Southern District of Ohio February 28, 1923 confirmed March 2, 1923; nominee declined

 

Calvin Coolidge (1923-1929)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
69th (1925-1927) McCarthy, James W. District of New Jersey March 18, 1925 confirmed March 18, 1925; nominee declined
  McCamant, Wallace (2) Ninth Circuit December 8, 1925 rejected by Senate March 17, 1926
  Tilson, William J. (2) Middle District of Georgia June 9, 1926 withdrawn by president June 18, 1926
  Tilson, William J. (2) Middle District of Georgia December 7, 1926 withdrawn by president February 8, 1927
70th (1927-1929) McDermott, George T. District of Kansas December 13, 1927 withdrawn by president January 12, 1928
  Bowen, Crate D. Southern District of Florida May 24, 1928 no Senate vote
  Vaught, Edward S. (1), (2) Western District of Oklahoma May 26, 1928 no Senate vote
  Bowen, Crate D. Southern District of Florida January, 19, 1929 withdrawn by president January 23, 1929
  Glassie, Henry H. Supreme Court of the District of Columbia February 14, 1929 no Senate vote
  Lenroot, Irvine L. (1) Court of Customs Appeals February 14, 1929 no Senate vote
  Wheat, Alfred A. Eastern District of New York February 28, 1929 no Senate vote
  Woolsey, John M. (1) Southern District of New York February 28, 1929 no Senate vote
  Caffey, Francis G. (1) Southern District of New York March 1, 1929 no Senate vote
  Gardner, Archibald K. (1) Eighth Circuit March 1, 1929 no Senate vote
  McDermott, George T. (1) Tenth Circuit March 1, 1929 no Senate vote
  Phillips, Orie L. (1) Tenth Circuit March 1, 1929 no Senate vote
  Stryker, Lloyd P. Southern District of New York March 1, 1929 no Senate vote
  Wilbur, Curtis D. (1) Ninth Circuit March 1, 1929 no Senate vote
  Wyman, A. Lee (1) District of South Dakota March 1, 1929 no Senate vote

 

Herbert Hoover (1929-1933)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
71st (1929-1931) Watson, Albert L. (1) Middle District of Pennsylvania June 8, 1929 no Senate vote
  Parker, John J. Supreme Court March 21, 1930 rejected by Senate May 7, 1930
  Nordbye, Gunnar H. (1), (2) District of Minnesota February 20, 1931 no Senate vote
  Fee, James A. (1), (2) District of Oregon February 26, 1931 no Senate vote
72nd (1931-1933) Mackintosh, Kenneth Ninth Circuit January 8, 1932 no Senate vote
  Wilkerson, James H. Seventh Circuit January 12, 1932 no Senate vote
  Johnson, George E.Q. (2) Northern District of Illinois December 7, 1932 no Senate vote
  Mackintosh, Kenneth Ninth Circuit December 7, 1932 no Senate vote
  Ramseyer, C. William Customs Court December 13, 1932 no Senate vote
  Newton, Walter H. District of Minnesota February 18, 1933 no Senate vote
  Richardson, Seth W. Eighth Circuit February 23, 1933 no Senate vote

 

Franklin D. Roosevelt (1933-1945)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
73rd (1933-1935) Norcross, Frank H. Ninth Circuit September 23, 1933 (recess appointment) appointee declined
  Woodburn, William District of Nevada September 23, 1933 (recess appointment) appointment invalid; vacancy did not occur
  Norcross, Frank H. Ninth Circuit January 8, 1934 no Senate vote
75th (1937-1939) Allred, James V. (1) Southern District of Texas July 11, 1938 (recess appointment) appointee declined
76th (1939-1941) Roberts, Floyd H. (2) Western District of Virginia January 5, 1939 rejected by Senate February 6, 1939
  Lee, William B. Eastern and Middle Districts of Tennessee January 24, 1939 confirmed February 1, 1939; nominee died prior to appointment
  Porterie, Gaston L.N. Northern District of Louisiana [sic] January 24, 1939 withdrawn by president January 25, 1939
  Darr, Leslie R. (1) Eastern and Middle Districts of Tennessee May 17, 1939 withdrawn by president May 24, 1939
77th (1941-1943) Chandler, Stephen S., Jr. (1) Western District of Oklahoma December 11, 1942 no Senate vote
  Lawrence, Charles D. (1) Customs Court December 11, 1942 no Senate vote
78th (1943-1945) Allred, James V. Fifth Circuit February 18, 1943 no Senate vote
79th (1945-1947) Margold, Nathan R. District of the District of Columbia January 19, 1945 no Senate vote
  Johnson, Jed Customs Court March 29, 1945 confirmed April 3, 1945; nominee declined

 

Harry S Truman (1945-1953)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
79th (1945-1947) Kalodner, Harry E. Third Circuit May 7, 1946 withdrawn by president, May 21, 1946
80th (1947-1949) Harper, Roy W. (1), (2) Eastern and Western Districts of Missouri July 10, 1947 no Senate vote
  Harper, Roy W. (1), (2) Eastern and Western Districts of Missouri November 24, 1947 no Senate vote
  Tamm, Edward A. (1), (2) District of the District of Columbia February 3, 1948 no Senate vote
  Warlick, Wilson Western District of North Carolina April 2, 1948 no Senate vote
  Rao, Paul P. (1), (2) Customs Court May 3, 1948 no Senate vote
  Kaufman, Samuel H. (1), (2) Southern District of New York May 17, 1948 no Senate vote
  Harper, Roy W. (1), (2) Eastern and Western Districts of Missouri July 29, 1948 no Senate vote
  Kaufman, Samuel H. (1), (2) Southern District of New York July 29, 1948 no Senate vote
  Rao, Paul P. (1), (2) Customs Court July 29, 1948 no Senate vote
  Tamm, Edward A. (1), (2) District of the District of Columbia July 29, 1948 no Senate vote
81st (1949-1951) Eberharter, Herman P. Western District of Pennsylvania April 26, 1949 no Senate vote
  Switzer, Carroll O. (2) Southern District of Iowa June 9, 1949 no Senate vote
  Ritter, Willis W. (1), (2) District of Utah August 25, 1949 no Senate vote
  Andrews, M. Neil Northern District of Georgia October 15, 1949 no Senate vote
  Bazelon, David L. (1), (2) District of Columbia Circuit October 15, 1949 no Senate vote
  Burns, Owen M. (1), (2) Western District of Pennsylvania October 15, 1949 no Senate vote
  Clary, Thomas J. (1), (2) Eastern District of Pennsylvania October 15, 1949 no Senate vote
  Fahy, Charles (1), (2) District of Columbia Circuit October 15, 1949 no Senate vote
  Grim, Allan K. (1), (2) Eastern District of Pennsylvania October 15, 1949 no Senate vote
  Hastie, William H. (1), (2) Third Circuit October 15, 1949 no Senate vote
  Hill, Delmas C. (1), (2) District of Kansas October 15, 1949 no Senate vote
  Hooper, Frank A. Northern District of Georgia October 15, 1949 no Senate vote
  Kaufman, Irving R. (1), (2) Southern District of New York October 15, 1949 no Senate vote
  McGohey, John F.X. (1), (2) Southern District of New York October 15, 1949 no Senate vote
  Noonan, Gregory F. (1), (2) Southern District of New York October 15, 1949 no Senate vote
  Solomon, Gus J. (1), (2) District of Oregon October 15, 1949 no Senate vote
  Sugarman, Sidney (1), (2) Southern District of New York October 15, 1949 no Senate vote
  Swaim, H. Nathan (1), (2) Seventh Circuit October 15, 1949 no Senate vote
  Washington, George T. (1), (2) District of Columbia Circuit October 15, 1949 no Senate vote
  Wright, J. Skelly (1), (2) Eastern District of Louisiana October 15, 1949 no Senate vote
  Kirkland, James R. (1), (2) District of the District of Columbia October 17, 1949 no Senate vote
  Matthews, Burnita S. (1), (2) District of the District of Columbia October 17, 1949 no Senate vote
  McLaughlin, Charles F. (1), (2) District of the District of Columbia October 17, 1949 no Senate vote
  Andrews, M. Neil (2) Northern District of Georgia January 5, 1950 rejected by Senate August 9, 1950
  Switzer, Carroll O. (2) Southern District of Iowa January 5, 1950 rejected by Senate August 9, 1950
  Byrne, William M., Sr. (1), (2) Southern District of California September 1, 1950 no Senate vote
  Carter, Oliver J. (1), (2) Northern District of California September 1, 1950 no Senate vote
82nd (1951-1953) Hennock, Frieda B. Southern District of New York June 11, 1951 no Senate vote
  Drucker, Joseph J. Northern District of Illinois July 13, 1951 rejected by Senate October 9, 1951
  Harrington, Cornelius J. Northern District of Illinois July 13, 1951 rejected by Senate October 9, 1951
  Tolin, Ernest A. (1), (2) Southern District of California October 18, 1951 no Senate vote
  Friedman, Monroe M. (2) Northern District of California June 27, 1952 no Senate vote
83rd (1953-1955) Friedman, Monroe M. (2) Northern District of California January 9, 1953 withdrawn by president July 24, 1953

 

Dwight D. Eisenhower (1953-1961)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
83rd (1953-1955) Van Dusen, Francis L. (1) Eastern District of Pennsylvania March 29, 1954 no Senate vote
  Bastian, Walter M. (1), (2) District of Columbia Circuit August 19, 1954 no Senate vote
  Cecil, Lamar J.R. (1), (2) Eastern District of Texas August 19, 1954 no Senate vote
  Miller, William E. (1) Middle District of Tennessee August 19, 1954 no Senate vote
  Harlan, John M. (1) Supreme Court November 9, 1954 no Senate vote
  Devitt, Edward J. (1), (2) District of Minnesota November 16, 1954 no Senate vote
  Miller, William E. (1) Middle District of Tennessee November 16, 1954 no Senate vote
84th (1955-1957) Herlands, William B. (1), (2) Southern District of New York May 11, 1955 no Senate vote
  Kraft, C. William, Jr. (1), (2) Eastern District of Pennsylvania May 20, 1955 no Senate vote
  Burger, Warren E. (1) District of Columbia Circuit June 21, 1955 no Senate vote
  Sobeloff, Simon E. (1) Fourth Circuit July 14, 1955 no Senate vote
  Lieb, Joseph P. (1), (2) Southern District of Florida July 30, 1955 no Senate vote
  Watkins, R. Dorsey (1), (2) District of Maryland July 30, 1955 no Senate vote
  Morgan, Justin C. (1) Western District of New York August 1, 1955 no Senate vote
85th (1957-1959) Moore, Leonard P. (1), (2) Second Circuit March 19, 1957 no Senate vote
  Henley, J. Smith (2) Eastern District of Arkansas February 24, 1958 no Senate vote
  Hart, George L., Jr. (1), (2) District of the District of Columbia August 16, 1958 no Senate vote
  Boreman, Herbert S. (1) Fourth Circuit October 17, 1958 (recess appointment) appointee declined
86th (1959-1961) Henley, J. Smith (2) Eastern District of Arkansas January 17, 1959 withdrawn by president August 18, 1959
  Tucker, John G. Eastern District of Texas February 12, 1959 withdrawn by president August 3, 1959
  Paul, Charles F. (1) Northern District of West Virginia August 3, 1959 no Senate vote
  Durfee, James (1) Court of Claims August 25, 1959 no Senate vote
  Smith, J. Joseph (1) Second Circuit August 27, 1959 no Senate vote
  Timbers, William H. (1) District of Connecticut August 27, 1959 no Senate vote
  Tavares, C. Nils (1), (2) District of Hawaii January 14, 1960 no Senate vote
  Kennerly, Thomas E. Southern District of Texas June 6, 1960 no Senate vote
  Feikens, John (2) Eastern District of Michigan June 10, 1960 no Senate vote
  Caffrey, Andrew A. (1), (2) District of Massachusetts July 1, 1960 no Senate vote
87th (1961-1963) Feikens, John (2) Eastern District of Michigan January 10, 1961 no Senate vote

 

John F. Kennedy (1961-1963)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
87th (1961-1963) Bell, Griffin B. (1), (2) Fifth Circuit September 20, 1961 no Senate vote
  Gewin, Walter P. (1), (2) Fifth Circuit September 20, 1961 no Senate vote
  Rosling, George (1), (2) Eastern District of New York September 21, 1961 no Senate vote
  Allgood, Clarence W. (1), (2) Northern District of Alabama September 23, 1961 no Senate vote
  Bonsal, Dudley B. (1), (2) Southern District of New York September 23, 1961 no Senate vote
  Cooper, Irving B. (1), (2) Southern District of New York September 23, 1961 no Senate vote
  Daugherty, Frederick A. (1), (2) Eastern, Northern and Western Districts of Oklahoma September 23, 1961 no Senate vote
  Feinberg, Wilfred (1), (2) Southern District of New York September 23, 1961 no Senate vote
  Green, Ben C. (1), (2) Northern District of Ohio September 23, 1961 no Senate vote
  Hays, Paul R. (1), (2) Second Circuit September 23, 1961 no Senate vote
  Marshall, Thurgood (1), (2) Second Circuit September 23, 1961 no Senate vote
  Peck, John W. II (1), (2) Southern District of Ohio September 23, 1961 no Senate vote
  Smith, Talbot (1), (2) Eastern District of Michigan September 23, 1961 no Senate vote
  Brewster, Leo (1), (2) Northern District of Texas September 25, 1961 no Senate vote
  Hughes, Sarah T. (1), (2) Northern District of Texas September 25, 1961 no Senate vote
  Noel, James L., Jr. (1), (2) Southern District of Texas September 25, 1961 no Senate vote
  Spears, Adrian A. (1), (2) Western District of Texas September 25, 1961 no Senate vote
  Almond, J. Lindsay, Jr. (1), (2) Court of Customs and Patent Appeals April 16, 1962 no Senate vote
  McGowan, Carl E. (1) District of Columbia Circuit August 16, 1962 no Senate vote
88th (1963-1965) Davis, John M. (1), (2) Eastern District of Pennsylvania September 3, 1963 no Senate vote
  Rabinovitz, David (2) Western District of Wisconsin September 6, 1963 no Senate vote
  Higginbotham, A. Leon, Jr. (1), (2) Eastern District of Pennsylvania September 25, 1963 no Senate vote
  Robinson, Spottswood W. III (1), (2) District of the District of Columbia October 1, 1963 no Senate vote

 

Lyndon B. Johnson (1963-1969)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
88th (1963-1965) Rabinovitz, David (2) Western District of Wisconsin February 3, 1964 no Senate vote
89th (1965-1967) Fullam, John P. (1) Eastern District of Pennsylvania August 24, 1965 no Senate vote
  Morrissey, Francis X. District of Massachusetts September 28, 1965 no Senate vote
  Watson, James L. (1) Customs Court October 6, 1965 no Senate vote
  Feinberg, Wilfred (1) Second Circuit October 11, 1965 no Senate vote
  Thomas, William K. (1) Northern District of Ohio October 18, 1965 no Senate vote
  Weinstein, Jack B. (1) Eastern District of New York October 17, 1966 no Senate vote
90th (1967-1969) Poole, Cecil F. Northern District of California May 29, 1968 no Senate vote
  Fortas, Abe Chief Justice, Supreme Court June 26, 1968 withdrawn by president October 4, 1968
  Thornberry, Homer W. Supreme Court June 26, 1968 withdrawn by president October 4, 1968
  Bress, David G. District of the District of Columbia August 2, 1968 no Senate vote
  Sanders, Harold B., Jr. District of Columbia Circuit September 25, 1968 no Senate vote
  Byrne, William M., Jr. Central District of California October 1, 1968 no Senate vote
91st (1969-1971) Bress, David G. District of the District of Columbia January 9, 1969 withdrawn by president January 23, 1969
  Byrne, William M., Jr. Central District of California January 9, 1969 withdrawn by president January 23, 1969
  Poole, Cecil F. Northern District of California January 9, 1969 withdrawn by president January 23, 1969
  Sanders, Harold B., Jr. District of Columbia Circuit January 9, 1969 withdrawn by president January 23, 1969

 

Richard M. Nixon (1969-1974)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
91st (1969-1971) Bane, Charles A. Seventh Circuit May 28, 1969 withdrawn by president October 22, 1969
  Haynsworth, Clement F., Jr. Supreme Court August 21, 1969 rejected by Senate November 21, 1969
  Pell, Wilbur F., Jr. (1) Seventh Circuit December 15, 1969 no Senate vote
  Carswell, G. Harrold Supreme Court January 19, 1970 rejected by Senate April 8, 1970
  Varner, Robert E. (1) Middle District of Alabama December 4, 1970 no Senate vote
93rd (1973-1975) Torruella, Juan R. (1) District of Puerto Rico May 28, 1974 no Senate vote
  Meskill, Thomas J. (1) Second Circuit August 8, 1974 no Senate vote

 

Gerald R. Ford (1974-1977)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
93rd (1973-1975) Meskill, Thomas J. (1) Second Circuit November 18, 1974 no Senate vote
  Henley, J. Smith (1) Eighth Circuit December 11, 1974 no Senate vote
94th (1975-1977) Poff, William B. Western District of Virginia April 1, 1976 withdrawn by president June 7, 1976
  Revell, Richard A. Western District of Kentucky April 26, 1976 no Senate vote
  Kovachevich, Elizabeth A. Middle District of Florida June 11, 1976 no Senate vote
  Bethune, Edwin R., Jr. Eastern and Western Districts of Arkansas June 15, 1976 no Senate vote
  Brotzman, Donald G. District of Colorado July 22, 1976 no Senate vote
  Bilby, Richard M. Ninth Circuit August 3, 1976 no Senate vote
  Moore, John H. II Southern District of Florida August 4, 1976 no Senate vote
  Wellford, Harry W. Sixth Circuit August 4, 1976 no Senate vote
  DeSimone, Herbert F. District of Rhode Island August 5, 1976 no Senate vote
  Walter, Donald E. Western District of Louisiana August 5, 1976 no Senate vote
  Anderson, James A. Eastern and Western Districts of Washington August 6, 1976 no Senate vote

 

Jimmy Carter (1977-1981)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
95th (1977-1979) Collins, Robert F. (1) Eastern District of Louisiana November 2, 1977 no Senate vote
  Mazzone, A. David (1) District of Massachusetts November 21, 1977 no Senate vote
  Simmons, Paul A. (1) Western District of Pennsylvania November 22, 1977 no Senate vote
  Paletta, Len J. Western District of Pennsylvania April 7, 1978 withdrawn by president May 25, 1978
  Clauss, Carin Ann District of the District of Columbia September 19, 1978 no Senate vote
96th (1979-1981) Green, Joyce H. District of the District of Columbia March 2, 1979 withdrawn by president March 6, 1979
  Winberry, Charles B., Jr. Eastern District of North Carolina March 29, 1979 withdrawn by president August 26, 1980
  Jones, James P. Western District of Virginia May 16, 1979 no Senate vote
  Jefferson, Andrew L., Jr. Fifth Circuit October 11, 1979 no Senate vote
  Arnold, Richard S. (1) Eighth Circuit December 14, 1979 withdrawn by president December 19, 1979
  Gray, Fred D. Middle District of Alabama January 10, 1980 withdrawn by president September 17, 1980
  Heen, Walter M. (2) District of Hawaii February 27, 1980 no Senate vote
  Sheffield, James E. Eastern District of Virginia April 9, 1980 no Senate vote
  Sprizzo, John E. (1) Southern District of New York June 2, 1980 no Senate vote
  Sachs, Howard F. Eighth Circuit July 30, 1980 no Senate vote
  Gimenez-Munoz, Miguel A. District of Puerto Rico July 31, 1980 no Senate vote
  Arnold, S. Gerald Eastern District of North Carolina August 26, 1980 no Senate vote
  Lackey, Gerald B. Northern District of Ohio August 28, 1980 no Senate vote
  Lowry, Peter M. Western District of Texas August 28, 1980 no Senate vote
  Nickerson, Eugene H. Second Circuit August 28, 1980 no Senate vote
  Roberts, David G. District of Maine August 28, 1980 no Senate vote
  Bua, Nicholas J. Seventh Circuit September 10, 1980 no Senate vote
  Glasser, Israel L. Eastern District of New York September 17, 1980 no Senate vote
  Nimmons, Ralph W., Jr. Middle District of Florida September 17, 1980 no Senate vote
  Weinberg, Philip Eastern District of New York September 17, 1980 no Senate vote
97th (1981-1983) Heen, Walter M. (2) District of Hawaii January 8, 1981 withdrawn by president January 21, 1981

 

Ronald Reagan (1981-1989)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
97th (1981-1983) Unger, Sherman E. Federal Circuit December 15, 1982 no Senate vote
  Vukasin, John P., Jr. (1) Northern District of California December 17, 1982 no Senate vote
98th (1983-1985) Vukasin, John P., Jr. (1) Northern District of California January 31, 1983 no Senate vote
  Unger, Sherman E. Federal Circuit April 21, 1983 no Senate vote
  Starr, Kenneth W. (1) District of Columbia Circuit July 13, 1983 no Senate vote
  Galane, Morton R. District of Nevada July 21, 1983 no Senate vote
  Keenan, John F. (1) Southern District of New York July 21, 1983 no Senate vote
  Galane, Morton R. District of Nevada September 13, 1983 withdrawn by president October 18, 1983
  Unger, Sherman E. Federal Circuit September 13, 1983 no Senate vote
  Hargrove, John R., Sr. (1) District of Maryland November 10, 1983 no Senate vote
  Wilkinson, J. Harvie III (1) Fourth Circuit November 10, 1983 no Senate vote
  Sporkin, Stanley (1) District of the District of Columbia June 28, 1984 no Senate vote
  Aquilino, Thomas J., Jr. (1) Court of International Trade August 1, 1984 no Senate vote
  Bator, Paul M. District of Columbia Circuit August 1, 1984 withdrawn by president September 6, 1984
  Easterbrook, Frank H. (1) Seventh Circuit August 1, 1984 no Senate vote
  Holderman, James F., Jr. (1) Northern District of Illinois September 6, 1984 no Senate vote
  Cobb, Howell Eastern District of Texas September 10, 1984 no Senate vote
  Edgar, R. Allan (1) Eastern District of Tennessee September 11, 1984 no Senate vote
  La Plata, George (1) Eastern District of Michigan September 11, 1984 no Senate vote
  Meredith, Ronald E. (1) Western District of Kentucky September 11, 1984 no Senate vote
  Young, William G. (1) District of Massachusetts September 11, 1984 no Senate vote
  Jones, Edith H. (1) Fifth Circuit September 17, 1984 no Senate vote
  Rodriguez, Joseph H. (1) District of New Jersey September 17, 1984 no Senate vote
  Weber, Herman J. (1) Southern District of Ohio September 17, 1984 no Senate vote
  Batchelder, Alice M. (1) Northern District of Ohio October 5, 1984 no Senate vote
  Brunetti, Melvin T. (1) Ninth Circuit October 5, 1984 no Senate vote
  Walter, Donald E. (1) Western District of Louisiana October 5, 1984 no Senate vote
  Williams, Ann C. (1) Northern District of Illinois October 5, 1984 no Senate vote
  Wolf, Mark L. (1) District of Massachusetts October 5, 1984 no Senate vote
99th (1985-1987) Moon, Albert I., Jr. District of Hawaii October 16, 1985 no Senate vote
  Sessions, Jefferson B. III Southern District of Alabama October 23, 1985 no Senate vote
  Fitzwater, Sidney A. (1) Northern District of Texas October 29, 1985 no Senate vote
  McAvoy, Thomas J. (1) Northern District of New York October 29, 1985 no Senate vote
  Bryan, Robert J. (1) Western District of Washington December 4, 1985 no Senate vote
  Cedarbaum, Miriam G. (1) Southern District of New York December 4, 1985 no Senate vote
  Gex, Walter J. III (1) Southern District of Mississippi December 4, 1985 no Senate vote
  Hansen, David R. (1) Northern District of Iowa December 4, 1985 no Senate vote
  Boggs, Danny J. (1) Sixth Circuit December 9, 1985 no Senate vote
  Sessions, Jefferson B. III Southern District of Alabama January 29, 1986 withdrawn by president July 31, 1986
  Porter, James K. Eastern District of Tennessee July 30, 1986 no Senate vote
  Dwyer, William L. (1) Western District of Washington September 26, 1986 no Senate vote
  Raggi, Reena (1) Eastern District of New York October 3, 1986 no Senate vote
100th (1987-1989) Siegan, Bernard H. Ninth Circuit February 2, 1987 withdrawn by president September 16, 1988
  Miller, Robert N. District of Colorado February 5, 1987 withdrawn by president February 2, 1988
  Liebeler, Susan W. Federal Circuit March 23, 1987 no Senate vote
  Bork, Robert H. Supreme Court July 7, 1987 rejected by Senate October 23, 1987
  Treen, David C. Fifth Circuit July 22, 1987 withdrawn by president May 10, 1988
  Summit, Stuart A. Second Circuit September 23, 1987 no Senate vote
  Roberto, Robert, Jr. Eastern District of New York November 24, 1987 withdrawn by president July 26, 1988
  Schmutzer, Alfred C., Jr. Eastern District of Tennessee December 18, 1987 withdrawn by president March 28, 1988
  Walker, Vaughn R. (1) Northern District of California December 18, 1987 no Senate vote
  Levitt, Howard E. Eastern District of New York December 22, 1987 no Senate vote
  Abram, Donald E. District of Colorado February 19, 1988 no Senate vote
  Mason, Shannon T., Jr. Eastern District of Virginia February 22, 1988 no Senate vote
  McGregor, James R. Western District of Pennsylvania March 14, 1988 no Senate vote
  Erickson, William H. District of Colorado March 23, 1988 no Senate vote
  Hope, Judith R. District of Columbia Circuit April 14, 1988 no Senate vote
  Rymer, Pamela A. (1) Ninth Circuit April 26, 1988 no Senate vote
  Bonner, Robert C. (1) Central District of California June 15, 1988 no Senate vote
  Harmon, Melinda (1) Southern District of Texas June 23, 1988 no Senate vote
  Weiner, Jacques L., Jr. Fifth Circuit June 27, 1988 no Senate vote
  Garbis, Marvin J. (1) District of Maryland July 6, 1988 no Senate vote
  Hurlbutt, Guy G. Ninth Circuit August 11, 1988 no Senate vote
  Fernandez, Ferdinand F. (1) Ninth Circuit September 16, 1988 no Senate vote

 

George H.W. Bush (1989-1993)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
101st (1989-1991) Walker, Vaughn R. (1) Northern District of California February 28, 1989 no Senate vote
  Ryskamp, Kenneth L. Eleventh Circuit April 26, 1990 no Senate vote
  Wanger, Oliver W. (1) Eastern District of California September 21, 1990 no Senate vote
  McGregor, James R. Western District of Pennsylvania October 15, 1990 no Senate vote
102nd (1991-1993) McGregor, James R. Western District of Pennsylvania January 8, 1991 no Senate vote
  Ryskamp, Kenneth L. Eleventh Circuit January 8, 1991 no Senate vote
  Kavanagh, Edmund A.M. Northern District of New York July 25, 1991 no Senate vote
  Sholts, Thomas E. Southern District of Florida July 26, 1991 no Senate vote
  Waldman, Jay C. Third Circuit July 26, 1991 no Senate vote
  Van Antwerpen, Franklin S. Third Circuit September 11, 1991 no Senate vote
  BeVier, Lillian R. Fourth Circuit October 22, 1991 no Senate vote
  Boyle, Terrence W. Fourth Circuit October 22, 1991 no Senate vote
  Hendren, Jimm L. Eastern District of Arkansas October 24, 1991 withdrawn by president November 5, 1991
  O'Rourke, Andrew P. Southern District of New York November 12, 1991 no Senate vote
  Graham, Tony M. Northern District of Oklahoma November 14, 1991 no Senate vote
  Keating, Francis A. II Tenth Circuit November 14, 1991 no Senate vote
  Bea, Carlos T. Northern District of California November 20, 1991 no Senate vote
  Franklin, James B. Southern District of Georgia November 26, 1991 no Senate vote
  Trager, David G. (1) Eastern District of New York November 27, 1991 no Senate vote
  Carr, Kenneth R. Western District of Texas January 27, 1992 no Senate vote
  Fitzwater, Sidney A. Fifth Circuit January 27, 1992 no Senate vote
  Jackson, James W. Northern District of Ohio January 27, 1992 no Senate vote
  Roberts, John G., Jr. District of Columbia Circuit January 27, 1992 no Senate vote
  Smietanka, John A. Sixth Circuit January 27, 1992 no Senate vote
  Smith, Terral R. Western District of Texas January 27, 1992 no Senate vote
  Moreno, Federico A. Eleventh Circuit March 10, 1992 no Senate vote
  Anderson, Percy Central District of California March 20, 1992 no Senate vote
  Davis, Lawrence O. Eastern District of Missouri March 20, 1992 no Senate vote
  Hanen, Andrew S. Southern District of Texas March 20, 1992 no Senate vote
  Lloyd, Russell T. Southern District of Texas March 20, 1992 no Senate vote
  Shechtman, Paul L. Southern District of New York March 20, 1992 no Senate vote
  Walter, John F. Central District of California March 20, 1992 no Senate vote
  Wilson, Justin P. Sixth Circuit March 20, 1992 no Senate vote
  Voigts, Gene E. Western District of Missouri March 24, 1992 no Senate vote
  Quintana, Manuel H. Southern District of New York March 26, 1992 no Senate vote
  Banks, Charles A. Eastern District of Arkansas April 1, 1992 no Senate vote
  Hunter, Robert D. Northern District of Alabama April 2, 1992 no Senate vote
  Mahoney, Maureen E. Eastern District of Virginia April 2, 1992 no Senate vote
  Mitchell, James S. District of Nebraska April 7, 1992 no Senate vote
  Leighton, Ronald B. Western District of Washington April 30, 1992 no Senate vote
  McIntyre, James A. Southern District of California June 2, 1992 no Senate vote
  Quarles, William D., Jr. District of Maryland June 2, 1992 no Senate vote
  Davis, Leonard E. Eastern District of Texas June 3, 1992 no Senate vote
  Drushal, J. Douglas Northern District of Ohio June 3, 1992 no Senate vote
  Hagy, C. Christopher Northern District of Georgia June 3, 1992 no Senate vote
  Leonatti, Louis J. Eastern District of Missouri June 3, 1992 no Senate vote
  Armentrout, Katharine J. District of Maryland June 23, 1992 no Senate vote
  McMonagle, James J. Northern District of Ohio June 23, 1992 no Senate vote
  Casey, Richard C. Southern District of New York July 2, 1992 no Senate vote
  Hicks, Larry R. District of Nevada July 2, 1992 no Senate vote
  Campbell, R. Edgar Middle District of Georgia July 27, 1992 no Senate vote
  Seybert, Joanna (1) Eastern District of New York July 27, 1992 no Senate vote
  Kostelka, Robert W. Western District of Louisiana August 7, 1992 no Senate vote
  Dorr, Richard E. Western District of Missouri September 9, 1992 no Senate vote
  Payne, James H. Eastern, Northern and Western Districts of Oklahoma September 17, 1992 no Senate vote
  Prince, Walter B. District of Massachusetts September 17, 1992 no Senate vote
  O'Toole, George A., Jr. District of Massachusetts September 24, 1992 no Senate vote
  Dimitrouleas, William P. Southern District of Florida October 2, 1992 no Senate vote
  Saad, Henry W. Eastern District of Michigan October 2, 1992 no Senate vote

 

William J. Clinton (1993-2001)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
103rd (1993-1995) Klein, Theodore Southern District of Florida October 29, 1993 no Senate vote
  Paz, R. Samuel Central District of California March 24, 1994 no Senate vote
  Dennis, James L. (1) Fifth Circuit June 8, 1994 no Senate vote
  McConnell, Judith D. Southern District of California August 5, 1994 no Senate vote
  Tait, John R. District of Idaho August 25, 1994 no Senate vote
  Chesney, Maxine M. (1) Northern District of California September 14, 1994 no Senate vote
  Moore, Karen N. (1) Sixth Circuit September 14, 1994 no Senate vote
  Stein, Sidney H. (1) Southern District of New York September 14, 1994 no Senate vote
  Lynch, Sandra L. (1) First Circuit September 19, 1994 no Senate vote
  Snodgrass, John D. Northern District of Alabama September 22, 1994 no Senate vote
  Toole, Patrick J., Jr. Middle District of Pennsylvania September 23, 1994 no Senate vote
  Folsom, David (1) Eastern District of Texas October 5, 1994 no Senate vote
  Heartfield, Thad (1) Eastern District of Texas October 5, 1994 no Senate vote
  Thornburg, Lacy (1) Western District of North Carolina October 5, 1994 no Senate vote
104th (1995-1997) Snodgrass, John D. Northern District of Alabama January 11, 1995 withdrawn by president September 5, 1995
  Whitfield, Wenona Y. Southern District of Illinois March 23, 1995 no Senate vote
  Shurin, Leland M. Western District of Missouri April 4, 1995 withdrawn by president September 5, 1995
  Fletcher, William A. (1) Ninth Circuit April 25, 1995 no Senate vote
  Bingler, John H., Jr. Western District of Pennsylvania July 21, 1995 no Senate vote
  Greer, Bruce W. Southern District of Florida August 1, 1995 withdrawn by president May 13, 1996
  Tagle, Hilda G. (1) Southern District of Texas August 10, 1995 no Senate vote
  Garland, Merrick B. (1) District of Columbia Circuit September 5, 1995 no Senate vote
  Sundram, Clarence J. Northern District of New York September 29, 1995 no Senate vote
  Myerscough, Sue E. Central District of Illinois October 11, 1995 no Senate vote
  Stack, Charles R. Eleventh Circuit October 27, 1995 withdrawn by president May 13, 1996
  Aiken, Ann L. (1) District of Oregon November 27, 1995 no Senate vote
  Hochberg, Faith S. District of New Jersey November 27, 1995 no Senate vote
  Wattley, Cheryl B. Northern District of Texas December 12, 1995 no Senate vote
  Schattman, Michael D. Northern District of Texas December 19, 1995 no Senate vote
  Mollway, Susan O. (1) District of Hawaii December 21, 1995 no Senate vote
  Beaty, James A., Jr. Fourth Circuit December 22, 1995 no Senate vote
  Leonard, J. Rich Fourth Circuit December 22, 1995 no Senate vote
  Paez, Richard A. (1) Ninth Circuit January 25, 1996 no Senate vote
  Rodriguez Rodriguez, Anabelle District of Puerto Rico January 26, 1996 no Senate vote
  Bataillon, Joseph F. (1) District of Nebraska March 6, 1996 no Senate vote
  Clay, Eric L. (1) Sixth Circuit March 6, 1996 no Senate vote
  Kollar-Kotelly, Colleen (1) District of the District of Columbia March 29, 1996 no Senate vote
  McKeown, M. Margaret (1) Ninth Circuit March 29, 1996 no Senate vote
  Gajarsa, Arthur (1) Federal Circuit April 18, 1996 no Senate vote
  Lazzara, Richard A. (1) Middle District of Florida May 9, 1996 no Senate vote
  Morrow, Margaret M. (1) Central District of California May 9, 1996 no Senate vote
  Snyder, Christina A. (1) Central District of California May 15, 1996 no Senate vote
  Thrash, Thomas W., Jr. (1) Northern District of Georgia May 15, 1996 no Senate vote
  Miller, Jeffrey T. (1) Southern District of California July 19, 1996 no Senate vote
  Pratt, Robert W. (1) Southern District of Iowa August 2, 1996 no Senate vote
  Middlebrooks, Donald M. (1) Southern District of Florida September 5, 1996 no Senate vote
105th (1997-1999) Beaty, James A., Jr. Fourth Circuit January 7, 1997 no Senate vote
  Paez, Richard A. (1) Ninth Circuit January 7, 1997 no Senate vote
  Sundram, Clarence J. Northern District of New York January 7, 1997 no Senate vote
  White, Helene N. Sixth Circuit January 7, 1997 no Senate vote
  Lasry, Lynn R. Southern District of California February 12, 1997 withdrawn by president February 12, 1998
  Rodriguez Rodriguez, Anabelle District of Puerto Rico March 21, 1997 no Senate vote
  Schattman, Michael D. Northern District of Texas March 21, 1997 withdrawn by president July 31, 1998
  White, Ronnie L. Eastern District of Missouri June 26, 1997 no Senate vote
  Ware, James S. Ninth Circuit June 27, 1997 withdrawn by president November 7, 1997
  Rangel, Jorge C. Fifth Circuit July 24, 1997 no Senate vote
  Bingler, John H., Jr. Western District of Pennsylvania July 31, 1997 withdrawn by president February 12, 1998
  Colman, Jeffrey D. Northern District of Illinois July 31, 1997 no Senate vote
  Massiah-Jackson, Frederica A. Eastern District of Pennsylvania July 31, 1997 withdrawn by president March 16, 1998
  Gould, Ronald M. (1) Ninth Circuit November 8, 1997 no Senate vote
  Berzon, Marsha L. (1) Ninth Circuit January 27, 1998 no Senate vote
  Klein, James W. District of the District of Columbia January 27, 1998 no Senate vote
  Dyk, Timothy B. (1) Federal Circuit April 1, 1998 no Senate vote
  Freedberg, Robert A. Eastern District of Pennsylvania April 23, 1998 no Senate vote
  Norton, Lynette Western District of Pennsylvania April 29, 1998 no Senate vote
  Stark, Jeffrey G. Court of International Trade April 29, 1998 no Senate vote
  Phillips, Virginia A. (1) Central District of California May 11, 1998 no Senate vote
  Raymar, Robert S. Third Circuit June 5, 1998 no Senate vote
  Goode, Barry P. Ninth Circuit June 24, 1998 no Senate vote
  Davis, Legrome D. (1) Eastern District of Pennsylvania July 30, 1998 no Senate vote
  Hibbler, William J. (1) Northern District of Illinois September 16, 1998 no Senate vote
  Kennelly, Matthew F. (1) Northern District of Illinois September 16, 1998 no Senate vote
106th (1999-2001) Davis, Legrome D. (1) Eastern District of Pennsylvania January 26, 1999 no Senate vote
  Durham, Barbara Ninth Circuit January 26, 1999 no Senate vote
  Goode, Barry P. Ninth Circuit January 26, 1999 no Senate vote
  Norton, Lynette Western District of Pennsylvania January 26, 1999 no Senate vote
  White, Helene N. Sixth Circuit January 26, 1999 no Senate vote
  White, Ronnie L. Eastern District of Missouri January 26, 1999 rejected by Senate October 5, 1999
  Leonard, J. Rich Eastern District of North Carolina March 24, 1999 no Senate vote
  Klein, James W. District of the District of Columbia March 25, 1999 no Senate vote
  Johnson, H. Alston III Fifth Circuit April 22, 1999 no Senate vote
  McCarthy, Frank H. Northern District of Oklahoma April 30, 1999 no Senate vote
  Coan, Patricia A. District of Colorado May 27, 1999 no Senate vote
  Gee, Dolly M. Central District of California May 27, 1999 no Senate vote
  Woocher, Fredric D. Central District of California May 27, 1999 no Senate vote
  Duffy, James E., Jr. Ninth Circuit June 17, 1999 no Senate vote
  Kagan, Elena District of Columbia Circuit June 17, 1999 no Senate vote
  Tusan, Gail S. Northern District of Georgia August 3, 1999 withdrawn by president March 27, 2000
  Bell, Steven D. Northern District of Ohio August 5, 1999 no Senate vote
  Wynn, James A., Jr. (1) Fourth Circuit August 5, 1999 no Senate vote
  Lewis, Kathleen M. Sixth Circuit September 16, 1999 no Senate vote
  Moreno, Enrique Fifth Circuit September 16, 1999 no Senate vote
  Lyons, James M. Tenth Circuit September 22, 1999 withdrawn by president June 6, 2000
  Snyder, Allen R. District of Columbia Circuit September 22, 1999 no Senate vote
  Fields, Rhonda C. District of the District of Columbia November 17, 1999 no Senate vote
  Cindrich, Robert J. Third Circuit February 9, 2000 no Senate vote
  Markus, Kent R. Sixth Circuit February 9, 2000 no Senate vote
  Campbell, Bonnie J. Eighth Circuit March 2, 2000 no Senate vote
  Fineman, S. David Eastern District of Pennsylvania March 9, 2000 no Senate vote
  Riegle, Linda B. District of Nevada April 25, 2000 no Senate vote
  Morado, Ricardo Southern District of Texas May 11, 2000 no Senate vote
  Orlofsky, Stephen M. Third Circuit May 25, 2000 no Senate vote
  Sebelius, K. Gary District of Kansas June 6, 2000 no Senate vote
  Simon, Kenneth O. Northern District of Alabama June 6, 2000 no Senate vote
  Lim, John S.W. District of Hawaii June 8, 2000 no Senate vote
  Gregory, Roger L. (1), (2) Fourth Circuit June 30, 2000 no Senate vote
  Arguello, Christine M. Tenth Circuit July 27, 2000 no Senate vote
  Cercone, David S. Western District of Pennsylvania July 27, 2000 no Senate vote
  Litman, Harry P. Western District of Pennsylvania July 27, 2000 no Senate vote
  Couch, Valerie K. Western District of Oklahoma September 7, 2000 no Senate vote
  Johnston, Marian M. Eastern District of Oklahoma September 7, 2000 no Senate vote
  Achelpohl, Steven E. District of Nebraska September 12, 2000 no Senate vote
  Anderson, Richard W. District of Montana September 13, 2000 no Senate vote
  Lieberman, Stephen B. Eastern District of Pennsylvania September 14, 2000 no Senate vote
  Hall, Melvin C. Western District of Oklahoma October 3, 2000 no Senate vote
  Davis, Andre M. (1) Fourth Circuit October 6, 2000 no Senate vote
  Gibson, S. Elizabeth Fourth Circuit October 26, 2000 no Senate vote
107th (2001-2003) Campbell, Bonnie J. Eighth Circuit January 3, 2001 withdrawn by president March 19, 2001
  Duffy, James E., Jr. Ninth Circuit January 3, 2001 withdrawn by president March 19, 2001
  Goode, Barry P. Ninth Circuit January 3, 2001 withdrawn by president March 19, 2001
  Gregory, Roger L. (1), (2) Fourth Circuit January 3, 2001 withdrawn by president March 19, 2001
  Lewis, Kathleen M. Sixth Circuit January 3, 2001 withdrawn by president March 19, 2001
  Moreno, Enrique Fifth Circuit January 3, 2001 withdrawn by president March 19, 2001
  White, Helene N. Sixth Circuit January 3, 2001 withdrawn by president March 19, 2001
  Wynn, James A., Jr. (1) Fourth Circuit January 3, 2001 withdrawn by president March 19, 2001
  Johnson, H. Alston III Fifth Circuit January 4, 2001 withdrawn by president March 19, 2001

 

George W. Bush (2001-2009)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
107th (2001-2003) Boyle, Terrence W. Fourth Circuit May 9, 2001 no Senate vote
  Clement, Edith B. (1) Fifth Circuit May 9, 2001 no Senate vote
  Cook, Deborah L. (1) Sixth Circuit May 9, 2001 no Senate vote
  Estrada, Miguel A. District of Columbia Circuit May 9, 2001 no Senate vote
  McConnell, Michael W. (1) Tenth Circuit May 9, 2001 no Senate vote
  Owen, Priscilla R. (1) Fifth Circuit May 9, 2001 no Senate vote
  Parker, Barrington D., Jr. (1) Second Circuit May 9, 2001 no Senate vote
  Roberts, John G., Jr. (1) District of Columbia Circuit May 9, 2001 no Senate vote
  Shedd, Dennis (1) Fourth Circuit May 9, 2001 no Senate vote
  Sutton, Jeffrey S. (1) Sixth Circuit May 9, 2001 no Senate vote
  Prost, Sharon (1) Federal Circuit May 21, 2001 no Senate vote
  Smith, Lavenski R. (1) Eighth Circuit May 22, 2001 no Senate vote
  Pickering, Charles W., Sr. (2) Fifth Circuit May 25, 2001 no Senate vote
  Tymkovich, Timothy M. (1) Tenth Circuit May 25, 2001 no Senate vote
  Wooten, Terry L. (1) District of South Carolina June 18, 2001 no Senate vote
  Smith Camp, Laurie (1) District of Nebraska June 19, 2001 no Senate vote
  Cassell, Paul G. (1) District of Utah June 19, 2001 no Senate vote
  Bates, John D. (1) District of the District of Columbia June 20, 2001 no Senate vote
  Walton, Reggie B. (1) District of the District of Columbia June 20, 2001 no Senate vote
  Hartz, Harris L. (1) Tenth Circuit June 21, 2001 no Senate vote
  Clifton, Richard R. (1) Ninth Circuit June 22, 2001 no Senate vote
  Kuhl, Carolyn B. Ninth Circuit June 22, 2001 no Senate vote
  Gritzner, James E. (1) Southern District of Iowa July 10, 2001 no Senate vote
  Melloy, Michael J. (1) Eighth Circuit July 10, 2001 no Senate vote
  Mills, Michael P. (1) Northern District of Mississippi July 10, 2001 no Senate vote
  Armijo, M. Christina (1) District of New Mexico August 2, 2001 no Senate vote
  Bowdre, Karon O. (1) Northern District of Alabama August 2, 2001 no Senate vote
  Bunning, David L. (1) Eastern District of Kentucky August 2, 2001 no Senate vote
  Caldwell, Karen K. (1) Eastern District of Kentucky August 2, 2001 no Senate vote
  Eagan, Claire V. (1) Northern District of Oklahoma August 2, 2001 no Senate vote
  Engelhardt, Kurt D. (1) Eastern District of Louisiana August 2, 2001 no Senate vote
  Friot, Stephen P. (1) Western District of Oklahoma August 2, 2001 no Senate vote
  Granade, Callie V. (1) Southern District of Alabama August 2, 2001 no Senate vote
  Heaton, Joe L. (1) Western District of Oklahoma August 2, 2001 no Senate vote
  Hicks, Larry R. (1) District of Nevada August 2, 2001 no Senate vote
  Howard, Jeffrey R. (1) First Circuit August 2, 2001 no Senate vote
  Johnson, William P. (1) District of New Mexico August 2, 2001 no Senate vote
  O'Brien, Terrence L. (1) Tenth Circuit August 2, 2001 no Senate vote
  Payne, James H. (1) Eastern, Northern and Western Districts of Oklahoma August 2, 2001 no Senate vote
  Reeves, Danny C. (1) Eastern District of Kentucky August 2, 2001 no Senate vote
  Boyle, Terrence W. Fourth Circuit September 4, 2001 no Senate vote
  Cook, Deborah L. (1) Sixth Circuit September 4, 2001 no Senate vote
  Estrada, Miguel A. District of Columbia Circuit September 4, 2001 no Senate vote
  Kuhl, Carolyn B. Ninth Circuit September 4, 2001 no Senate vote
  Owen, Priscilla R. (1) Fifth Circuit September 4, 2001 no Senate vote
  Pickering, Charles W., Sr. (2) Fifth Circuit September 4, 2001 no Senate vote
  Roberts, John G., Jr. (1) District of Columbia Circuit September 4, 2001 no Senate vote
  Sutton, Jeffrey S. (1) Sixth Circuit September 4, 2001 no Senate vote
  Tymkovich, Timothy M. (1) Tenth Circuit September 4, 2001 no Senate vote
  Steele, William H. Eleventh Circuit October 9, 2001 no Senate vote
  McKeague, David W. (1) Sixth Circuit November 8, 2001 no Senate vote
  Neilson, Susan B. (1) Sixth Circuit November 8, 2001 no Senate vote
  Saad, Henry W. Sixth Circuit November 8, 2001 no Senate vote
  Stanceu, Timothy C. (1) Court of International Trade December 19, 2001 no Senate vote
  Rohlfing, Frederick W. III District of Hawaii January 23, 2002 no Senate vote
  Bybee, Jay S. (1) Ninth Circuit May 22, 2002 no Senate vote
  Dever, James C. III (1) Eastern District of North Carolina May 22, 2002 no Senate vote
  Griffin, Richard A. (1) Sixth Circuit June 26, 2002 no Senate vote
  Junell, Robert A. (1) Western District of Texas July 18, 2002 no Senate vote
  Otero, S. James (1) Central District of California July 18, 2002 no Senate vote
  Feuerstein, Sandra J. (1) Eastern District of New York July 25, 2002 no Senate vote
  Frost, Gregory L. (1) Southern District of Ohio August 1, 2002 no Senate vote
  Holwell, Richard J. (1) Southern District of New York August 1, 2002 no Senate vote
  Erickson, Ralph R. (1) District of North Dakota September 12, 2002 no Senate vote
  Hicks, S. Maurice, Jr. (1) Western District of Louisiana September 12, 2002 no Senate vote
  Ludington, Thomas L. (1) Eastern District of Michigan September 12, 2002 no Senate vote
  Quarles, William D., Jr. (1) District of Maryland September 12, 2002 no Senate vote
  Adams, John R. (1) Northern District of Ohio October 10, 2002 no Senate vote
  Breen, J. Daniel (1) Western District of Tennessee October 10, 2002 no Senate vote
  Carney, Cormac J. (1) Central District of California October 10, 2002 no Senate vote
  Varlan, Thomas A. (1) Eastern District of Tennessee October 10, 2002 no Senate vote
108th (2003-2005) Boyle, Terrence W. Fourth Circuit January 7, 2003 no Senate vote
  Dever, James C. III (1) Eastern District of North Carolina January 7, 2003 no Senate vote
  Estrada, Miguel A. District of Columbia Circuit January 7, 2003 withdrawn by president September 4, 2003
  Griffin, Richard A. (1) Sixth Circuit January 7, 2003 no Senate vote
  Kuhl, Carolyn B. Ninth Circuit January 7, 2003 no Senate vote
  Ludington, Thomas L. (1) Eastern District of Michigan January 7, 2003 no Senate vote
  McKeague, David W. (1) Sixth Circuit January 7, 2003 no Senate vote
  Neilson, Susan B. (1) Sixth Circuit January 7, 2003 no Senate vote
  Owen, Priscilla R. (1) Fifth Circuit January 7, 2003 no Senate vote
  Pickering, Charles W., Sr. (2) Fifth Circuit January 7, 2003 no Senate vote
  Rohlfing, Frederick W. District of Hawaii January 7, 2003 withdrawn by president May 6, 2004
  Saad, Henry W. Sixth Circuit January 7, 2003 no Senate vote
  Pryor, William H., Jr. (1), (2) Eleventh Circuit April 9, 2003 no Senate vote
  Allen, Claude A. Fourth Circuit April 28, 2003 no Senate vote
  Conrad, Robert J., Jr. (1) Western District of North Carolina April 28, 2003 no Senate vote
  Ryan, Daniel P. Eastern District of Michigan April 28, 2003 no Senate vote
  Myers, William G. III Ninth Circuit May 15, 2003 no Senate vote
  Brown, Janice R. (1) District of Columbia Circuit July 25, 2003 no Senate vote
  Kavanaugh, Brett M. (1) District of Columbia Circuit July 25, 2003 no Senate vote
  Haynes, William J. II Fourth Circuit September 29, 2003 no Senate vote
  Sheridan, Peter G. (1) District of New Jersey November 5, 2003 no Senate vote
  Allen, Claude A. Fourth Circuit January 20, 2004 no Senate vote
  Pickering, Charles W., Sr. (2) Fifth Circuit February 6, 2004 no Senate vote
  Pryor, William H., Jr. (1), (2) Eleventh Circuit March 12, 2004 no Senate vote
  Griffith, Thomas B. (1) District of Columbia Circuit May 10, 2004 no Senate vote
  Crotty, Paul A. (1) Southern District of New York September 7, 2004 no Senate vote
  Cox, Sean F. (1) Eastern District of Michigan September 10, 2004 no Senate vote
  Seabright, J. Michael (1) District of Hawaii September 15, 2004 no Senate vote
109th (2005-2007) Boyle, Terrence W. Fourth Circuit February 14, 2005 no Senate vote
  Haynes, William J. II Fourth Circuit February 14, 2005 no Senate vote
  Kavanaugh, Brett M. (1) District of Columbia Circuit February 14, 2005 no Senate vote
  Myers, William G. III Ninth Circuit February 14, 2005 no Senate vote
  Ryan, Daniel P. Eastern District of Michigan February 14, 2005 withdrawn by president March 30, 2006
  Saad, Henry W. Sixth Circuit February 14, 2005 withdrawn by president March 27, 2006
  Roberts, John G., Jr. Supreme Court July 29, 2005 withdrawn by president September 6, 2005
  Payne, James H. Tenth Circuit September 29, 2005 withdrawn by president March 7, 2006
  Miers, Harriet E. Supreme Court October 7, 2005 withdrawn by president October 28, 2005
  Smith, N. Randy Ninth Circuit December 16, 2005 no Senate vote
  Bryant, Vanessa L. (1) District of Connecticut January 25, 2006 no Senate vote
  Wallace, Michael B. Fifth Circuit February 8, 2006 no Senate vote
  Holmes, Jerome A. Northern District of Oklahoma February 14, 2006 withdrawn by president May 4, 2006
  Gutierrez, Philip S. (1) Central District of California April 24, 2006 no Senate vote
  Fairbank, Valerie B. (1) Central District of California May 4, 2006 no Senate vote
  Howard, Marcia M. (1) Middle District of Florida June 6, 2006 no Senate vote
  Southwick, Leslie Southern District of Mississippi June 6, 2006 no Senate vote
  Frizzell, Gregory K. (1) Northern District of Oklahoma June 7, 2006 no Senate vote
  Wood, Lisa G. (1) Southern District of Georgia June 12, 2006 no Senate vote
  Bailey, John P. (1) Northern District of West Virginia June 28, 2006 no Senate vote
  Donohue, Mary O. Northern District of New York June 28, 2006 no Senate vote
  Jarvey, John A. (1) Southern District of Iowa June 28, 2006 no Senate vote
  Jonker, Robert J. (1) Western District of Michigan June 28, 2006 no Senate vote
  Kethledge, Raymond M. (1) Sixth Circuit June 28, 2006 no Senate vote
  Livingston, Debra A. (1) Second Circuit June 28, 2006 no Senate vote
  Maloney, Paul L. (1) Western District of Michigan June 28, 2006 no Senate vote
  Murphy, Stephen J. III Sixth Circuit June 28, 2006 no Senate vote
  Neff, Janet T. (1) Western District of Michigan June 28, 2006 no Senate vote
  Keisler, Peter D. District of Columbia Circuit June 29, 2006 no Senate vote
  Fischer, Nora B. (1) Western District of Pennsylvania July 13, 2006 no Senate vote
  Lioi, Sara E. (1) Northern District of Ohio July 13, 2006 no Senate vote
  Mauskopf, Roslynn R. (1) Eastern District of New York August 2, 2006 no Senate vote
  O'Grady, Liam (1) Eastern District of Virginia August 2, 2006 no Senate vote
  O'Neil, Lawrence J. (1) Eastern District of California August 2, 2006 no Senate vote
  Boyle, Terrence W. Fourth Circuit September 5, 2006 no Senate vote
  Haynes, William J. II Fourth Circuit September 5, 2006 no Senate vote
  Myers, William G. III Ninth Circuit September 5, 2006 no Senate vote
  Ozerden, Halil S. (1) Southern District of Mississippi September 5, 2006 no Senate vote
  Smith, N. Randy Ninth Circuit September 5, 2006 no Senate vote
  Wallace, Michael B. Fifth Circuit September 5, 2006 no Senate vote
  Wright, Otis D. III (1) Central District of California September 5, 2006 no Senate vote
  Wu, George H. (1) Central District of California September 5, 2006 no Senate vote
  Hardiman, Thomas M. (1) Third Circuit September 13, 2006 no Senate vote
  Osteen, William L., Jr. (1) Middle District of North Carolina September 29, 2006 no Senate vote
  Reidinger, Martin K. (1) Western District of North Carolina September 29, 2006 no Senate vote
  Schroeder, Thomas D. (1) Middle District of North Carolina September 29, 2006 no Senate vote
  Boyle, Terrence W. Fourth Circuit November 15, 2006 no Senate vote
  Haynes, William J. II Fourth Circuit November 15, 2006 no Senate vote
  Keisler, Peter D. District of Columbia Circuit November 15, 2006 no Senate vote
  Myers, William G. III Ninth Circuit November 15, 2006 no Senate vote
  Rogan, James E. Central District of California November 15, 2006 no Senate vote
  Settle, Benjamin H. (1) Western District of Washington November 15, 2006 no Senate vote
  Smith, N. Randy Ninth Circuit November 15, 2006 no Senate vote
  Wallace, Michael B. Fifth Circuit November 15, 2006 no Senate vote
  Kapala, Frederick J. (1) Northern District of Illinois December 5, 2006 no Senate vote
  Farr, Thomas A. Eastern District of North Carolina December 7, 2006 no Senate vote
110th (2007-2009) Donohue, Mary O. Northern District of New York January 9, 2007 withdrawn by president September 6, 2007
  Farr, Thomas A. Eastern District of North Carolina January 9, 2007 no Senate vote
  Keisler, Peter D. District of Columbia Circuit January 9, 2007 no Senate vote
  Rogan, James E. Central District of California January 9, 2007 no Senate vote
  Smith, N. Randy Ninth Circuit January 9, 2007 withdrawn by president January 16, 2007
  Dugas, David R. Middle District of Louisiana March 19, 2007 no Senate vote
  Honaker, Richard H. District of Wyoming March 19, 2007 no Senate vote
  Murphy, Stephen J. III Sixth Circuit March 19, 2007 withdrawn by president April 15, 2008
  Powell, William J. Northern District of West Virginia May 24, 2007 no Senate vote
  Puryear, Gustavus A. IV Middle District of Tennessee June 13, 2007 no Senate vote
  Conrad, Robert J., Jr. Fourth Circuit July 17, 2007 no Senate vote
  Stone, Shalom D. Third Circuit July 17, 2007 no Senate vote
  Getchell, E. Duncan Fourth Circuit September 6, 2007 withdrawn by president January 23, 2008
  Matthews, Steve A. Fourth Circuit September 6, 2007 no Senate vote
  Almond, Lincoln D. District of Rhode Island November 15, 2007 no Senate vote
  Novak, David J. Eastern District of Virginia November 15, 2007 no Senate vote
  Pratter, Gene E.K. Third Circuit November 15, 2007 withdrawn by president July 24, 2008
  Rosenstein, Rod J. Fourth Circuit November 15, 2007 no Senate vote
  Short, Carolyn P. Eastern District of Pennsylvania November 15, 2007 withdrawn by president July 24, 2008
  Smith, William E. First Circuit December 6, 2007 no Senate vote
  Connolly, Colm F. District of Delaware February 26, 2008 no Senate vote
  Conrad, Glen E. Fourth Circuit May 8, 2008 no Senate vote
  O'Neill, Michael District of the District of Columbia June 19, 2008 no Senate vote
  Rosen, Jeffrey A. District of the District of Columbia June 19, 2008 no Senate vote
  Goldberg, Gregory E. District of Colorado July 10, 2008 no Senate vote
  Jung, William F. Middle District of Florida July 10, 2008 no Senate vote
  Dugan, Timothy G. Eastern District of Wisconsin July 15, 2008 no Senate vote
  Hernandez, Marco A. (1) District of Oregon July 23, 2008 no Senate vote
  Diamond, Paul S. Third Circuit July 24, 2008 no Senate vote
  Short, Carolyn P. Eastern District of Pennsylvania July 24, 2008 no Senate vote
  Barry, J. Richard Southern District of Mississippi July 31, 2008 no Senate vote
  Marcelle, Thomas Northern District of New York July 31, 2008 no Senate vote
  Tharp, John J., Jr. Northern District of Illinois July 31, 2008 no Senate vote
  Davis, J. Mac District of Wisconsin September 9, 2008 no Senate vote
  Preska, Loretta A. Second Circuit September 9, 2008 no Senate vote
  Simon, Philip P. Seventh Circuit September 26, 2008 no Senate vote

 

Barack Obama (2009-2017)
Congress
Nominee
Court
Nomination Date
Outcome
111th (2009-2011) Chen, Edward M. (1) Northern District of California August 6, 2009 no Senate vote
  Butler, Louis B., Jr. Western District of Wisconsin September 30, 2009 no Senate vote
  Butler, Louis B., Jr. Western District of Wisconsin January 20, 2010 no Senate vote
  Chen, Edward M. (1) Northern District of California January 20, 2010 no Senate vote
  Chatigny, Robert N. Second Circuit February 24, 2010 no Senate vote
  Liu, Goodwin Ninth Circuit February 24, 2010 no Senate vote
  McConnell, John J., Jr. (1) District of Rhode Island March 10, 2010 no Senate vote
  Totenberg, Amy M. (1) Northern District of Georgia March 17, 2010 no Senate vote
  DuMont, Edward C. Federal Circuit April 14, 2010 no Senate vote
  Holmes, Paul K. III (1) Western District of Arkansas April 28, 2010 no Senate vote
  Battaglia, Anthony J. (1) Southern District of California May 20, 2010 no Senate vote
  Carney, Susan L. (1) Second Circuit May 20, 2010 no Senate vote
  Davila, Edward J. (1) Northern District of California May 20, 2010 no Senate vote
  Cogburn, Max O., Jr. (1) Western District of North Carolina May 27, 2010 no Senate vote
  Shadid, James E. (1) Central District of Illinois May 27, 2010 no Senate vote
  Graves, James E., Jr. (1) Fifth Circuit June 10, 2010 no Senate vote
  Boasberg, James E. (1) District of the District of Columbia June 17, 2010 no Senate vote
  Jackson, Amy B. (1) District of the District of Columbia June 17, 2010 no Senate vote
  Myerscough, Sue E. Central District of Illinois June 17, 2010 withdrawn by president July 14, 2010
  Hernandez, Marco A. (1) District of Oregon July 14, 2010 no Senate vote
  Jones, Steve C. (1) Northern District of Georgia July 14, 2010 no Senate vote
  Myerscough, Sue E. (1) Central District of Illinois July 14, 2010 no Senate vote
  Nourse, Victoria F. Seventh Circuit July 14, 2010 no Senate vote
  Saldana, Diana (1) Southern District of Texas July 14, 2010 no Senate vote
  Simon, Michael H. (1) District of Oregon July 14, 2010 no Senate vote
  Day, Charles B. District of Maryland July 21, 2010 no Senate vote
  Williams, Kathleen M. (1) Southern District of Florida July 21, 2010 no Senate vote
  Garcia Marmolejo, Marina (1) Southern District of Texas July 28, 2010 no Senate vote
  Butler, Louis B., Jr. Western District of Wisconsin September 13, 2010 no Senate vote
  Chatigny, Robert N. Second Circuit September 13, 2010 no Senate vote
  Chen, Edward M. (1) Northern District of California September 13, 2010 no Senate vote
  Liu, Goodwin Ninth Circuit September 13, 2010 no Senate vote
  McConnell, John J., Jr. (1) District of Rhode Island September 13, 2010 no Senate vote
  D'Agostino, Mae A. (1) Northern District of New York September 29, 2010 no Senate vote
  Halligan, Caitlin J. District of Columbia Circuit September 29, 2010 no Senate vote
  Jackson, Richard B. (1) District of Colorado September 29, 2010 no Senate vote
  Reyna, Jimmie V. (1) Federal Circuit September 29, 2010 no Senate vote
  Bissoon, Cathy (1) Western District of Pennsylvania November 17, 2010 no Senate vote
  Briccetti, Vincent L. (1) Southern District of New York November 17, 2010 no Senate vote
  Dalton, Roy B., Jr. (1) Middle District of Florida November 17, 2010 no Senate vote
  Darrow, Sara L. (1) Central District of Illinois November 17, 2010 no Senate vote
  Kronstadt, John A. (1) Central District of California November 17, 2010 no Senate vote
  Sharp, Kevin H. (1) Middle District of Tennessee November 17, 2010 no Senate vote
  Allen, Arenda L.W. (1) Eastern District of Virginia December 1, 2010 no Senate vote
  Cecchi, Claire C. (1) District of New Jersey December 1, 2010 no Senate vote
  Donald, Bernice B. (1) Sixth Circuit December 1, 2010 no Senate vote
  Hornak, Mark R. (1) Western District of Pennsylvania December 1, 2010 no Senate vote
  Mariani, Robert D. (1) Middle District of Pennsylvania December 1, 2010 no Senate vote
  Ross, John A. (1) Eastern District of Missouri December 1, 2010 no Senate vote
  Salas, Esther (1) District of New Jersey December 1, 2010 no Senate vote
  Urbanski, Michael F. (1) Western District of Virginia December 1, 2010 no Senate vote
112th (2011-2013) Butler, Louis B., Jr. Western District of Wisconsin January 5, 2011 no Senate vote
  Day, Charles B. District of Maryland January 5, 2011 withdrawn by president October 31, 2011
  DuMont, Edward C. Federal Circuit January 5, 2011 withdrawn by president November 10, 2011
  Halligan, Caitlin J. District of Columbia Circuit January 5, 2011 no Senate vote
  Liu, Goodwin Ninth Circuit January 5, 2011 withdrawn by president July 29, 2011
  Nourse, Victoria F. Seventh Circuit January 5, 2011 no Senate vote
  Green, Michael C. Western District of New York January 26, 2011 no Senate vote
  Silas, Natasha P. Northern District of Georgia January 26, 2011 no Senate vote
  Walker, Linda T. Northern District of Georgia January 26, 2011 no Senate vote
  Mikkanen, Arvo Northern District of Oklahoma February 2, 2011 no Senate vote
  Six, Steve Tenth Circuit March 9, 2011 no Senate vote
  Marquez, Rosemary (1) District of Arizona June 23, 2011 no Senate vote
  Shwartz, Patty (1) Third Circuit October 5, 2011 no Senate vote
  Taranto, Richard G. (1) Federal Circuit November 10, 2011 no Senate vote
  Bacharach, Robert E. (1) Tenth Circuit January 23, 2012 no Senate vote
  Kayatta, William J., Jr. (1) First Circuit January 23, 2012 no Senate vote
  Cadish, Elissa F. District of Nevada February 16, 2012 no Senate vote
  Pryor, Jill A. (1) Eleventh Circuit February 16, 2012 no Senate vote
  Davis, Brian J. (1) Middle District of Florida February 29, 2012 no Senate vote
  Dick, Shelly D. (1) Middle District of Louisiana April 25, 2012 no Senate vote
  Halligan, Caitlin J. District of Columbia Circuit June 11, 2012 no Senate vote
  Orrick, William H. III (1) Northern District of California June 11, 2012 no Senate vote
  Srinivasan, Srikanth (1) District of Columbia Circuit June 11, 2012 no Senate vote
  Chappell, Sheri P. (1) Middle District of Florida June 25, 2012 no Senate vote
  Failla, Katherine P. (1) Southern District of New York June 25, 2012 no Senate vote
  Nunley, Troy L. (1) Eastern District of California June 25, 2012 no Senate vote
  Barnett, Mark A. (1) Court of International Trade July 12, 2012 no Senate vote
  Chen, Pamela K.M. (1) Eastern District of New York August 2, 2012 no Senate vote
  Dorsey, Jennifer A. (1) District of Nevada September 19, 2012 no Senate vote
  Gordon, Andrew P. (1) District of Nevada September 19, 2012 no Senate vote
  Halligan, Caitlin J. District of Columbia Circuit September 19, 2012 no Senate vote
  McShane, Michael J. (1) District of Oregon September 19, 2012 no Senate vote
  Jackson, Ketanji B. (1) District of the District of Columbia September 20, 2012 no Senate vote
  Roman, Nelson S. (1) Southern District of New York September 20, 2012 no Senate vote
  Caproni, Valerie E. (1) Southern District of New York November 14, 2012 no Senate vote
  Gonzales, Kenneth J. (1) District of New Mexico November 14, 2012 no Senate vote
  Kelly, Claire R. (1) Court of International Trade November 14, 2012 no Senate vote
  Moore, Raymond P. (1) District of Colorado November 14, 2012 no Senate vote
  O'Connell, Beverly R. (1) Central District of California November 14, 2012 no Senate vote
  Thomas, William L. Southern District of Florida November 14, 2012 no Senate vote
  Torres, Analisa (1) Southern District of New York November 14, 2012 no Senate vote
  Watson, Derrick K. (1) District of Hawaii November 14, 2012 no Senate vote
  Quinones Alejandro, Nitza I. (1) Eastern District of Pennsylvania November 27, 2012 no Senate vote
  Restrepo, Luis F. (1) Eastern District of Pennsylvania November 27, 2012 no Senate vote
  Schmehl, Jeffrey L. (1) Eastern District of Pennsylvania November 27, 2012 no Senate vote
113th (2013-2015) Cadish, Elissa F. District of Nevada January 4, 2013 withdrawn by president March 13, 2013
  Halligan, Caitlin J. District of Columbia Circuit January 4, 2013 withdrawn by president March 22, 2013
  Marquez, Rosemary (1) District of Arizona January 4, 2013 no Senate vote
  Pryor, Jill A. (1) Eleventh Circuit January 4, 2013 no Senate vote
  Thomas, William L. Southern District of Florida January 4, 2013 no Senate vote
  McHugh, Carolyn B. (1) Tenth Circuit May 16, 2013 no Senate vote
  Reeves, Pamela L. (1) Eastern District of Tennessee May 16, 2013 no Senate vote
  Brooks, Timothy L. (1) Western District of Arkansas June 7, 2013 no Senate vote
  Meyer, Jeffrey A. (1) District of Connecticut June 7, 2013 no Senate vote
  Donato, James (1) Northern District of California June 20, 2013 no Senate vote
  Freeman, Beth L. (1) Northern District of California June 20, 2013 no Senate vote
  May-Parker, Jennifer P. Eastern District of North Carolina June 20, 2013 no Senate vote
  Delgado Hernandez, Pedro A. (1) District of Puerto Rico June 26, 2013 no Senate vote
  Hendricks, Bruce H. (1) District of South Carolina June 26, 2013 no Senate vote
  Lee, Alison R. District of South Carolina June 26, 2013 no Senate vote
  Chhabria, Vince G. (1) Northern District of California July 25, 2013 no Senate vote
  Leitman, Matthew F. (1) Eastern District of Michigan July 25, 2013 no Senate vote
  Levy, Judith E. (1) Eastern District of Michigan July 25, 2013 no Senate vote
  Michelson, Laurie J. (1) Eastern District of Michigan July 25, 2013 no Senate vote
  Moody, James M., Jr. (1) Eastern District of Arkansas July 25, 2013 no Senate vote
  Parker, Linda V. (1) Eastern District of Michigan July 25, 2013 no Senate vote
  Cooper, Christopher R. (1) District of the District of Columbia August 1, 2013 no Senate vote
  Crabtree, Daniel D. (1) District of Kansas August 1, 2013 no Senate vote
  Friedland, Michelle T. (1) Ninth Circuit August 1, 2013 no Senate vote
  Harpool, M. Douglas (1) Western District of Missouri August 1, 2013 no Senate vote
  Lipman, Sheryl H. (1) Western District of Tennessee August 1, 2013 no Senate vote
  McHugh, Gerald A., Jr. (1) Eastern District of Pennsylvania August 1, 2013 no Senate vote
  Moritz, Nancy L. (1) Tenth Circuit August 1, 2013 no Senate vote
  Owens, John B. (1) Ninth Circuit August 1, 2013 no Senate vote
  Smith, Edward G. (1) Eastern District of Pennsylvania August 1, 2013 no Senate vote
  Bashant, Cynthia A. (1) Southern District of California September 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  Bastian, Stanley A. (1) Eastern District of Washington September 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  Humetewa, Diane J. (1) District of Arizona September 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  Levy, Jon D. (1) District of Maine September 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  Logan, Steven P. (1) District of Arizona September 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  Rayes, Douglas L. (1) District of Arizona September 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  Shah, Manish S. (1) Northern District of Illinois September 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  Tuchi, John J. (1) District of Arizona September 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  Barron, David J. (1) First Circuit September 24, 2013 no Senate vote
  Mastroianni, Mark G. (1) District of Massachusetts September 24, 2013 no Senate vote
  Talwani, Indira (1) District of Massachusetts September 24, 2013 no Senate vote
  Chuang, Theodore D. (1) District of Maryland September 25, 2013 no Senate vote
  Hazel, George J. (1) District of Maryland September 25, 2013 no Senate vote
  Peterson, James D. (1) Western District of Wisconsin November 7, 2013 no Senate vote
  Rosenbaum, Robin S. (1) Eleventh Circuit November 7, 2013 no Senate vote
  Rosenstengel, Nancy J. (1) Southern District of Illinois November 7, 2013 no Senate vote
  White, Ronnie L. (1) Eastern District of Missouri November 7, 2013 no Senate vote
  Boggs, Michael P. Northern District of Georgia December 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  Carnes, Julie E. (1) Eleventh Circuit December 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  Chutkan, Tanya S. (1) District of the District of Columbia December 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  Cohen, Mark H. (1) Northern District of Georgia December 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  Costa, Gregg J. (1) Fifth Circuit December 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  Lauck, M. Hannah (1) Eastern District of Virginia December 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  May, Leigh M. (1) Northern District of Georgia December 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  Ross, Eleanor L. (1) Northern District of Georgia December 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  Sorokin, Leo T. (1) District of Massachusetts December 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  Soto, James A. (1) District of Arizona December 19, 2013 no Senate vote
  Lee, Alison R. District of South Carolina January 6, 2014 withdrawn by president September 18, 2014
  Boggs, Michael P. Northern District of Georgia January 6, 2014 no Senate vote
  May-Parker, Jennifer P. Eastern District of North Carolina January 6, 2014 no Senate vote
  Davidson, Jeanne E. Court of International Trade August 18, 2014 no Senate vote
  Bennett, Alfred H. (1) Southern District of Texas September 18, 2014 no Senate vote
  Hanks, George C., Jr. (1) Southern District of Texas September 18, 2014 no Senate vote
  Olvera, Jose R., Jr. (1) Southern District of Texas September 18, 2014 no Senate vote
  Parrish, Jill N. (1) District of Utah September 18, 2014 no Senate vote
  Hall, LaShann M. D. (1) Eastern District of New York November 12, 2014 no Senate vote
  Drozd, Dale A. (1) Eastern District of California November 12, 2014 no Senate vote
  Restrepo, Luis F. (1) Third Circuit November 12, 2014 no Senate vote
  Stoll, Kara F. (1) Federal Circuit November 12, 2014 no Senate vote
  Donnelly, Ann (1) Eastern District of New York November 20, 2014 no Senate vote
  Ketchmark, Roseann A. (1) Western District of Missouri November 20, 2014 no Senate vote
  McDonough, Travis R. (1) Eastern District of Tennessee November 20, 2014 no Senate vote
114th (2015-2017) Davidson, Jeanne E. Court of International Trade January 7, 2015 no Senate vote
  Barzee Flores, Mary Southern District of Florida February 26, 2015 no Senate vote
  Neals, Julien X. District of New Jersey February 26, 2015 no Senate vote
  Stanton, Edward L. III Western District of Tennessee May 21, 2015 no Senate vote
  Young, Mark A. Central District of California July 16, 2015 no Senate vote
  Baxter, Susan P. Western District of Pennsylvania July 30, 2015 no Senate vote
  Bernstein, Inga S. District of Massachusetts July 30, 2015 no Senate vote
  Brown, Gary R. Eastern District of New York July 30, 2015 no Senate vote
  Colville, Robert J. Western District of Pennsylvania July 30, 2015 no Senate vote
  Drake, Elizabeth J. Court of International Trade July 30, 2015 no Senate vote
  Horan, Marilyn J. Western District of Pennsylvania July 30, 2015 no Senate vote
  Lopez, Dax E. Northern District of Georgia July 30, 2015 no Senate vote
  Younge, John M. Eastern District of Pennsylvania July 30, 2015 no Senate vote
  Connors, Clare E. District of Hawaii September 8, 2015 no Senate vote
  Gallagher, Stephanie A. District of Maryland September 8, 2015 no Senate vote
  McElroy, Mary S. District of Rhode Island September 8, 2015 no Senate vote
  Abrams, Paul L. Central District of California December 16, 2015 no Senate vote
  Mitchell, Suzanne Western District of Oklahoma December 16, 2015 no Senate vote
  Palk, Scott L. Western District of Oklahoma December 16, 2015 no Senate vote
  Russell, Ronald G. District of Utah December 16, 2015 no Senate vote
  Ong, Winfield D. Southern District of Indiana January 12, 2016 no Senate vote
  Schott, Donald K. Seventh Circuit January 12, 2016 no Senate vote
  Selby, Myra C. Seventh Circuit January 12, 2016 no Senate vote
  Campbell, Terrence J. District of Kansas January 28, 2016 no Senate vote
  Puhl, Jennifer K. Eighth Circuit January 28, 2016 no Senate vote
  Finley, Stephanie A. Western District of Louisiana February 4, 2016 no Senate vote
  Kelly, Claude J. III Eastern District of Louisiana February 4, 2016 no Senate vote
  Kallon, Abdul K. Eleventh Circuit February 11, 2016 no Senate vote
  Beatty, Donald W. District of South Carolina February 25, 2016 no Senate vote
  Coggins, Donald C., Jr. District of South Carolina February 25, 2016 no Senate vote
  Koh, Lucy H. Ninth Circuit February 25, 2016 no Senate vote
  Counts, Walter D. III Western District of Texas March 15, 2016 no Senate vote
  Frost, E. Scott Northern District of Texas March 15, 2016 no Senate vote
  Haywood, Rebecca R. Third Circuit March 15, 2016 no Senate vote
  Hendrix, James W. Northern District of Texas March 15, 2016 no Senate vote
  Ramirez, Irma C. Northern District of Texas March 15, 2016 no Senate vote
  Scholer, Karen G. Eastern District of Texas March 15, 2016 no Senate vote
  Sweet, Kathleen M. Western District of New York March 15, 2016 no Senate vote
  Garland, Merrick B. Supreme Court March 16, 2016 no Senate vote
  Hughes, Lisabeth T. Sixth Circuit March 17, 2016 no Senate vote
  Nye, David C. District of Idaho April 5, 2016 no Senate vote
  Andrus, Beth M. Western District of Washington April 14, 2016 no Senate vote
  Diaz, J. Michael Western District of Washington April 14, 2016 no Senate vote
  O'Sullivan, Kathleen M. Western District of Washington April 14, 2016 no Senate vote
  Barksdale, Patricia D. Middle District of Florida April 28, 2016 no Senate vote
  Edelman, Todd E. District of Columbia April 28, 2016 no Senate vote
  Jung, William F. Middle District of Florida April 28, 2016 no Senate vote
  Lammens, Philip R. Northern District of Florida April 28, 2016 no Senate vote
  Pan, Florence Y. District of Columbia April 28, 2016 no Senate vote
  Rodriguez, Regina M. District of Colorado April 28, 2016 no Senate vote
  Timmons-Goodson, Patricia A. Eastern District of North Carolina April 28, 2016 no Senate vote
  Traum, Anne R. District of Nevada April 28, 2016 no Senate vote
  Qureshi, Abid R. District of Columbia September 6, 2016 no Senate vote
  Gujarati, Diane Eastern District of New York September 13, 2016 no Senate vote