Unsuccessful Nominations and Recess Appointments

Notations:
(1) Subsequently confirmed to the same vacancy
(2) Received a recess appointment to the same vacancy

George Washington (1789-1797)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
1st (1789-1791)	Harrison, Robert H.	Supreme Court	September 24, 1789	confirmed September 26, 1789; nominee declined
	Johnson, Thomas	District of Maryland	September 24, 1789	confirmed September 26, 1789; nominee declined
	Pendleton, Edmund	District of Virginia	September 24, 1789	confirmed September 26, 1789; nominee declined
	Pinckney, Thomas	District of South Carolina	September 24, 1789	confirmed September 26, 1789; nominee declined
	Davie, William R.	District of North Carolina	June 7, 1790	confirmed June 8, 1790; nominee declined
2nd (1791-1793)	Paterson, William (1)	Supreme Court	February 27, 1793	withdrawn by president February 28, 1793
3rd (1793-1795)	Harrison, Richard	District of New York	April 16, 1794	withdrawn by president May 5, 1794
4th (1795-1797)	Rutledge, John (2)	Chief Justice, Supreme Court	December 10, 1795	rejected by Senate December 15, 1795
	Cushing, William	Chief Justice, Supreme Court	January 26, 1796	confirmed January 27, 1796; nominee declined

John Adams (1797-1801)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
6th (1799-1801)	Jay, John	Chief Justice, Supreme Court	December 18, 1800	confirmed December 19, 1800; nominee declined
	Greene, Ray	District of Rhode Island	February 18, 1801	confirmed February 20, 1801; no commission issued
	Ingersoll, Jared	Chief Judge, Third Circuit	February 18, 1801	confirmed February 20, 1801; nominee declined
	Lee, Charles	Chief Judge, Fourth Circuit	February 18, 1801	confirmed February 20, 1801; nominee declined
	Bee, Thomas	Chief Judge, Fifth Circuit	February 21, 1801	confirmed February 24, 1801; nominee declined
	Clay, Joseph, Jr.	Fifth Circuit	February 21, 1801	confirmed February 24, 1801; nominee declined
	Hill, William H.	Albemarle, Cape Fear and Pamptico Districts of North Carolina	February 21, 1801	confirmed February 24, 1801; vacancy did not occur
	Read, Jacob	District of South Carolina	February 21, 1801	confirmed February 24, 1801; vacancy did not occur
	Sitgreaves, John	Fifth Circuit	February 21, 1801	confirmed February 24, 1801; nominee declined
	Gibbons, Thomas	District of Georgia	February 24, 1801	confirmed February 25, 1801; vacancy did not occur
	Johnson, Thomas	Chief Judge, Circuit Court of the District of Columbia	February 28, 1801	confirmed March 3, 1801; nominee declined

Thomas Jefferson (1801-1809)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
7th (1801-1803)	Gaillard, Theodore	Chief Judge, Fifth Circuit	May 30, 1801 (recess appointment)	appointee declined
8th (1803-1805)	Tompkins, Daniel D.	District of New York	March 1, 1805	confirmed March 2, 1805; nominee declined
9th (1805-1807)	Livingston, Henry B.	District of New York	May 16, 1805 (recess appointment)	appointee declined

James Madison (1809-1817)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
11th (1809-1811)	Lincoln, Levi	Supreme Court	January 2, 1811	confirmed January 3, 1811; nominee declined
	Wolcott, Alexander	Supreme Court	February 4, 1811	rejected by Senate February 13, 1811
	Adams, John Quincy	Supreme Court	February 21, 1811	confirmed February 22, 1811; nominee declined
12th (1811-1813)	Parker, Thomas	District of South Carolina	March 13, 1812	confirmed March 17, 1812; nominee declined
13th (1813-1815)	Gaillard, Theodore	District of Louisiana	April 13, 1813 (recess appointment)	appointee declined
14th (1815-1817)	Parke, Benjamin (1)	District of Indiana	January 28, 1817	no Senate vote

James Monroe (1817-1825)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
17th (1821-1823)	Charlton, Thomas U.P.	District of Georgia	May 15, 1821 (recess appointment)	appointee declined

John Quincy Adams (1825-1829)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
19th (1825-1827)	Smith, Daniel	Western District of Virginia	August 27, 1825 (recess appointment)	appointee declined
	Pickens, Israel	Northern and Southern Districts of Alabama	February 17, 1826	confirmed March 9, 1826; nominee declined
20th (1827-1829)	Creighton, William, Jr. (2)	District of Ohio	December 11, 1828	no Senate vote
	Crittenden, John J.	Supreme Court	December 17, 1828	no Senate vote
	Gurley, Henry H.	Eastern and Western Districts of Louisiana	January 6, 1829	no Senate vote

Andrew Jackson (1829-1837)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
23rd (1833-1835)	Tappan, Benjamin (2)	District of Ohio	January 20, 1834	rejected by Senate May 29, 1834
	Taney, Roger B.	Supreme Court	January 15, 1835	no Senate vote
24th (1835-1837)	Smith, William	Supreme Court	March 3, 1837	confirmed March 8, 1837; nominee declined

Martin Van Buren (1837-1841)
None

William Henry Harrison (1841)
None

John Tyler (1841-1845)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
27th (1841-1843)	Ogden, Abner Nash	Eastern and Western Districts of Louisiana	July 15, 1841	confirmed July 15, 1841; nominee declined
	Crawford, Bennet A.	Eastern and Western Districts of Lousiana	October 19, 1841 (recess appointment)	appointment invalid; vacancy did not occur
	Binney, Horace	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	January 18, 1842	confirmed January 25, 1842; nominee declined
	Bradford, Thomas	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	February 5, 1842	rejected by Senate February 21, 1842
	Dewey, Charles	District of Indiana	April 4, 1842	confirmed April 6, 1842; nominee declined
28th (1843-1845)	Spencer, John C.	Supreme Court	January 8, 1844	rejected by Senate January 31, 1844
	Walworth, Reuben H.	Supreme Court	March 13, 1844	withdrawn by president June 17, 1844
	Christian, John B.	Eastern District of Virginia	April 2, 1844	rejected by Senate June 15, 1844
	King, Edward	Supreme Court	June 5, 1844	no Senate vote
	Collier, R.R.	Eastern District of Virginia	June 15, 1844	rejected by Senate June 15, 1844
	Spencer, John C.	Supreme Court	June 17, 1844	withdrawn by president June 17, 1844
	Walworth, Reuben H.	Supreme Court	June 17, 1844	no Senate vote
	King, Edward	Supreme Court	December 4, 1844	withdrawn by president February 7, 1845
	Walworth, Reuben H.	Supreme Court	December 4, 1844	withdrawn by president February 4, 1845
	Read, John M.	Supreme Court	February 7, 1845	no Senate vote

James K. Polk (1845-1849)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
29th (1845-1847)	Woodward, George W.	Supreme Court	December 23, 1845	rejected by Senate January 22, 1846

Zachary Taylor (1849-1850)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
31st (1849-1851)	Campbell, James G.	Western District of Louisiana	March 16, 1849	confirmed March 19, 1849; nominee declined
	Elgee, John K.	Western District of Louisiana	April 26, 1849 (recess appointment)	appointee declined

Millard Fillmore (1850-1853)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
31st (1849-1851)	Benjamin, Judah P.	Northern District of California	September 28, 1850	confirmed September 28, 1850; nominee declined
	Healey, John P.	Southern District of California	September 28, 1850	confirmed September 28, 1850; nominee declined
	Currey, John	Northern District of California	December 23, 1850	rejected by Senate January 25, 1851
32nd (1851-1853)	Currey, John	Southern District of California	February 26, 1852	no Senate vote
	Bradford, E.A.	Supreme Court	August 16, 1852	no Senate vote
	Badger, George E.	Supreme Court	January 3, 1853	withdrawn by president February 14, 1853
	Micou, William C.	Supreme Court	February 14, 1853	no Senate vote

Franklin Pierce (1853-1857)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
33rd (1853-1855)	Lumpkin, Joseph H.	Court of Claims	March 3, 1855	confirmed March 3, 1855; nominee declined
34th (1855-1857)	Hopkins, George W.	Chief Judge, Circuit Court of the District of Columbia	October 5, 1855 (recess appointment)	appointee declined

James Buchanan (1857-1861)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
36th (1859-1861)	Pettit, John	District of Kansas	January 31, 1861	no Senate vote
	Black, Jeremiah S.	Supreme Court	February 5, 1861	no Senate vote

Abraham Lincoln (1861-1865)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
37th (1861-1863)	Field, Stephen J.	California Circuit	February 25, 1863	no Senate vote
	Withey, Solomon L. (1)	Western District of Michigan	February 26, 1863	no Senate vote
38th (1863-1865)	Wylie, Andrew (1), (2)	Supreme Court of the District of Columbia	March 10, 1863	confirmed March 12, 1863; Senate voted to reconsider confirmation March 13, 1863; no subsequent Senate vote
	Bingham, John	Southern District of Florida	June 4, 1863 (recess appointment)	appointee declined
	Lawrence, William	Southern District of Florida	September 9, 1863 (recess appointment)	appointee declined
	Durell, Edward H. (1), (2)	Eastern District of Louisiana	January 5, 1864	returned to president by Senate vote February 3, 1864
	Thompson, Richard W.	Court of Claims	February 10, 1865	withdrawn by president February 21, 1865

Andrew Johnson (1865-1869)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
39th (1865-1867)	Dick, Robert P.	Albemarle, Cape Fear and Pamptico Districts of North Carolina	May 29, 1865 (recess appointment)	appointee declined
	Stanberry, Henry	Supreme Court	April 16, 1866	no Senate vote
40th (1867-1869)	Lockwood, William F.	District of Nebraska	March 15, 1867	rejected by Senate April 20, 1867
	Wilkinson, Ira O.	District of Nebraska	July 20, 1867	no Senate vote
	Worthington, Henry G.	District of Nebraska	January 28, 1868	withdrawn by president March 18, 1868

Ulysses Grant (1869-1877)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
41st (1869-1871)	Clarke, James M.	District of Rhode Island	September 15, 1869 (recess appointment)	appointee declined
	Pearre, George A.	Fourth Circuit	December 8, 1869	withdrawn by president April 6, 1870
	Yeaman, George H.	Sixth Circuit	December 8, 1869	withdrawn by president December 17, 1869
	Hoar, Ebenezer R.	Supreme Court	December 14, 1869	rejected by Senate February 3, 1870
	Withey, Solomon L.	Sixth Circuit	December 17, 1869	confirmed December 22, 1869; nominee declined
	Stanton, Edwin M.	Supreme Court	December 20, 1869	confirmed December 20, 1869; nominee died prior to appointment
	Gobin, John P.S.	Southern District of Florida	February 4, 1870	no Senate vote
	Appleton, John F.	Eastern District of Texas	April 26, 1870	confirmed May 16, 1870; nominee declined
	Conant, Sherman	Southern District of Florida	June 29, 1870	withdrawn by president July 7, 1870
	Oliver, John M.	Supreme Court of the District of Columbia	June 29, 1870	withdrawn by president July 14, 1870
	Hopkins, James C. (1)	Western District of Wisconsin	July 1, 1870	no Senate vote
	Winch, Joel C.C. (2)	Eastern District of Texas	December 15, 1870	no Senate vote
	Bruce, John	Eastern District of Texas	February 14, 1871	no Senate vote
42nd (1871-1873)	Gray, Bird W.	Eastern District of Texas	March 10, 1871	confirmed March 10, 1871; Senate voted to reconsider confirmation March 20, 1871; no subsequent Senate vote
	Gray, Bird W.	Eastern District of Texas	May 15, 1871	no Senate vote
	Goddard, William H.	Eastern District of Texas	December 18, 1871	withdrawn by president January 18, 1872
	Busteed, Richard	Supreme Court of the District of Columbia	January 13, 1873	returned to president by Senate vote February 13, 1873
	Humphreys, David C.	Middle, Northern and Southern Districts of Alabama	January 13, 1873	returned to president by Senate vote February 13, 1873
43rd (1873-1875)	Williams, George H.	Chief Justice, Supreme Court	December 1, 1873	withdrawn by president January 8, 1874
	Cushing, Caleb	Chief Justice, Supreme Court	January 9, 1874	withdrawn by president January 13, 1874
	Pardee, Don A.	District of Louisiana	December 14, 1874	no Senate vote
	Parsons, Lewis E.	Middle, Northern and Southern Districts of Alabama	December 18, 1874	withdrawn by president February 23, 1875
44th (1875-1877)	Pardee, Don A.	District of Louisiana	March 9, 1875	no Senate vote
	Kinsman, J. Burnham	Western District of Arkansas	March 10, 1875	withdrawn by president March 18, 1875
	Griswold, Elias	Northern District of Florida	January 11, 1877	withdrawn by president January 12, 1877
	Griswold, Elias	Northern District of Florida	January 18, 1877	withdrawn by president January 23, 1877

Rutherford B. Hayes (1877-1881)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
45th (1877-1879)	Baxter, John (1)	Sixth Circuit	October 25, 1877	no Senate vote
	Turner, Ezekiel B.	Northern District of Texas	March 1, 1879	no Senate vote
46th (1879-1881)	Turner, Ezekiel B.	Northern District of Texas	March 19, 1879	rejected by Senate April 2, 1879
	Matthews, R. Stockett	District of Maryland	April 9, 1879	withdrawn by president July 1, 1879
	McCrary, George W.	Eighth Circuit	June 3, 1879	withdrawn by president June 21, 1879
	Billings, Edward C.	Fifth Circuit	January 24, 1881	no Senate vote
	Matthews, Stanley (1)	Supreme Court	January 26, 1881	no Senate vote

James A. Garfield (1881)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
47th (1881-1883)	Phillips, Samuel F.	Court of Claims	March 23, 1881	withdrawn by president May 19, 1881

Chester A. Arthur (1881-1885)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
47th (1881-1883)	Conkling, Roscoe	Supreme Court	February 24, 1882	confirmed March 2, 1882; nominee declined
	Atkins, James	Northern District of Georgia	July 3, 1882	withdrawn by president August 3, 1882

Grover Cleveland (1885-1889)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
50th (1887-1889)	Lacombe, Emile H. (1), (2)	Second Circuit	December 20, 1887	withdrawn by president February 27, 1888
	Hartridge, John E.	Northern District of Florida	December 18, 1888	no Senate vote
	Stevenson, Adlai E.	Supreme Court of the District of Columbia	February 11, 1889	no Senate vote

Benjamin Harrison (1889-1893)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
51st (1889-1891)	Day, William R.	Northern District of Ohio	May 24, 1889 (recess appointment)	appointee declined
	Beatty, James H. (1), (2)	District of Idaho	February 10, 1891	no Senate vote
52nd (1891-1893)	Hanchett, Benton	Sixth Circuit	February 23, 1893	no Senate vote

Grover Cleveland (1893-1897)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
53rd (1893-1895)	Hornblower, William B.	Supreme Court	September 19, 1893	no Senate vote
	Hornblower, William B.	Supreme Court	December 5, 1893	rejected by Senate January 15, 1894
	Peckham, Wheeler H.	Supreme Court	January 22, 1894	rejected by Senate February 19, 1894
	Porter, James D.	Eastern and Middle Districts of Tennessee	August 6, 1894	no Senate vote
54th (1895-1897)	McHugh, William D. (2)	District of Nebraska	December 8, 1896	withdrawn by president February 1, 1897
	Wolcott, James L.	District of Delaware	February 20, 1897	no Senate vote
	Clark, William W.	Eastern District of North Carolina	February 25, 1897	no Senate vote

William McKinley (1897-1901)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
55th (1897-1899)	Ewart, Hamilton G. (2)	Western District of North Carolina	January 27, 1898	no Senate vote
	Meek, Edward R. (1), (2)	Northern District of Texas	March 10, 1898	no Senate vote
	Ewart, Hamilton G. (2)	Western District of North Carolina	December 13, 1898	no Senate vote
56th (1899-1901)	Ewart, Hamilton G. (2)	Western District of North Carolina	December 19, 1899	no Senate vote

Theodore Roosevelt (1901-1909)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
57th (1901-1903)	Holmes, Oliver W., Jr. (1)	Supreme Court	August 11, 1902 (recess appointment)	appointment cancelled by president
	Morris, Page (1)	District of Minnesota	February 19, 1903	no Senate vote
58th (1903-1905)	Quarles, Joseph V. (1)	Eastern District of Wisconsin	February 25, 1905	no Senate vote
59th (1905-1907)	Chatfield, Thomas (1)	Eastern District of New York	December 10, 1906	withdrawn by president December 17, 1906
60th (1907-1909)	Van Fleet, William C. (1), (2)	Northern District of California	March 4, 1907 (recess appointment)	appointment cancelled by president
	Hundley, Oscar R. (2)	Northern District of Alabama	December 3, 1907	no Senate vote
	Sater, John E. (1), (2)	Southern District of Ohio	December 3, 1907	no Senate vote
	Purdy, Milton D. (2)	District of Minnesota	April 23, 1908	no Senate vote
	Hundley, Oscar R. (2)	Northern District of Alabama	December 8, 1908	no Senate vote
	Purdy, Milton D. (2)	District of Minnesota	December 8, 1908	no Senate vote
	Seawell, Herbert F.	Eastern District of North Carolina	January 18, 1909	no Senate vote

William H. Taft (1909-1913)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
61st (1909-1911)	Barber, Orion M. (1)	Court of Customs Appeals	January 5, 1910	withdrawn by president February 22, 1910
	Coxe, Alfred C., Sr.	Presiding Judge, Court of Customs Appeals	January 5, 1910	withdrawn by president February 22, 1910
	De Vries, Marion (1)	Court of Customs Appeals	January 5, 1910	withdrawn by president February 22, 1910
	Hunt, William H. (1)	Court of Customs Appeals	January 5, 1910	withdrawn by president February 22, 1910
	Smith, James F. (1)	Court of Customs Appeals	January 5, 1910	withdrawn by president February 22, 1910
62nd (1911-1913)	Sloan, Richard E. (2)	District of Arizona	March 1, 1912	no Senate vote
	Cheney, John M. (2)	Southern District of Florida	July 25, 1912	no Senate vote
	Howard, Clinton W. (2)	Western District of Washington	August 19, 1912	no Senate vote
	Cheney, John M. (2)	Southern District of Florida	December 3, 1912	no Senate vote
	Howard, Clinton W. (2)	Western District of Washington	December 3, 1912	no Senate vote
	Sloan, Richard E. (2)	District of Arizona	December 3, 1912	no Senate vote
	Carpenter, George A.	Seventh Circuit	December 17, 1912	no Senate vote
	Cutting, Charles C.	Northern District of Illinois	December 17, 1912	no Senate vote
	Booth, Fenton W.	Chief Justice, Court of Claims	January 2, 1913	no Senate vote
	Boutell, Henry S.	Court of Claims	January 2, 1913	no Senate vote
	Brown, Arthur L.	First Circuit	February 10, 1913	no Senate vote
	Mumford, Charles C.	District of Rhode Island	February 10, 1913	no Senate vote
	Fisher, Samuel H.	District of Connecticut	February 20, 1913	no Senate vote

Woodrow Wilson (1913-1921)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
63rd (1913-1915)	Siddons, Frederick L. (1)	Supreme Court of the District of Columbia	October 21, 1914	no Senate vote
64th (1915-1917)	Palmer, A. Mitchell	Court of Claims	March 16, 1915 (recess appointment)	appointee declined
	Westenhaver, David C. (1)	Northern District of Ohio	February 19, 1917	no Senate vote
65th (1917-1919)	Whipple, U.V.	Southern District of Georgia	April 9, 1917	rejected by Senate April 24, 1917
	Thomas, W.E.	Southern District of Georgia	July 11, 1917	rejected by Senate July 12, 1917
	Haight, Thomas G. (1), (2)	Third Circuit	March 1, 1919	no Senate vote
66th (1919-1921)	Garrett, Finis J.	Western District of Tennessee	November 22, 1920 (recess appointment)	appointee declined
	Garrett, Finis J.	Western District of Tennessee	December 10, 1920	no Senate vote
	Ryan, William	Western District of Wisconsin	January 7, 1921	no Senate vote

Warren G. Harding (1921-1923)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
67th (1921-1923)	Butler, Pierce (1)	Supreme Court	November 21, 1922	no Senate vote
	Rose, John C. (1)	Fourth Circuit	November 27, 1922	no Senate vote
	Hoffheimer, Harry M.	Southern District of Ohio	February 28, 1923	confirmed March 2, 1923; nominee declined

Calvin Coolidge (1923-1929)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
69th (1925-1927)	McCarthy, James W.	District of New Jersey	March 18, 1925	confirmed March 18, 1925; nominee declined
	McCamant, Wallace (2)	Ninth Circuit	December 8, 1925	rejected by Senate March 17, 1926
	Tilson, William J. (2)	Middle District of Georgia	June 9, 1926	withdrawn by president June 18, 1926
	Tilson, William J. (2)	Middle District of Georgia	December 7, 1926	withdrawn by president February 8, 1927
70th (1927-1929)	McDermott, George T.	District of Kansas	December 13, 1927	withdrawn by president January 12, 1928
	Bowen, Crate D.	Southern District of Florida	May 24, 1928	no Senate vote
	Vaught, Edward S. (1), (2)	Western District of Oklahoma	May 26, 1928	no Senate vote
	Bowen, Crate D.	Southern District of Florida	January, 19, 1929	withdrawn by president January 23, 1929
	Glassie, Henry H.	Supreme Court of the District of Columbia	February 14, 1929	no Senate vote
	Lenroot, Irvine L. (1)	Court of Customs Appeals	February 14, 1929	no Senate vote
	Wheat, Alfred A.	Eastern District of New York	February 28, 1929	no Senate vote
	Woolsey, John M. (1)	Southern District of New York	February 28, 1929	no Senate vote
	Caffey, Francis G. (1)	Southern District of New York	March 1, 1929	no Senate vote
	Gardner, Archibald K. (1)	Eighth Circuit	March 1, 1929	no Senate vote
	McDermott, George T. (1)	Tenth Circuit	March 1, 1929	no Senate vote
	Phillips, Orie L. (1)	Tenth Circuit	March 1, 1929	no Senate vote
	Stryker, Lloyd P.	Southern District of New York	March 1, 1929	no Senate vote
	Wilbur, Curtis D. (1)	Ninth Circuit	March 1, 1929	no Senate vote
	Wyman, A. Lee (1)	District of South Dakota	March 1, 1929	no Senate vote

Herbert Hoover (1929-1933)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
71st (1929-1931)	Watson, Albert L. (1)	Middle District of Pennsylvania	June 8, 1929	no Senate vote
	Parker, John J.	Supreme Court	March 21, 1930	rejected by Senate May 7, 1930
	Nordbye, Gunnar H. (1), (2)	District of Minnesota	February 20, 1931	no Senate vote
	Fee, James A. (1), (2)	District of Oregon	February 26, 1931	no Senate vote
72nd (1931-1933)	Mackintosh, Kenneth	Ninth Circuit	January 8, 1932	no Senate vote
	Wilkerson, James H.	Seventh Circuit	January 12, 1932	no Senate vote
	Johnson, George E.Q. (2)	Northern District of Illinois	December 7, 1932	no Senate vote
	Mackintosh, Kenneth	Ninth Circuit	December 7, 1932	no Senate vote
	Ramseyer, C. William	Customs Court	December 13, 1932	no Senate vote
	Newton, Walter H.	District of Minnesota	February 18, 1933	no Senate vote
	Richardson, Seth W.	Eighth Circuit	February 23, 1933	no Senate vote

Franklin D. Roosevelt (1933-1945)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
73rd (1933-1934)	Norcross, Frank H.	Ninth Circuit	September 23, 1933 (recess appointment)	appointee declined
	Woodburn, William	District of Nevada	September 23, 1933 (recess appointment)	appointment invalid; vacancy did not occur
	Norcross, Frank H.	Ninth Circuit	January 8, 1934	no Senate vote
75th (1937-1938)	Allred, James V. (1)	Southern District of Texas	July 11, 1938 (recess appointment)	appointee declined
76th (1939-1941)	Roberts, Floyd H. (2)	Western District of Virginia	January 5, 1939	rejected by Senate February 6, 1939
	Lee, William B.	Eastern and Middle Districts of Tennessee	January 24, 1939	confirmed February 1, 1939; nominee died prior to appointment
	Porterie, Gaston L.N.	Northern District of Louisiana [sic]	January 24, 1939	withdrawn by president January 25, 1939
	Darr, Leslie R. (1)	Eastern and Middle Districts of Tennessee	May 17, 1939	withdrawn by president May 24, 1939
77th (1941-1942)	Chandler, Stephen S., Jr. (1)	Western District of Oklahoma	December 11, 1942	no Senate vote
	Lawrence, Charles D. (1)	Customs Court	December 11, 1942	no Senate vote
78th (1943-1944)	Allred, James V.	Fifth Circuit	February 18, 1943	no Senate vote
79th (1945-1946)	Margold, Nathan R.	District of the District of Columbia	January 19, 1945	no Senate vote
	Johnson, Jed	Customs Court	March 29, 1945	confirmed April 3, 1945; nominee declined

Harry S Truman (1945-1953)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
79th (1945-1946)	Kalodner, Harry E.	Third Circuit	May 7, 1946	withdrawn by president, May 21, 1946
80th (1947-1948)	Harper, Roy W. (1), (2)	Eastern and Western Districts of Missouri	July 10, 1947	no Senate vote
	Harper, Roy W. (1), (2)	Eastern and Western Districts of Missouri	November 24, 1947	no Senate vote
	Tamm, Edward A. (1), (2)	District of the District of Columbia	February 3, 1948	no Senate vote
	Warlick, Wilson	Western District of North Carolina	April 2, 1948	no Senate vote
	Rao, Paul P. (1), (2)	Customs Court	May 3, 1948	no Senate vote
	Kaufman, Samuel H. (1), (2)	Southern District of New York	May 17, 1948	no Senate vote
	Harper, Roy W. (1), (2)	Eastern and Western Districts of Missouri	July 29, 1948	no Senate vote
	Kaufman, Samuel H. (1), (2)	Southern District of New York	July 29, 1948	no Senate vote
	Rao, Paul P. (1), (2)	Customs Court	July 29, 1948	no Senate vote
	Tamm, Edward A. (1), (2)	District of the District of Columbia	July 29, 1948	no Senate vote
81st (1949-1951)	Eberharter, Herman P.	Western District of Pennsylvania	April 26, 1949	no Senate vote
	Switzer, Carroll O. (2)	Southern District of Iowa	June 9, 1949	no Senate vote
	Ritter, Willis W. (1), (2)	District of Utah	August 25, 1949	no Senate vote
	Andrews, M. Neil	Northern District of Georgia	October 15, 1949	no Senate vote
	Bazelon, David L. (1), (2)	District of Columbia Circuit	October 15, 1949	no Senate vote
	Burns, Owen M. (1), (2)	Western District of Pennsylvania	October 15, 1949	no Senate vote
	Clary, Thomas J. (1), (2)	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	October 15, 1949	no Senate vote
	Fahy, Charles (1), (2)	District of Columbia Circuit	October 15, 1949	no Senate vote
	Grim, Allan K. (1), (2)	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	October 15, 1949	no Senate vote
	Hastie, William H. (1), (2)	Third Circuit	October 15, 1949	no Senate vote
	Hill, Delmas C. (1), (2)	District of Kansas	October 15, 1949	no Senate vote
	Hooper, Frank A.	Northern District of Georgia	October 15, 1949	no Senate vote
	Kaufman, Irving R. (1), (2)	Southern District of New York	October 15, 1949	no Senate vote
	McGohey, John F.X. (1), (2)	Southern District of New York	October 15, 1949	no Senate vote
	Noonan, Gregory F. (1), (2)	Southern District of New York	October 15, 1949	no Senate vote
	Solomon, Gus J. (1), (2)	District of Oregon	October 15, 1949	no Senate vote
	Sugarman, Sidney (1), (2)	Southern District of New York	October 15, 1949	no Senate vote
	Swaim, H. Nathan (1), (2)	Seventh Circuit	October 15, 1949	no Senate vote
	Washington, George T. (1), (2)	District of Columbia Circuit	October 15, 1949	no Senate vote
	Wright, J. Skelly (1), (2)	Eastern District of Louisiana	October 15, 1949	no Senate vote
	Kirkland, James R. (1), (2)	District of the District of Columbia	October 17, 1949	no Senate vote
	Matthews, Burnita S. (1), (2)	District of the District of Columbia	October 17, 1949	no Senate vote
	McLaughlin, Charles F. (1), (2)	District of the District of Columbia	October 17, 1949	no Senate vote
	Andrews, M. Neil (2)	Northern District of Georgia	January 5, 1950	rejected by Senate August 9, 1950
	Switzer, Carroll O. (2)	Southern District of Iowa	January 5, 1950	rejected by Senate August 9, 1950
	Byrne, William M., Sr. (1), (2)	Southern District of California	September 1, 1950	no Senate vote
	Carter, Oliver J. (1), (2)	Northern District of California	September 1, 1950	no Senate vote
82nd (1951-1952)	Hennock, Frieda B.	Southern District of New York	June 11, 1951	no Senate vote
	Drucker, Joseph J.	Northern District of Illinois	July 13, 1951	rejected by Senate October 9, 1951
	Harrington, Cornelius J.	Northern District of Illinois	July 13, 1951	rejected by Senate October 9, 1951
	Tolin, Ernest A. (1), (2)	Southern District of California	October 18, 1951	no Senate vote
	Friedman, Monroe M. (2)	Northern District of California	June 27, 1952	no Senate vote
83rd (1953-1954)	Friedman, Monroe M. (2)	Northern District of California	January 9, 1953	withdrawn by president July 24, 1953

Dwight D. Eisenhower (1953-1961)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
83rd (1953-1954)	Van Dusen, Francis L. (1)	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	March 29, 1954	no Senate vote
	Bastian, Walter M. (1), (2)	District of Columbia Circuit	August 19, 1954	no Senate vote
	Cecil, Lamar J.R. (1), (2)	Eastern District of Texas	August 19, 1954	no Senate vote
	Miller, William E. (1)	Middle District of Tennessee	August 19, 1954	no Senate vote
	Harlan, John M. (1)	Supreme Court	November 9, 1954	no Senate vote
	Devitt, Edward J. (1), (2)	District of Minnesota	November 16, 1954	no Senate vote
	Miller, William E. (1)	Middle District of Tennessee	November 16, 1954	no Senate vote
84th (1955-1956)	Herlands, William B. (1), (2)	Southern District of New York	May 11, 1955	no Senate vote
	Kraft, C. William, Jr. (1), (2)	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	May 20, 1955	no Senate vote
	Burger, Warren E. (1)	District of Columbia Circuit	June 21, 1955	no Senate vote
	Sobeloff, Simon E. (1)	Fourth Circuit	July 14, 1955	no Senate vote
	Lieb, Joseph P. (1), (2)	Southern District of Florida	July 30, 1955	no Senate vote
	Watkins, R. Dorsey (1), (2)	District of Maryland	July 30, 1955	no Senate vote
	Morgan, Justin C. (1)	Western District of New York	August 1, 1955	no Senate vote
85th (1957-1958)	Moore, Leonard P. (1), (2)	Second Circuit	March 19, 1957	no Senate vote
	Henley, J. Smith (2)	Eastern District of Arkansas	February 24, 1958	no Senate vote
	Hart, George L., Jr. (1), (2)	District of the District of Columbia	August 16, 1958	no Senate vote
	Boreman, Herbert S. (1)	Fourth Circuit	October 17, 1958 (recess appointment)	appointee declined
86th (1959-1960)	Henley, J. Smith (2)	Eastern District of Arkansas	January 17, 1959	withdrawn by president August 18, 1959
	Tucker, John G.	Eastern District of Texas	February 12, 1959	withdrawn by president August 3, 1959
	Paul, Charles F. (1)	Northern District of West Virginia	August 3, 1959	no Senate vote
	Durfee, James (1)	Court of Claims	August 25, 1959	no Senate vote
	Smith, J. Joseph (1)	Second Circuit	August 27, 1959	no Senate vote
	Timbers, William H. (1)	District of Connecticut	August 27, 1959	no Senate vote
	Tavares, C. Nils (1), (2)	District of Hawaii	January 14, 1960	no Senate vote
	Kennerly, Thomas E.	Southern District of Texas	June 6, 1960	no Senate vote
	Feikens, John (2)	Eastern District of Michigan	June 10, 1960	no Senate vote
	Caffrey, Andrew A. (1), (2)	District of Massachusetts	July 1, 1960	no Senate vote
87th (1961-1962)	Feikens, John (2)	Eastern District of Michigan	January 10, 1961	no Senate vote

John F. Kennedy (1961-1963)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
87th (1961-1962)	Bell, Griffin B. (1), (2)	Fifth Circuit	September 20, 1961	no Senate vote
	Gewin, Walter P. (1), (2)	Fifth Circuit	September 20, 1961	no Senate vote
	Rosling, George (1), (2)	Eastern District of New York	September 21, 1961	no Senate vote
	Allgood, Clarence W. (1), (2)	Northern District of Alabama	September 23, 1961	no Senate vote
	Bonsal, Dudley B. (1), (2)	Southern District of New York	September 23, 1961	no Senate vote
	Cooper, Irving B. (1), (2)	Southern District of New York	September 23, 1961	no Senate vote
	Daugherty, Frederick A. (1), (2)	Eastern, Northern and Western Districts of Oklahoma	September 23, 1961	no Senate vote
	Feinberg, Wilfred (1), (2)	Southern District of New York	September 23, 1961	no Senate vote
	Green, Ben C. (1), (2)	Northern District of Ohio	September 23, 1961	no Senate vote
	Hays, Paul R. (1), (2)	Second Circuit	September 23, 1961	no Senate vote
	Marshall, Thurgood (1), (2)	Second Circuit	September 23, 1961	no Senate vote
	Peck, John W. II (1), (2)	Southern District of Ohio	September 23, 1961	no Senate vote
	Smith, Talbot (1), (2)	Eastern District of Michigan	September 23, 1961	no Senate vote
	Brewster, Leo (1), (2)	Northern District of Texas	September 25, 1961	no Senate vote
	Hughes, Sarah T. (1), (2)	Northern District of Texas	September 25, 1961	no Senate vote
	Noel, James L., Jr. (1), (2)	Southern District of Texas	September 25, 1961	no Senate vote
	Spears, Adrian A. (1), (2)	Western District of Texas	September 25, 1961	no Senate vote
	Almond, J. Lindsay, Jr. (1), (2)	Court of Customs and Patent Appeals	April 16, 1962	no Senate vote
	McGowan, Carl E. (1)	District of Columbia Circuit	August 16, 1962	no Senate vote
88th (1963-1964)	Davis, John M. (1), (2)	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	September 3, 1963	no Senate vote
	Rabinovitz, David (2)	Western District of Wisconsin	September 6, 1963	no Senate vote
	Higginbotham, A. Leon, Jr. (1), (2)	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	September 25, 1963	no Senate vote
	Robinson, Spottswood W. III (1), (2)	District of the District of Columbia	October 1, 1963	no Senate vote

Lyndon B. Johnson (1963-1969)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
88th (1963-1964)	Rabinovitz, David (2)	Western District of Wisconsin	February 3, 1964	no Senate vote
89th (1965-1966)	Fullam, John P. (1)	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	August 24, 1965	no Senate vote
	Morrissey, Francis X.	District of Massachusetts	September 28, 1965	no Senate vote
	Watson, James L. (1)	Customs Court	October 6, 1965	no Senate vote
	Feinberg, Wilfred (1)	Second Circuit	October 11, 1965	no Senate vote
	Thomas, William K. (1)	Northern District of Ohio	October 18, 1965	no Senate vote
	Weinstein, Jack B. (1)	Eastern District of New York	October 17, 1966	no Senate vote
90th (1967-1968)	Poole, Cecil F.	Northern District of California	May 29, 1968	no Senate vote
	Fortas, Abe	Chief Justice, Supreme Court	June 26, 1968	withdrawn by president October 4, 1968
	Thornberry, Homer W.	Supreme Court	June 26, 1968	withdrawn by president October 4, 1968
	Bress, David G.	District of the District of Columbia	August 2, 1968	no Senate vote
	Sanders, Harold B., Jr.	District of Columbia Circuit	September 25, 1968	no Senate vote
	Byrne, William M., Jr.	Central District of California	October 1, 1968	no Senate vote
91st (1969-1971)	Bress, David G.	District of the District of Columbia	January 9, 1969	withdrawn by president January 23, 1969
	Byrne, William M., Jr.	Central District of California	January 9, 1969	withdrawn by president January 23, 1969
	Poole, Cecil F.	Northern District of California	January 9, 1969	withdrawn by president January 23, 1969
	Sanders, Harold B., Jr.	District of Columbia Circuit	January 9, 1969	withdrawn by president January 23, 1969

Richard M. Nixon (1969-1974)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
91st (1969-1971)	Bane, Charles A.	Seventh Circuit	May 28, 1969	withdrawn by president October 22, 1969
	Haynsworth, Clement F., Jr.	Supreme Court	August 21, 1969	rejected by Senate November 21, 1969
	Pell, Wilbur F., Jr. (1)	Seventh Circuit	December 15, 1969	no Senate vote
	Carswell, G. Harrold	Supreme Court	January 19, 1970	rejected by Senate April 8, 1970
	Varner, Robert E. (1)	Middle District of Alabama	December 4, 1970	no Senate vote
93rd (1973-1974)	Torruella, Juan R. (1)	District of Puerto Rico	May 28, 1974	no Senate vote
	Meskill, Thomas J. (1)	Second Circuit	August 8, 1974	no Senate vote

Gerald R. Ford (1974-1977)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
93rd (1973-1974)	Meskill, Thomas J. (1)	Second Circuit	November 18, 1974	no Senate vote
	Henley, J. Smith (1)	Eighth Circuit	December 11, 1974	no Senate vote
94th (1975-1976)	Poff, William B.	Western District of Virginia	April 1, 1976	withdrawn by president June 7, 1976
	Revell, Richard A.	Western District of Kentucky	April 26, 1976	no Senate vote
	Kovachevich, Elizabeth A.	Middle District of Florida	June 11, 1976	no Senate vote
	Bethune, Edwin R., Jr.	Eastern and Western Districts of Arkansas	June 15, 1976	no Senate vote
	Brotzman, Donald G.	District of Colorado	July 22, 1976	no Senate vote
	Bilby, Richard M.	Ninth Circuit	August 3, 1976	no Senate vote
	Moore, John H. II	Southern District of Florida	August 4, 1976	no Senate vote
	Wellford, Harry W.	Sixth Circuit	August 4, 1976	no Senate vote
	DeSimone, Herbert F.	District of Rhode Island	August 5, 1976	no Senate vote
	Walter, Donald E.	Western District of Louisiana	August 5, 1976	no Senate vote
	Anderson, James A.	Eastern and Western Districts of Washington	August 6, 1976	no Senate vote

Jimmy Carter (1977-1981)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
95th (1977-1978)	Collins, Robert F. (1)	Eastern District of Louisiana	November 2, 1977	no Senate vote
	Mazzone, A. David (1)	District of Massachusetts	November 21, 1977	no Senate vote
	Simmons, Paul A. (1)	Western District of Pennsylvania	November 22, 1977	no Senate vote
	Paletta, Len J.	Western District of Pennsylvania	April 7, 1978	withdrawn by president May 25, 1978
	Clauss, Carin Ann	District of the District of Columbia	September 19, 1978	no Senate vote
96th (1979-1980)	Green, Joyce H.	District of the District of Columbia	March 2, 1979	withdrawn by president March 6, 1979
	Winberry, Charles B., Jr.	Eastern District of North Carolina	March 29, 1979	withdrawn by president August 26, 1980
	Jones, James P.	Western District of Virginia	May 16, 1979	no Senate vote
	Jefferson, Andrew L., Jr.	Fifth Circuit	October 11, 1979	no Senate vote
	Arnold, Richard S. (1)	Eighth Circuit	December 14, 1979	withdrawn by president December 19, 1979
	Gray, Fred D.	Middle District of Alabama	January 10, 1980	withdrawn by president September 17, 1980
	Heen, Walter M. (2)	District of Hawaii	February 27, 1980	no Senate vote
	Sheffield, James E.	Eastern District of Virginia	April 9, 1980	no Senate vote
	Sprizzo, John E. (1)	Southern District of New York	June 2, 1980	no Senate vote
	Sachs, Howard F.	Eighth Circuit	July 30, 1980	no Senate vote
	Gimenez-Munoz, Miguel A.	District of Puerto Rico	July 31, 1980	no Senate vote
	Arnold, S. Gerald	Eastern District of North Carolina	August 26, 1980	no Senate vote
	Lackey, Gerald B.	Northern District of Ohio	August 28, 1980	no Senate vote
	Lowry, Peter M.	Western District of Texas	August 28, 1980	no Senate vote
	Nickerson, Eugene H.	Second Circuit	August 28, 1980	no Senate vote
	Roberts, David G.	District of Maine	August 28, 1980	no Senate vote
	Bua, Nicholas J.	Seventh Circuit	September 10, 1980	no Senate vote
	Glasser, Israel L.	Eastern District of New York	September 17, 1980	no Senate vote
	Nimmons, Ralph W., Jr.	Middle District of Florida	September 17, 1980	no Senate vote
	Weinberg, Philip	Eastern District of New York	September 17, 1980	no Senate vote
97th (1981-1983)	Heen, Walter M. (2)	District of Hawaii	January 8, 1981	withdrawn by president January 21, 1981

Ronald Reagan (1981-1989)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
97th (1981-1982)	Unger, Sherman E.	Federal Circuit	December 15, 1982	no Senate vote
	Vukasin, John P., Jr. (1)	Northern District of California	December 17, 1982	no Senate vote
98th (1983-1984)	Vukasin, John P., Jr. (1)	Northern District of California	January 31, 1983	no Senate vote
	Unger, Sherman E.	Federal Circuit	April 21, 1983	no Senate vote
	Starr, Kenneth W. (1)	District of Columbia Circuit	July 13, 1983	no Senate vote
	Galane, Morton R.	District of Nevada	July 21, 1983	no Senate vote
	Keenan, John F. (1)	Southern District of New York	July 21, 1983	no Senate vote
	Galane, Morton R.	District of Nevada	September 13, 1983	withdrawn by president October 18, 1983
	Unger, Sherman E.	Federal Circuit	September 13, 1983	no Senate vote
	Hargrove, John R., Sr. (1)	District of Maryland	November 10, 1983	no Senate vote
	Wilkinson, J. Harvie III (1)	Fourth Circuit	November 10, 1983	no Senate vote
	Sporkin, Stanley (1)	District of the District of Columbia	June 28, 1984	no Senate vote
	Aquilino, Thomas J., Jr. (1)	Court of International Trade	August 1, 1984	no Senate vote
	Bator, Paul M.	District of Columbia Circuit	August 1, 1984	withdrawn by president September 6, 1984
	Easterbrook, Frank H. (1)	Seventh Circuit	August 1, 1984	no Senate vote
	Holderman, James F., Jr. (1)	Northern District of Illinois	September 6, 1984	no Senate vote
	Cobb, Howell	Eastern District of Texas	September 10, 1984	no Senate vote
	Edgar, R. Allan (1)	Eastern District of Tennessee	September 11, 1984	no Senate vote
	La Plata, George (1)	Eastern District of Michigan	September 11, 1984	no Senate vote
	Meredith, Ronald E. (1)	Western District of Kentucky	September 11, 1984	no Senate vote
	Young, William G. (1)	District of Massachusetts	September 11, 1984	no Senate vote
	Jones, Edith H. (1)	Fifth Circuit	September 17, 1984	no Senate vote
	Rodriguez, Joseph H. (1)	District of New Jersey	September 17, 1984	no Senate vote
	Weber, Herman J. (1)	Southern District of Ohio	September 17, 1984	no Senate vote
	Batchelder, Alice M. (1)	Northern District of Ohio	October 5, 1984	no Senate vote
	Brunetti, Melvin T. (1)	Ninth Circuit	October 5, 1984	no Senate vote
	Walter, Donald E. (1)	Western District of Louisiana	October 5, 1984	no Senate vote
	Williams, Ann C. (1)	Northern District of Illinois	October 5, 1984	no Senate vote
	Wolf, Mark L. (1)	District of Massachusetts	October 5, 1984	no Senate vote
99th (1985-1986)	Moon, Albert I., Jr.	District of Hawaii	October 16, 1985	no Senate vote
	Sessions, Jefferson B. III	Southern District of Alabama	October 23, 1985	no Senate vote
	Fitzwater, Sidney A. (1)	Northern District of Texas	October 29, 1985	no Senate vote
	McAvoy, Thomas J. (1)	Northern District of New York	October 29, 1985	no Senate vote
	Bryan, Robert J. (1)	Western District of Washington	December 4, 1985	no Senate vote
	Cedarbaum, Miriam G. (1)	Southern District of New York	December 4, 1985	no Senate vote
	Gex, Walter J. III (1)	Southern District of Mississippi	December 4, 1985	no Senate vote
	Hansen, David R. (1)	Northern District of Iowa	December 4, 1985	no Senate vote
	Boggs, Danny J. (1)	Sixth Circuit	December 9, 1985	no Senate vote
	Sessions, Jefferson B. III	Southern District of Alabama	January 29, 1986	withdrawn by president July 31, 1986
	Porter, James K.	Eastern District of Tennessee	July 30, 1986	no Senate vote
	Dwyer, William L. (1)	Western District of Washington	September 26, 1986	no Senate vote
	Raggi, Reena (1)	Eastern District of New York	October 3, 1986	no Senate vote
100th (1987-1988)	Siegan, Bernard H.	Ninth Circuit	February 2, 1987	withdrawn by president September 16, 1988
	Miller, Robert N.	District of Colorado	February 5, 1987	withdrawn by president February 2, 1988
	Liebeler, Susan W.	Federal Circuit	March 23, 1987	no Senate vote
	Bork, Robert H.	Supreme Court	July 7, 1987	rejected by Senate October 23, 1987
	Treen, David C.	Fifth Circuit	July 22, 1987	withdrawn by president May 10, 1988
	Summit, Stuart A.	Second Circuit	September 23, 1987	no Senate vote
	Roberto, Robert, Jr.	Eastern District of New York	November 24, 1987	withdrawn by president July 26, 1988
	Schmutzer, Alfred C., Jr.	Eastern District of Tennessee	December 18, 1987	withdrawn by president March 28, 1988
	Walker, Vaughn R. (1)	Northern District of California	December 18, 1987	no Senate vote
	Levitt, Howard E.	Eastern District of New York	December 22, 1987	no Senate vote
	Abram, Donald E.	District of Colorado	February 19, 1988	no Senate vote
	Mason, Shannon T., Jr.	Eastern District of Virginia	February 22, 1988	no Senate vote
	McGregor, James R.	Western District of Pennsylvania	March 14, 1988	no Senate vote
	Erickson, William H.	District of Colorado	March 23, 1988	no Senate vote
	Hope, Judith R.	District of Columbia Circuit	April 14, 1988	no Senate vote
	Rymer, Pamela A. (1)	Ninth Circuit	April 26, 1988	no Senate vote
	Bonner, Robert C. (1)	Central District of California	June 15, 1988	no Senate vote
	Harmon, Melinda (1)	Southern District of Texas	June 23, 1988	no Senate vote
	Wiener, Jacques L., Jr.	Fifth Circuit	June 27, 1988	no Senate vote
	Garbis, Marvin J. (1)	District of Maryland	July 6, 1988	no Senate vote
	Hurlbutt, Guy G.	Ninth Circuit	August 11, 1988	no Senate vote
	Fernandez, Ferdinand F. (1)	Ninth Circuit	September 16, 1988	no Senate vote

George H.W. Bush (1989-1993)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
101st (1989-1990)	Walker, Vaughn R. (1)	Northern District of California	February 28, 1989	no Senate vote
	Ryskamp, Kenneth L.	Eleventh Circuit	April 26, 1990	no Senate vote
	Wanger, Oliver W. (1)	Eastern District of California	September 21, 1990	no Senate vote
	McGregor, James R.	Western District of Pennsylvania	October 15, 1990	no Senate vote
102nd (1991-1992)	McGregor, James R.	Western District of Pennsylvania	January 8, 1991	no Senate vote
	Ryskamp, Kenneth L.	Eleventh Circuit	January 8, 1991	no Senate vote
	Kavanagh, Edmund A.M.	Northern District of New York	July 25, 1991	no Senate vote
	Sholts, Thomas E.	Southern District of Florida	July 26, 1991	no Senate vote
	Waldman, Jay C.	Third Circuit	July 26, 1991	no Senate vote
	Van Antwerpen, Franklin S.	Third Circuit	September 11, 1991	no Senate vote
	BeVier, Lillian R.	Fourth Circuit	October 22, 1991	no Senate vote
	Boyle, Terrence W.	Fourth Circuit	October 22, 1991	no Senate vote
	Hendren, Jimm L.	Eastern District of Arkansas	October 24, 1991	withdrawn by president November 5, 1991
	O'Rourke, Andrew P.	Southern District of New York	November 12, 1991	no Senate vote
	Graham, Tony M.	Northern District of Oklahoma	November 14, 1991	no Senate vote
	Keating, Francis A. II	Tenth Circuit	November 14, 1991	no Senate vote
	Bea, Carlos T.	Northern District of California	November 20, 1991	no Senate vote
	Franklin, James B.	Southern District of Georgia	November 26, 1991	no Senate vote
	Trager, David G. (1)	Eastern District of New York	November 27, 1991	no Senate vote
	Carr, Kenneth R.	Western District of Texas	January 27, 1992	no Senate vote
	Fitzwater, Sidney A.	Fifth Circuit	January 27, 1992	no Senate vote
	Jackson, James W.	Northern District of Ohio	January 27, 1992	no Senate vote
	Roberts, John G., Jr.	District of Columbia Circuit	January 27, 1992	no Senate vote
	Smietanka, John A.	Sixth Circuit	January 27, 1992	no Senate vote
	Smith, Terral R.	Western District of Texas	January 27, 1992	no Senate vote
	Moreno, Federico A.	Eleventh Circuit	March 10, 1992	no Senate vote
	Anderson, Percy	Central District of California	March 20, 1992	no Senate vote
	Davis, Lawrence O.	Eastern District of Missouri	March 20, 1992	no Senate vote
	Hanen, Andrew S.	Southern District of Texas	March 20, 1992	no Senate vote
	Lloyd, Russell T.	Southern District of Texas	March 20, 1992	no Senate vote
	Shechtman, Paul L.	Southern District of New York	March 20, 1992	no Senate vote
	Walter, John F.	Central District of California	March 20, 1992	no Senate vote
	Wilson, Justin P.	Sixth Circuit	March 20, 1992	no Senate vote
	Voigts, Gene E.	Western District of Missouri	March 24, 1992	no Senate vote
	Quintana, Manuel H.	Southern District of New York	March 26, 1992	no Senate vote
	Banks, Charles A.	Eastern District of Arkansas	April 1, 1992	no Senate vote
	Hunter, Robert D.	Northern District of Alabama	April 2, 1992	no Senate vote
	Mahoney, Maureen E.	Eastern District of Virginia	April 2, 1992	no Senate vote
	Mitchell, James S.	District of Nebraska	April 7, 1992	no Senate vote
	Leighton, Ronald B.	Western District of Washington	April 30, 1992	no Senate vote
	McIntyre, James A.	Southern District of California	June 2, 1992	no Senate vote
	Quarles, William D., Jr.	District of Maryland	June 2, 1992	no Senate vote
	Davis, Leonard E.	Eastern District of Texas	June 3, 1992	no Senate vote
	Drushal, J. Douglas	Northern District of Ohio	June 3, 1992	no Senate vote
	Hagy, C. Christopher	Northern District of Georgia	June 3, 1992	no Senate vote
	Leonatti, Louis J.	Eastern District of Missouri	June 3, 1992	no Senate vote
	Armentrout, Katharine J.	District of Maryland	June 23, 1992	no Senate vote
	McMonagle, James J.	Northern District of Ohio	June 23, 1992	no Senate vote
	Casey, Richard C.	Southern District of New York	July 2, 1992	no Senate vote
	Hicks, Larry R.	District of Nevada	July 2, 1992	no Senate vote
	Campbell, R. Edgar	Middle District of Georgia	July 27, 1992	no Senate vote
	Seybert, Joanna (1)	Eastern District of New York	July 27, 1992	no Senate vote
	Kostelka, Robert W.	Western District of Louisiana	August 7, 1992	no Senate vote
	Dorr, Richard E.	Western District of Missouri	September 9, 1992	no Senate vote
	Payne, James H.	Eastern, Northern and Western Districts of Oklahoma	September 17, 1992	no Senate vote
	Prince, Walter B.	District of Massachusetts	September 17, 1992	no Senate vote
	O'Toole, George A., Jr.	District of Massachusetts	September 24, 1992	no Senate vote
	Dimitrouleas, William P.	Southern District of Florida	October 2, 1992	no Senate vote
	Saad, Henry W.	Eastern District of Michigan	October 2, 1992	no Senate vote

William J. Clinton (1993-2001)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
103rd (1993-1994)	Klein, Theodore	Southern District of Florida	October 29, 1993	no Senate vote
	Paz, R. Samuel	Central District of California	March 24, 1994	no Senate vote
	Dennis, James L. (1)	Fifth Circuit	June 8, 1994	no Senate vote
	McConnell, Judith D.	Southern District of California	August 5, 1994	no Senate vote
	Tait, John R.	District of Idaho	August 25, 1994	no Senate vote
	Chesney, Maxine M. (1)	Northern District of California	September 14, 1994	no Senate vote
	Moore, Karen N. (1)	Sixth Circuit	September 14, 1994	no Senate vote
	Stein, Sidney H. (1)	Southern District of New York	September 14, 1994	no Senate vote
	Lynch, Sandra L. (1)	First Circuit	September 19, 1994	no Senate vote
	Snodgrass, John D.	Northern District of Alabama	September 22, 1994	no Senate vote
	Toole, Patrick J., Jr.	Middle District of Pennsylvania	September 23, 1994	no Senate vote
	Folsom, David (1)	Eastern District of Texas	October 5, 1994	no Senate vote
	Heartfield, Thad (1)	Eastern District of Texas	October 5, 1994	no Senate vote
	Thornburg, Lacy (1)	Western District of North Carolina	October 5, 1994	no Senate vote
104th (1995-1996)	Snodgrass, John D.	Northern District of Alabama	January 11, 1995	withdrawn by president September 5, 1995
	Whitfield, Wenona Y.	Southern District of Illinois	March 23, 1995	no Senate vote
	Shurin, Leland M.	Western District of Missouri	April 4, 1995	withdrawn by president September 5, 1995
	Fletcher, William A. (1)	Ninth Circuit	April 25, 1995	no Senate vote
	Bingler, John H., Jr.	Western District of Pennsylvania	July 21, 1995	no Senate vote
	Greer, Bruce W.	Southern District of Florida	August 1, 1995	withdrawn by president May 13, 1996
	Tagle, Hilda G. (1)	Southern District of Texas	August 10, 1995	no Senate vote
	Garland, Merrick B. (1)	District of Columbia Circuit	September 5, 1995	no Senate vote
	Sundram, Clarence J.	Northern District of New York	September 29, 1995	no Senate vote
	Myerscough, Sue E.	Central District of Illinois	October 11, 1995	no Senate vote
	Stack, Charles R.	Eleventh Circuit	October 27, 1995	withdrawn by president May 13, 1996
	Aiken, Ann L. (1)	District of Oregon	November 27, 1995	no Senate vote
	Hochberg, Faith S.	District of New Jersey	November 27, 1995	no Senate vote
	Wattley, Cheryl B.	Northern District of Texas	December 12, 1995	no Senate vote
	Schattman, Michael D.	Northern District of Texas	December 19, 1995	no Senate vote
	Mollway, Susan O. (1)	District of Hawaii	December 21, 1995	no Senate vote
	Beaty, James A., Jr.	Fourth Circuit	December 22, 1995	no Senate vote
	Leonard, J. Rich	Fourth Circuit	December 22, 1995	no Senate vote
	Paez, Richard A. (1)	Ninth Circuit	January 25, 1996	no Senate vote
	Rodriguez Rodriguez, Anabelle	District of Puerto Rico	January 26, 1996	no Senate vote
	Bataillon, Joseph F. (1)	District of Nebraska	March 6, 1996	no Senate vote
	Clay, Eric L. (1)	Sixth Circuit	March 6, 1996	no Senate vote
	Kollar-Kotelly, Colleen (1)	District of the District of Columbia	March 29, 1996	no Senate vote
	McKeown, M. Margaret (1)	Ninth Circuit	March 29, 1996	no Senate vote
	Gajarsa, Arthur (1)	Federal Circuit	April 18, 1996	no Senate vote
	Lazzara, Richard A. (1)	Middle District of Florida	May 9, 1996	no Senate vote
	Morrow, Margaret M. (1)	Central District of California	May 9, 1996	no Senate vote
	Snyder, Christina A. (1)	Central District of California	May 15, 1996	no Senate vote
	Thrash, Thomas W., Jr. (1)	Northern District of Georgia	May 15, 1996	no Senate vote
	Miller, Jeffrey T. (1)	Southern District of California	July 19, 1996	no Senate vote
	Pratt, Robert W. (1)	Southern District of Iowa	August 2, 1996	no Senate vote
	Middlebrooks, Donald M. (1)	Southern District of Florida	September 5, 1996	no Senate vote
105th (1997-1998)	Beaty, James A., Jr.	Fourth Circuit	January 7, 1997	no Senate vote
	Paez, Richard A. (1)	Ninth Circuit	January 7, 1997	no Senate vote
	Sundram, Clarence J.	Northern District of New York	January 7, 1997	no Senate vote
	White, Helene N.	Sixth Circuit	January 7, 1997	no Senate vote
	Lasry, Lynn R.	Southern District of California	February 12, 1997	withdrawn by president February 12, 1998
	Rodriguez Rodriguez, Anabelle	District of Puerto Rico	March 21, 1997	no Senate vote
	Schattman, Michael D.	Northern District of Texas	March 21, 1997	withdrawn by president July 31, 1998
	White, Ronnie L.	Eastern District of Missouri	June 26, 1997	no Senate vote
	Ware, James S.	Ninth Circuit	June 27, 1997	withdrawn by president November 7, 1997
	Rangel, Jorge C.	Fifth Circuit	July 24, 1997	no Senate vote
	Bingler, John H., Jr.	Western District of Pennsylvania	July 31, 1997	withdrawn by president February 12, 1998
	Colman, Jeffrey D.	Northern District of Illinois	July 31, 1997	no Senate vote
	Massiah-Jackson, Frederica A.	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	July 31, 1997	withdrawn by president March 16, 1998
	Gould, Ronald M. (1)	Ninth Circuit	November 8, 1997	no Senate vote
	Berzon, Marsha L. (1)	Ninth Circuit	January 27, 1998	no Senate vote
	Klein, James W.	District of the District of Columbia	January 27, 1998	no Senate vote
	Dyk, Timothy B. (1)	Federal Circuit	April 1, 1998	no Senate vote
	Freedberg, Robert A.	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	April 23, 1998	no Senate vote
	Norton, Lynette	Western District of Pennsylvania	April 29, 1998	no Senate vote
	Stark, Jeffrey G.	Court of International Trade	April 29, 1998	no Senate vote
	Phillips, Virginia A. (1)	Central District of California	May 11, 1998	no Senate vote
	Raymar, Robert S.	Third Circuit	June 5, 1998	no Senate vote
	Goode, Barry P.	Ninth Circuit	June 24, 1998	no Senate vote
	Davis, Legrome D. (1)	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	July 30, 1998	no Senate vote
	Hibbler, William J. (1)	Northern District of Illinois	September 16, 1998	no Senate vote
	Kennelly, Matthew F. (1)	Northern District of Illinois	September 16, 1998	no Senate vote
106th (1999-2000)	Davis, Legrome D. (1)	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	January 26, 1999	no Senate vote
	Durham, Barbara	Ninth Circuit	January 26, 1999	no Senate vote
	Goode, Barry P.	Ninth Circuit	January 26, 1999	no Senate vote
	Norton, Lynette	Western District of Pennsylvania	January 26, 1999	no Senate vote
	White, Helene N.	Sixth Circuit	January 26, 1999	no Senate vote
	White, Ronnie L.	Eastern District of Missouri	January 26, 1999	rejected by Senate October 5, 1999
	Leonard, J. Rich	Eastern District of North Carolina	March 24, 1999	no Senate vote
	Klein, James W.	District of the District of Columbia	March 25, 1999	no Senate vote
	Johnson, H. Alston III	Fifth Circuit	April 22, 1999	no Senate vote
	McCarthy, Frank H.	Northern District of Oklahoma	April 30, 1999	no Senate vote
	Coan, Patricia A.	District of Colorado	May 27, 1999	no Senate vote
	Gee, Dolly M.	Central District of California	May 27, 1999	no Senate vote
	Woocher, Fredric D.	Central District of California	May 27, 1999	no Senate vote
	Duffy, James E., Jr.	Ninth Circuit	June 17, 1999	no Senate vote
	Kagan, Elena	District of Columbia Circuit	June 17, 1999	no Senate vote
	Tusan, Gail S.	Northern District of Georgia	August 3, 1999	withdrawn by president March 27, 2000
	Bell, Steven D.	Northern District of Ohio	August 5, 1999	no Senate vote
	Wynn, James A., Jr. (1)	Fourth Circuit	August 5, 1999	no Senate vote
	Lewis, Kathleen M.	Sixth Circuit	September 16, 1999	no Senate vote
	Moreno, Enrique	Fifth Circuit	September 16, 1999	no Senate vote
	Lyons, James M.	Tenth Circuit	September 22, 1999	withdrawn by president June 6, 2000
	Snyder, Allen R.	District of Columbia Circuit	September 22, 1999	no Senate vote
	Fields, Rhonda C.	District of the District of Columbia	November 17, 1999	no Senate vote
	Cindrich, Robert J.	Third Circuit	February 9, 2000	no Senate vote
	Markus, Kent R.	Sixth Circuit	February 9, 2000	no Senate vote
	Campbell, Bonnie J.	Eighth Circuit	March 2, 2000	no Senate vote
	Fineman, S. David	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	March 9, 2000	no Senate vote
	Riegle, Linda B.	District of Nevada	April 25, 2000	no Senate vote
	Morado, Ricardo	Southern District of Texas	May 11, 2000	no Senate vote
	Orlofsky, Stephen M.	Third Circuit	May 25, 2000	no Senate vote
	Sebelius, K. Gary	District of Kansas	June 6, 2000	no Senate vote
	Simon, Kenneth O.	Northern District of Alabama	June 6, 2000	no Senate vote
	Lim, John S.W.	District of Hawaii	June 8, 2000	no Senate vote
	Gregory, Roger L. (1), (2)	Fourth Circuit	June 30, 2000	no Senate vote
	Arguello, Christine M.	Tenth Circuit	July 27, 2000	no Senate vote
	Cercone, David S.	Western District of Pennsylvania	July 27, 2000	no Senate vote
	Litman, Harry P.	Western District of Pennsylvania	July 27, 2000	no Senate vote
	Couch, Valerie K.	Western District of Oklahoma	September 7, 2000	no Senate vote
	Johnston, Marian M.	Eastern District of Oklahoma	September 7, 2000	no Senate vote
	Achelpohl, Steven E.	District of Nebraska	September 12, 2000	no Senate vote
	Anderson, Richard W.	District of Montana	September 13, 2000	no Senate vote
	Lieberman, Stephen B.	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	September 14, 2000	no Senate vote
	Hall, Melvin C.	Western District of Oklahoma	October 3, 2000	no Senate vote
	Davis, Andre M. (1)	Fourth Circuit	October 6, 2000	no Senate vote
	Gibson, S. Elizabeth	Fourth Circuit	October 26, 2000	no Senate vote
107th (2001-2002)	Campbell, Bonnie J.	Eighth Circuit	January 3, 2001	withdrawn by president March 19, 2001
	Duffy, James E., Jr.	Ninth Circuit	January 3, 2001	withdrawn by president March 19, 2001
	Goode, Barry P.	Ninth Circuit	January 3, 2001	withdrawn by president March 19, 2001
	Gregory, Roger L. (1), (2)	Fourth Circuit	January 3, 2001	withdrawn by president March 19, 2001
	Lewis, Kathleen M.	Sixth Circuit	January 3, 2001	withdrawn by president March 19, 2001
	Moreno, Enrique	Fifth Circuit	January 3, 2001	withdrawn by president March 19, 2001
	White, Helene N.	Sixth Circuit	January 3, 2001	withdrawn by president March 19, 2001
	Wynn, James A., Jr. (1)	Fourth Circuit	January 3, 2001	withdrawn by president March 19, 2001
	Johnson, H. Alston III	Fifth Circuit	January 4, 2001	withdrawn by president March 19, 2001

George W. Bush (2001-2009)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
107th (2001-2002)	Boyle, Terrence W.	Fourth Circuit	May 9, 2001	no Senate vote
	Clement, Edith B. (1)	Fifth Circuit	May 9, 2001	no Senate vote
	Cook, Deborah L. (1)	Sixth Circuit	May 9, 2001	no Senate vote
	Estrada, Miguel A.	District of Columbia Circuit	May 9, 2001	no Senate vote
	McConnell, Michael W. (1)	Tenth Circuit	May 9, 2001	no Senate vote
	Owen, Priscilla R. (1)	Fifth Circuit	May 9, 2001	no Senate vote
	Parker, Barrington D., Jr. (1)	Second Circuit	May 9, 2001	no Senate vote
	Roberts, John G., Jr. (1)	District of Columbia Circuit	May 9, 2001	no Senate vote
	Shedd, Dennis (1)	Fourth Circuit	May 9, 2001	no Senate vote
	Sutton, Jeffrey S. (1)	Sixth Circuit	May 9, 2001	no Senate vote
	Prost, Sharon (1)	Federal Circuit	May 21, 2001	no Senate vote
	Smith, Lavenski R. (1)	Eighth Circuit	May 22, 2001	no Senate vote
	Pickering, Charles W., Sr. (2)	Fifth Circuit	May 25, 2001	no Senate vote
	Tymkovich, Timothy M. (1)	Tenth Circuit	May 25, 2001	no Senate vote
	Wooten, Terry L. (1)	District of South Carolina	June 18, 2001	no Senate vote
	Smith Camp, Laurie (1)	District of Nebraska	June 19, 2001	no Senate vote
	Cassell, Paul G. (1)	District of Utah	June 19, 2001	no Senate vote
	Bates, John D. (1)	District of the District of Columbia	June 20, 2001	no Senate vote
	Walton, Reggie B. (1)	District of the District of Columbia	June 20, 2001	no Senate vote
	Hartz, Harris L. (1)	Tenth Circuit	June 21, 2001	no Senate vote
	Clifton, Richard R. (1)	Ninth Circuit	June 22, 2001	no Senate vote
	Kuhl, Carolyn B.	Ninth Circuit	June 22, 2001	no Senate vote
	Gritzner, James E. (1)	Southern District of Iowa	July 10, 2001	no Senate vote
	Melloy, Michael J. (1)	Eighth Circuit	July 10, 2001	no Senate vote
	Mills, Michael P. (1)	Northern District of Mississippi	July 10, 2001	no Senate vote
	Armijo, M. Christina (1)	District of New Mexico	August 2, 2001	no Senate vote
	Bowdre, Karon O. (1)	Northern District of Alabama	August 2, 2001	no Senate vote
	Bunning, David L. (1)	Eastern District of Kentucky	August 2, 2001	no Senate vote
	Caldwell, Karen K. (1)	Eastern District of Kentucky	August 2, 2001	no Senate vote
	Eagan, Claire V. (1)	Northern District of Oklahoma	August 2, 2001	no Senate vote
	Engelhardt, Kurt D. (1)	Eastern District of Louisiana	August 2, 2001	no Senate vote
	Friot, Stephen P. (1)	Western District of Oklahoma	August 2, 2001	no Senate vote
	Granade, Callie V. (1)	Southern District of Alabama	August 2, 2001	no Senate vote
	Heaton, Joe L. (1)	Western District of Oklahoma	August 2, 2001	no Senate vote
	Hicks, Larry R. (1)	District of Nevada	August 2, 2001	no Senate vote
	Howard, Jeffrey R. (1)	First Circuit	August 2, 2001	no Senate vote
	Johnson, William P. (1)	District of New Mexico	August 2, 2001	no Senate vote
	O'Brien, Terrence L. (1)	Tenth Circuit	August 2, 2001	no Senate vote
	Payne, James H. (1)	Eastern, Northern and Western Districts of Oklahoma	August 2, 2001	no Senate vote
	Reeves, Danny C. (1)	Eastern District of Kentucky	August 2, 2001	no Senate vote
	Boyle, Terrence W.	Fourth Circuit	September 4, 2001	no Senate vote
	Cook, Deborah L. (1)	Sixth Circuit	September 4, 2001	no Senate vote
	Estrada, Miguel A.	District of Columbia Circuit	September 4, 2001	no Senate vote
	Kuhl, Carolyn B.	Ninth Circuit	September 4, 2001	no Senate vote
	Owen, Priscilla R. (1)	Fifth Circuit	September 4, 2001	no Senate vote
	Pickering, Charles W., Sr. (2)	Fifth Circuit	September 4, 2001	no Senate vote
	Roberts, John G., Jr. (1)	District of Columbia Circuit	September 4, 2001	no Senate vote
	Sutton, Jeffrey S. (1)	Sixth Circuit	September 4, 2001	no Senate vote
	Tymkovich, Timothy M. (1)	Tenth Circuit	September 4, 2001	no Senate vote
	Steele, William H.	Eleventh Circuit	October 9, 2001	no Senate vote
	McKeague, David W. (1)	Sixth Circuit	November 8, 2001	no Senate vote
	Neilson, Susan B. (1)	Sixth Circuit	November 8, 2001	no Senate vote
	Saad, Henry W.	Sixth Circuit	November 8, 2001	no Senate vote
	Stanceu, Timothy C. (1)	Court of International Trade	December 19, 2001	no Senate vote
	Rohlfing, Frederick W. III	District of Hawaii	January 23, 2002	no Senate vote
	Bybee, Jay S. (1)	Ninth Circuit	May 22, 2002	no Senate vote
	Dever, James C. III (1)	Eastern District of North Carolina	May 22, 2002	no Senate vote
	Griffin, Richard A. (1)	Sixth Circuit	June 26, 2002	no Senate vote
	Junell, Robert A. (1)	Western District of Texas	July 18, 2002	no Senate vote
	Otero, S. James (1)	Central District of California	July 18, 2002	no Senate vote
	Feuerstein, Sandra J. (1)	Eastern District of New York	July 25, 2002	no Senate vote
	Frost, Gregory L. (1)	Southern District of Ohio	August 1, 2002	no Senate vote
	Holwell, Richard J. (1)	Southern District of New York	August 1, 2002	no Senate vote
	Erickson, Ralph R. (1)	District of North Dakota	September 12, 2002	no Senate vote
	Hicks, S. Maurice, Jr. (1)	Western District of Louisiana	September 12, 2002	no Senate vote
	Ludington, Thomas L. (1)	Eastern District of Michigan	September 12, 2002	no Senate vote
	Quarles, William D., Jr. (1)	District of Maryland	September 12, 2002	no Senate vote
	Adams, John R. (1)	Northern District of Ohio	October 10, 2002	no Senate vote
	Breen, J. Daniel (1)	Western District of Tennessee	October 10, 2002	no Senate vote
	Carney, Cormac J. (1)	Central District of California	October 10, 2002	no Senate vote
	Varlan, Thomas A. (1)	Eastern District of Tennessee	October 10, 2002	no Senate vote
108th (2003-2004)	Boyle, Terrence W.	Fourth Circuit	January 7, 2003	no Senate vote
	Dever, James C. III (1)	Eastern District of North Carolina	January 7, 2003	no Senate vote
	Estrada, Miguel A.	District of Columbia Circuit	January 7, 2003	withdrawn by president September 4, 2003
	Griffin, Richard A. (1)	Sixth Circuit	January 7, 2003	no Senate vote
	Kuhl, Carolyn B.	Ninth Circuit	January 7, 2003	no Senate vote
	Ludington, Thomas L. (1)	Eastern District of Michigan	January 7, 2003	no Senate vote
	McKeague, David W. (1)	Sixth Circuit	January 7, 2003	no Senate vote
	Neilson, Susan B. (1)	Sixth Circuit	January 7, 2003	no Senate vote
	Owen, Priscilla R. (1)	Fifth Circuit	January 7, 2003	no Senate vote
	Pickering, Charles W., Sr. (2)	Fifth Circuit	January 7, 2003	no Senate vote
	Rohlfing, Frederick W.	District of Hawaii	January 7, 2003	withdrawn by president May 6, 2004
	Saad, Henry W.	Sixth Circuit	January 7, 2003	no Senate vote
	Pryor, William H., Jr. (1), (2)	Eleventh Circuit	April 9, 2003	no Senate vote
	Allen, Claude A.	Fourth Circuit	April 28, 2003	no Senate vote
	Conrad, Robert J., Jr. (1)	Western District of North Carolina	April 28, 2003	no Senate vote
	Ryan, Daniel P.	Eastern District of Michigan	April 28, 2003	no Senate vote
	Myers, William G. III	Ninth Circuit	May 15, 2003	no Senate vote
	Brown, Janice R. (1)	District of Columbia Circuit	July 25, 2003	no Senate vote
	Kavanaugh, Brett M. (1)	District of Columbia Circuit	July 25, 2003	no Senate vote
	Haynes, William J. II	Fourth Circuit	September 29, 2003	no Senate vote
	Sheridan, Peter G. (1)	District of New Jersey	November 5, 2003	no Senate vote
	Allen, Claude A.	Fourth Circuit	January 20, 2004	no Senate vote
	Pickering, Charles W., Sr. (2)	Fifth Circuit	February 6, 2004	no Senate vote
	Pryor, William H., Jr. (1), (2)	Eleventh Circuit	March 12, 2004	no Senate vote
	Griffith, Thomas B. (1)	District of Columbia Circuit	May 10, 2004	no Senate vote
	Crotty, Paul A. (1)	Southern District of New York	September 7, 2004	no Senate vote
	Cox, Sean F. (1)	Eastern District of Michigan	September 10, 2004	no Senate vote
	Seabright, J. Michael (1)	District of Hawaii	September 15, 2004	no Senate vote
109th (2005-2006)	Boyle, Terrence W.	Fourth Circuit	February 14, 2005	no Senate vote
	Haynes, William J. II	Fourth Circuit	February 14, 2005	no Senate vote
	Kavanaugh, Brett M. (1)	District of Columbia Circuit	February 14, 2005	no Senate vote
	Myers, William G. III	Ninth Circuit	February 14, 2005	no Senate vote
	Ryan, Daniel P.	Eastern District of Michigan	February 14, 2005	withdrawn by president March 30, 2006
	Saad, Henry W.	Sixth Circuit	February 14, 2005	withdrawn by president March 27, 2006
	Roberts, John G., Jr.	Supreme Court	July 29, 2005	withdrawn by president September 6, 2005
	Payne, James H.	Tenth Circuit	September 29, 2005	withdrawn by president March 7, 2006
	Miers, Harriet E.	Supreme Court	October 7, 2005	withdrawn by president October 28, 2005
	Smith, N. Randy	Ninth Circuit	December 16, 2005	no Senate vote
	Bryant, Vanessa L. (1)	District of Connecticut	January 25, 2006	no Senate vote
	Wallace, Michael B.	Fifth Circuit	February 8, 2006	no Senate vote
	Holmes, Jerome A.	Northern District of Oklahoma	February 14, 2006	withdrawn by president May 4, 2006
	Gutierrez, Philip S. (1)	Central District of California	April 24, 2006	no Senate vote
	Fairbank, Valerie B. (1)	Central District of California	May 4, 2006	no Senate vote
	Howard, Marcia M. (1)	Middle District of Florida	June 6, 2006	no Senate vote
	Southwick, Leslie	Southern District of Mississippi	June 6, 2006	no Senate vote
	Frizzell, Gregory K. (1)	Northern District of Oklahoma	June 7, 2006	no Senate vote
	Wood, Lisa G. (1)	Southern District of Georgia	June 12, 2006	no Senate vote
	Bailey, John P. (1)	Northern District of West Virginia	June 28, 2006	no Senate vote
	Donohue, Mary O.	Northern District of New York	June 28, 2006	no Senate vote
	Jarvey, John A. (1)	Southern District of Iowa	June 28, 2006	no Senate vote
	Jonker, Robert J. (1)	Western District of Michigan	June 28, 2006	no Senate vote
	Kethledge, Raymond M. (1)	Sixth Circuit	June 28, 2006	no Senate vote
	Livingston, Debra A. (1)	Second Circuit	June 28, 2006	no Senate vote
	Maloney, Paul L. (1)	Western District of Michigan	June 28, 2006	no Senate vote
	Murphy, Stephen J. III	Sixth Circuit	June 28, 2006	no Senate vote
	Neff, Janet T. (1)	Western District of Michigan	June 28, 2006	no Senate vote
	Keisler, Peter D.	District of Columbia Circuit	June 29, 2006	no Senate vote
	Fischer, Nora B. (1)	Western District of Pennsylvania	July 13, 2006	no Senate vote
	Lioi, Sara E. (1)	Northern District of Ohio	July 13, 2006	no Senate vote
	Mauskopf, Roslynn R. (1)	Eastern District of New York	August 2, 2006	no Senate vote
	O'Grady, Liam (1)	Eastern District of Virginia	August 2, 2006	no Senate vote
	O'Neil, Lawrence J. (1)	Eastern District of California	August 2, 2006	no Senate vote
	Boyle, Terrence W.	Fourth Circuit	September 5, 2006	no Senate vote
	Haynes, William J. II	Fourth Circuit	September 5, 2006	no Senate vote
	Myers, William G. III	Ninth Circuit	September 5, 2006	no Senate vote
	Ozerden, Halil S. (1)	Southern District of Mississippi	September 5, 2006	no Senate vote
	Smith, N. Randy	Ninth Circuit	September 5, 2006	no Senate vote
	Wallace, Michael B.	Fifth Circuit	September 5, 2006	no Senate vote
	Wright, Otis D. III (1)	Central District of California	September 5, 2006	no Senate vote
	Wu, George H. (1)	Central District of California	September 5, 2006	no Senate vote
	Hardiman, Thomas M. (1)	Third Circuit	September 13, 2006	no Senate vote
	Osteen, William L., Jr. (1)	Middle District of North Carolina	September 29, 2006	no Senate vote
	Reidinger, Martin K. (1)	Western District of North Carolina	September 29, 2006	no Senate vote
	Schroeder, Thomas D. (1)	Middle District of North Carolina	September 29, 2006	no Senate vote
	Boyle, Terrence W.	Fourth Circuit	November 15, 2006	no Senate vote
	Haynes, William J. II	Fourth Circuit	November 15, 2006	no Senate vote
	Keisler, Peter D.	District of Columbia Circuit	November 15, 2006	no Senate vote
	Myers, William G. III	Ninth Circuit	November 15, 2006	no Senate vote
	Rogan, James E.	Central District of California	November 15, 2006	no Senate vote
	Settle, Benjamin H. (1)	Western District of Washington	November 15, 2006	no Senate vote
	Smith, N. Randy	Ninth Circuit	November 15, 2006	no Senate vote
	Wallace, Michael B.	Fifth Circuit	November 15, 2006	no Senate vote
	Kapala, Frederick J. (1)	Northern District of Illinois	December 5, 2006	no Senate vote
	Farr, Thomas A.	Eastern District of North Carolina	December 7, 2006	no Senate vote
110th (2007-2009)	Donohue, Mary O.	Northern District of New York	January 9, 2007	withdrawn by president September 6, 2007
	Farr, Thomas A.	Eastern District of North Carolina	January 9, 2007	no Senate vote
	Keisler, Peter D.	District of Columbia Circuit	January 9, 2007	no Senate vote
	Rogan, James E.	Central District of California	January 9, 2007	no Senate vote
	Smith, N. Randy	Ninth Circuit	January 9, 2007	withdrawn by president January 16, 2007
	Dugas, David R.	Middle District of Louisiana	March 19, 2007	no Senate vote
	Honaker, Richard H.	District of Wyoming	March 19, 2007	no Senate vote
	Murphy, Stephen J. III	Sixth Circuit	March 19, 2007	withdrawn by president April 15, 2008
	Powell, William J.	Northern District of West Virginia	May 24, 2007	no Senate vote
	Puryear, Gustavus A. IV	Middle District of Tennessee	June 13, 2007	no Senate vote
	Conrad, Robert J., Jr.	Fourth Circuit	July 17, 2007	no Senate vote
	Stone, Shalom D.	Third Circuit	July 17, 2007	no Senate vote
	Getchell, E. Duncan	Fourth Circuit	September 6, 2007	withdrawn by president January 23, 2008
	Matthews, Steve A.	Fourth Circuit	September 6, 2007	no Senate vote
	Almond, Lincoln D.	District of Rhode Island	November 15, 2007	no Senate vote
	Novak, David J.	Eastern District of Virginia	November 15, 2007	no Senate vote
	Pratter, Gene E.K.	Third Circuit	November 15, 2007	withdrawn by president July 24, 2008
	Rosenstein, Rod J.	Fourth Circuit	November 15, 2007	no Senate vote
	Short, Carolyn P.	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	November 15, 2007	withdrawn by president July 24, 2008
	Smith, William E.	First Circuit	December 6, 2007	no Senate vote
	Connolly, Colm F.	District of Delaware	February 26, 2008	no Senate vote
	Conrad, Glen E.	Fourth Circuit	May 8, 2008	no Senate vote
	O'Neill, Michael	District of the District of Columbia	June 19, 2008	no Senate vote
	Rosen, Jeffrey A.	District of the District of Columbia	June 19, 2008	no Senate vote
	Goldberg, Gregory E.	District of Colorado	July 10, 2008	no Senate vote
	Jung, William F.	Middle District of Florida	July 10, 2008	no Senate vote
	Dugan, Timothy G.	Eastern District of Wisconsin	July 15, 2008	no Senate vote
	Hernandez, Marco A. (1)	District of Oregon	July 23, 2008	no Senate vote
	Diamond, Paul S.	Third Circuit	July 24, 2008	no Senate vote
	Short, Carolyn P.	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	July 24, 2008	no Senate vote
	Barry, J. Richard	Southern District of Mississippi	July 31, 2008	no Senate vote
	Marcelle, Thomas	Northern District of New York	July 31, 2008	no Senate vote
	Tharp, John J., Jr.	Northern District of Illinois	July 31, 2008	no Senate vote
	Davis, J. Mac	District of Wisconsin	September 9, 2008	no Senate vote
	Preska, Loretta A.	Second Circuit	September 9, 2008	no Senate vote
	Simon, Philip P.	Seventh Circuit	September 26, 2008	no Senate vote

Barack Obama (2009-2017)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
111th (2009-2010)	Chen, Edward M. (1)	Northern District of California	August 6, 2009	no Senate vote
	Butler, Louis B., Jr.	Western District of Wisconsin	September 30, 2009	no Senate vote
	Butler, Louis B., Jr.	Western District of Wisconsin	January 20, 2010	no Senate vote
	Chen, Edward M. (1)	Northern District of California	January 20, 2010	no Senate vote
	Chatigny, Robert N.	Second Circuit	February 24, 2010	no Senate vote
	Liu, Goodwin	Ninth Circuit	February 24, 2010	no Senate vote
	McConnell, John J., Jr. (1)	District of Rhode Island	March 10, 2010	no Senate vote
	Totenberg, Amy M. (1)	Northern District of Georgia	March 17, 2010	no Senate vote
	DuMont, Edward C.	Federal Circuit	April 14, 2010	no Senate vote
	Holmes, Paul K. III (1)	Western District of Arkansas	April 28, 2010	no Senate vote
	Battaglia, Anthony J. (1)	Southern District of California	May 20, 2010	no Senate vote
	Carney, Susan L. (1)	Second Circuit	May 20, 2010	no Senate vote
	Davila, Edward J. (1)	Northern District of California	May 20, 2010	no Senate vote
	Cogburn, Max O., Jr. (1)	Western District of North Carolina	May 27, 2010	no Senate vote
	Shadid, James E. (1)	Central District of Illinois	May 27, 2010	no Senate vote
	Graves, James E., Jr. (1)	Fifth Circuit	June 10, 2010	no Senate vote
	Boasberg, James E. (1)	District of the District of Columbia	June 17, 2010	no Senate vote
	Jackson, Amy B. (1)	District of the District of Columbia	June 17, 2010	no Senate vote
	Myerscough, Sue E.	Central District of Illinois	June 17, 2010	withdrawn by president July 14, 2010
	Hernandez, Marco A. (1)	District of Oregon	July 14, 2010	no Senate vote
	Jones, Steve C. (1)	Northern District of Georgia	July 14, 2010	no Senate vote
	Myerscough, Sue E. (1)	Central District of Illinois	July 14, 2010	no Senate vote
	Nourse, Victoria F.	Seventh Circuit	July 14, 2010	no Senate vote
	Saldana, Diana (1)	Southern District of Texas	July 14, 2010	no Senate vote
	Simon, Michael H. (1)	District of Oregon	July 14, 2010	no Senate vote
	Day, Charles B.	District of Maryland	July 21, 2010	no Senate vote
	Williams, Kathleen M. (1)	Southern District of Florida	July 21, 2010	no Senate vote
	Garcia Marmolejo, Marina (1)	Southern District of Texas	July 28, 2010	no Senate vote
	Butler, Louis B., Jr.	Western District of Wisconsin	September 13, 2010	no Senate vote
	Chatigny, Robert N.	Second Circuit	September 13, 2010	no Senate vote
	Chen, Edward M. (1)	Northern District of California	September 13, 2010	no Senate vote
	Liu, Goodwin	Ninth Circuit	September 13, 2010	no Senate vote
	McConnell, John J., Jr. (1)	District of Rhode Island	September 13, 2010	no Senate vote
	D'Agostino, Mae A. (1)	Northern District of New York	September 29, 2010	no Senate vote
	Halligan, Caitlin J.	District of Columbia Circuit	September 29, 2010	no Senate vote
	Jackson, Richard B. (1)	District of Colorado	September 29, 2010	no Senate vote
	Reyna, Jimmie V. (1)	Federal Circuit	September 29, 2010	no Senate vote
	Bissoon, Cathy (1)	Western District of Pennsylvania	November 17, 2010	no Senate vote
	Briccetti, Vincent L. (1)	Southern District of New York	November 17, 2010	no Senate vote
	Dalton, Roy B., Jr. (1)	Middle District of Florida	November 17, 2010	no Senate vote
	Darrow, Sara L. (1)	Central District of Illinois	November 17, 2010	no Senate vote
	Kronstadt, John A. (1)	Central District of California	November 17, 2010	no Senate vote
	Sharp, Kevin H. (1)	Middle District of Tennessee	November 17, 2010	no Senate vote
	Allen, Arenda L.W. (1)	Eastern District of Virginia	December 1, 2010	no Senate vote
	Cecchi, Claire C. (1)	District of New Jersey	December 1, 2010	no Senate vote
	Donald, Bernice B. (1)	Sixth Circuit	December 1, 2010	no Senate vote
	Hornak, Mark R. (1)	Western District of Pennsylvania	December 1, 2010	no Senate vote
	Mariani, Robert D. (1)	Middle District of Pennsylvania	December 1, 2010	no Senate vote
	Ross, John A. (1)	Eastern District of Missouri	December 1, 2010	no Senate vote
	Salas, Esther (1)	District of New Jersey	December 1, 2010	no Senate vote
	Urbanski, Michael F. (1)	Western District of Virginia	December 1, 2010	no Senate vote
112th (2011-2013)	Butler, Louis B., Jr.	Western District of Wisconsin	January 5, 2011	no Senate vote
	Day, Charles B.	District of Maryland	January 5, 2011	withdrawn by president October 31, 2011
	DuMont, Edward C.	Federal Circuit	January 5, 2011	withdrawn by president November 10, 2011
	Halligan, Caitlin J.	District of Columbia Circuit	January 5, 2011	no Senate vote
	Liu, Goodwin	Ninth Circuit	January 5, 2011	withdrawn by president July 29, 2011
	Nourse, Victoria F.	Seventh Circuit	January 5, 2011	no Senate vote
	Green, Michael C.	Western District of New York	January 26, 2011	no Senate vote
	Silas, Natasha P.	Northern District of Georgia	January 26, 2011	no Senate vote
	Walker, Linda T.	Northern District of Georgia	January 26, 2011	no Senate vote
	Mikkanen, Arvo	Northern District of Oklahoma	February 2, 2011	no Senate vote
	Six, Steve	Tenth Circuit	March 9, 2011	no Senate vote
	Marquez, Rosemary (1)	District of Arizona	June 23, 2011	no Senate vote
	Shwartz, Patty (1)	Third Circuit	October 5, 2011	no Senate vote
	Taranto, Richard G. (1)	Federal Circuit	November 10, 2011	no Senate vote
	Bacharach, Robert E. (1)	Tenth Circuit	January 23, 2012	no Senate vote
	Kayatta, William J., Jr. (1)	First Circuit	January 23, 2012	no Senate vote
	Cadish, Elissa F.	District of Nevada	February 16, 2012	no Senate vote
	Pryor, Jill A. (1)	Eleventh Circuit	February 16, 2012	no Senate vote
	Davis, Brian J. (1)	Middle District of Florida	February 29, 2012	no Senate vote
	Dick, Shelly D. (1)	Middle District of Louisiana	April 25, 2012	no Senate vote
	Halligan, Caitlin J.	District of Columbia Circuit	June 11, 2012	no Senate vote
	Orrick, William H. III (1)	Northern District of California	June 11, 2012	no Senate vote
	Srinivasan, Srikanth (1)	District of Columbia Circuit	June 11, 2012	no Senate vote
	Chappell, Sheri P. (1)	Middle District of Florida	June 25, 2012	no Senate vote
	Failla, Katherine P. (1)	Southern District of New York	June 25, 2012	no Senate vote
	Nunley, Troy L. (1)	Eastern District of California	June 25, 2012	no Senate vote
	Barnett, Mark A. (1)	Court of International Trade	July 12, 2012	no Senate vote
	Chen, Pamela K.M. (1)	Eastern District of New York	August 2, 2012	no Senate vote
	Dorsey, Jennifer A. (1)	District of Nevada	September 19, 2012	no Senate vote
	Gordon, Andrew P. (1)	District of Nevada	September 19, 2012	no Senate vote
	Halligan, Caitlin J.	District of Columbia Circuit	September 19, 2012	no Senate vote
	McShane, Michael J. (1)	District of Oregon	September 19, 2012	no Senate vote
	Jackson, Ketanji B. (1)	District of the District of Columbia	September 20, 2012	no Senate vote
	Roman, Nelson S. (1)	Southern District of New York	September 20, 2012	no Senate vote
	Caproni, Valerie E. (1)	Southern District of New York	November 14, 2012	no Senate vote
	Gonzales, Kenneth J. (1)	District of New Mexico	November 14, 2012	no Senate vote
	Kelly, Claire R. (1)	Court of International Trade	November 14, 2012	no Senate vote
	Moore, Raymond P. (1)	District of Colorado	November 14, 2012	no Senate vote
	O'Connell, Beverly R. (1)	Central District of California	November 14, 2012	no Senate vote
	Thomas, William L.	Southern District of Florida	November 14, 2012	no Senate vote
	Torres, Analisa (1)	Southern District of New York	November 14, 2012	no Senate vote
	Watson, Derrick K. (1)	District of Hawaii	November 14, 2012	no Senate vote
	Quinones Alejandro, Nitza I. (1)	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	November 27, 2012	no Senate vote
	Restrepo, Luis F. (1)	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	November 27, 2012	no Senate vote
	Schmehl, Jeffrey L. (1)	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	November 27, 2012	no Senate vote
113th (2013-2014)	Cadish, Elissa F.	District of Nevada	January 4, 2013	withdrawn by president March 13, 2013
	Halligan, Caitlin J.	District of Columbia Circuit	January 4, 2013	withdrawn by president March 22, 2013
	Marquez, Rosemary (1)	District of Arizona	January 4, 2013	no Senate vote
	Pryor, Jill A. (1)	Eleventh Circuit	January 4, 2013	no Senate vote
	Thomas, William L.	Southern District of Florida	January 4, 2013	no Senate vote
	McHugh, Carolyn B. (1)	Tenth Circuit	May 16, 2013	no Senate vote
	Reeves, Pamela L. (1)	Eastern District of Tennessee	May 16, 2013	no Senate vote
	Brooks, Timothy L. (1)	Western District of Arkansas	June 7, 2013	no Senate vote
	Meyer, Jeffrey A. (1)	District of Connecticut	June 7, 2013	no Senate vote
	Donato, James (1)	Northern District of California	June 20, 2013	no Senate vote
	Freeman, Beth L. (1)	Northern District of California	June 20, 2013	no Senate vote
	May-Parker, Jennifer P.	Eastern District of North Carolina	June 20, 2013	no Senate vote
	Delgado Hernandez, Pedro A. (1)	District of Puerto Rico	June 26, 2013	no Senate vote
	Hendricks, Bruce H. (1)	District of South Carolina	June 26, 2013	no Senate vote
	Lee, Alison R.	District of South Carolina	June 26, 2013	no Senate vote
	Chhabria, Vince G. (1)	Northern District of California	July 25, 2013	no Senate vote
	Leitman, Matthew F. (1)	Eastern District of Michigan	July 25, 2013	no Senate vote
	Levy, Judith E. (1)	Eastern District of Michigan	July 25, 2013	no Senate vote
	Michelson, Laurie J. (1)	Eastern District of Michigan	July 25, 2013	no Senate vote
	Moody, James M., Jr. (1)	Eastern District of Arkansas	July 25, 2013	no Senate vote
	Parker, Linda V. (1)	Eastern District of Michigan	July 25, 2013	no Senate vote
	Cooper, Christopher R. (1)	District of the District of Columbia	August 1, 2013	no Senate vote
	Crabtree, Daniel D. (1)	District of Kansas	August 1, 2013	no Senate vote
	Friedland, Michelle T. (1)	Ninth Circuit	August 1, 2013	no Senate vote
	Harpool, M. Douglas (1)	Western District of Missouri	August 1, 2013	no Senate vote
	Lipman, Sheryl H. (1)	Western District of Tennessee	August 1, 2013	no Senate vote
	McHugh, Gerald A., Jr. (1)	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	August 1, 2013	no Senate vote
	Moritz, Nancy L. (1)	Tenth Circuit	August 1, 2013	no Senate vote
	Owens, John B. (1)	Ninth Circuit	August 1, 2013	no Senate vote
	Smith, Edward G. (1)	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	August 1, 2013	no Senate vote
	Bashant, Cynthia A. (1)	Southern District of California	September 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	Bastian, Stanley A. (1)	Eastern District of Washington	September 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	Humetewa, Diane J. (1)	District of Arizona	September 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	Levy, Jon D. (1)	District of Maine	September 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	Logan, Steven P. (1)	District of Arizona	September 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	Rayes, Douglas L. (1)	District of Arizona	September 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	Shah, Manish S. (1)	Northern District of Illinois	September 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	Tuchi, John J. (1)	District of Arizona	September 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	Barron, David J. (1)	First Circuit	September 24, 2013	no Senate vote
	Mastroianni, Mark G. (1)	District of Massachusetts	September 24, 2013	no Senate vote
	Talwani, Indira (1)	District of Massachusetts	September 24, 2013	no Senate vote
	Chuang, Theodore D. (1)	District of Maryland	September 25, 2013	no Senate vote
	Hazel, George J. (1)	District of Maryland	September 25, 2013	no Senate vote
	Peterson, James D. (1)	Western District of Wisconsin	November 7, 2013	no Senate vote
	Rosenbaum, Robin S. (1)	Eleventh Circuit	November 7, 2013	no Senate vote
	Rosenstengel, Nancy J. (1)	Southern District of Illinois	November 7, 2013	no Senate vote
	White, Ronnie L. (1)	Eastern District of Missouri	November 7, 2013	no Senate vote
	Boggs, Michael P.	Northern District of Georgia	December 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	Carnes, Julie E. (1)	Eleventh Circuit	December 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	Chutkan, Tanya S. (1)	District of the District of Columbia	December 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	Cohen, Mark H. (1)	Northern District of Georgia	December 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	Costa, Gregg J. (1)	Fifth Circuit	December 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	Lauck, M. Hannah (1)	Eastern District of Virginia	December 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	May, Leigh M. (1)	Northern District of Georgia	December 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	Ross, Eleanor L. (1)	Northern District of Georgia	December 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	Sorokin, Leo T. (1)	District of Massachusetts	December 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	Soto, James A. (1)	District of Arizona	December 19, 2013	no Senate vote
	Lee, Alison R.	District of South Carolina	January 6, 2014	withdrawn by president September 18, 2014
	Boggs, Michael P.	Northern District of Georgia	January 6, 2014	no Senate vote
	May-Parker, Jennifer P.	Eastern District of North Carolina	January 6, 2014	no Senate vote
	Davidson, Jeanne E.	Court of International Trade	August 18, 2014	no Senate vote
	Bennett, Alfred H. (1)	Southern District of Texas	September 18, 2014	no Senate vote
	Hanks, George C., Jr. (1)	Southern District of Texas	September 18, 2014	no Senate vote
	Olvera, Jose R., Jr. (1)	Southern District of Texas	September 18, 2014	no Senate vote
	Parrish, Jill N. (1)	District of Utah	September 18, 2014	no Senate vote
	Hall, LaShann M. D. (1)	Eastern District of New York	November 12, 2014	no Senate vote
	Drozd, Dale A. (1)	Eastern District of California	November 12, 2014	no Senate vote
	Restrepo, Luis F. (1)	Third Circuit	November 12, 2014	no Senate vote
	Stoll, Kara F. (1)	Federal Circuit	November 12, 2014	no Senate vote
	Donnelly, Ann (1)	Eastern District of New York	November 20, 2014	no Senate vote
	Ketchmark, Roseann A. (1)	Western District of Missouri	November 20, 2014	no Senate vote
	McDonough, Travis R. (1)	Eastern District of Tennessee	November 20, 2014	no Senate vote
114th (2015-2017)	Davidson, Jeanne E.	Court of International Trade	January 7, 2015	no Senate vote
	Barzee Flores, Mary	Southern District of Florida	February 26, 2015	no Senate vote
	Neals, Julien X.	District of New Jersey	February 26, 2015	no Senate vote
	Stanton, Edward L. III	Western District of Tennessee	May 21, 2015	no Senate vote
	Young, Mark A.	Central District of California	July 16, 2015	no Senate vote
	Baxter, Susan P. (1)	Western District of Pennsylvania	July 30, 2015	no Senate vote
	Bernstein, Inga S.	District of Massachusetts	July 30, 2015	no Senate vote
	Brown, Gary R.	Eastern District of New York	July 30, 2015	no Senate vote
	Colville, Robert J.	Western District of Pennsylvania	July 30, 2015	no Senate vote
	Drake, Elizabeth J.	Court of International Trade	July 30, 2015	no Senate vote
	Horan, Marilyn J.	Western District of Pennsylvania	July 30, 2015	no Senate vote
	Lopez, Dax E.	Northern District of Georgia	July 30, 2015	no Senate vote
	Younge, John M.	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	July 30, 2015	no Senate vote
	Connors, Clare E.	District of Hawaii	September 8, 2015	no Senate vote
	Gallagher, Stephanie A.	District of Maryland	September 8, 2015	no Senate vote
	McElroy, Mary S.	District of Rhode Island	September 8, 2015	no Senate vote
	Abrams, Paul L.	Central District of California	December 16, 2015	no Senate vote
	Mitchell, Suzanne	Western District of Oklahoma	December 16, 2015	no Senate vote
	Palk, Scott L. (1)	Western District of Oklahoma	December 16, 2015	no Senate vote
	Russell, Ronald G.	District of Utah	December 16, 2015	no Senate vote
	Ong, Winfield D.	Southern District of Indiana	January 12, 2016	no Senate vote
	Schott, Donald K.	Seventh Circuit	January 12, 2016	no Senate vote
	Selby, Myra C.	Seventh Circuit	January 12, 2016	no Senate vote
	Campbell, Terrence J.	District of Kansas	January 28, 2016	no Senate vote
	Puhl, Jennifer K.	Eighth Circuit	January 28, 2016	no Senate vote
	Finley, Stephanie A.	Western District of Louisiana	February 4, 2016	no Senate vote
	Kelly, Claude J. III	Eastern District of Louisiana	February 4, 2016	no Senate vote
	Kallon, Abdul K.	Eleventh Circuit	February 11, 2016	no Senate vote
	Beatty, Donald W.	District of South Carolina	February 25, 2016	no Senate vote
	Coggins, Donald C., Jr. (1)	District of South Carolina	February 25, 2016	no Senate vote
	Koh, Lucy H.	Ninth Circuit	February 25, 2016	no Senate vote
	Counts, Walter D. III (1)	Western District of Texas	March 15, 2016	no Senate vote
	Frost, E. Scott	Northern District of Texas	March 15, 2016	no Senate vote
	Haywood, Rebecca R.	Third Circuit	March 15, 2016	no Senate vote
	Hendrix, James W.	Northern District of Texas	March 15, 2016	no Senate vote
	Ramirez, Irma C.	Northern District of Texas	March 15, 2016	no Senate vote
	Scholer, Karen G.	Eastern District of Texas	March 15, 2016	no Senate vote
	Sweet, Kathleen M.	Western District of New York	March 15, 2016	no Senate vote
	Garland, Merrick B.	Supreme Court	March 16, 2016	no Senate vote
	Hughes, Lisabeth T.	Sixth Circuit	March 17, 2016	no Senate vote
	Nye, David C. (1)	District of Idaho	April 5, 2016	no Senate vote
	Andrus, Beth M.	Western District of Washington	April 14, 2016	no Senate vote
	Diaz, J. Michael	Western District of Washington	April 14, 2016	no Senate vote
	O'Sullivan, Kathleen M.	Western District of Washington	April 14, 2016	no Senate vote
	Barksdale, Patricia D.	Middle District of Florida	April 28, 2016	no Senate vote
	Edelman, Todd E.	District of Columbia	April 28, 2016	no Senate vote
	Jung, William F. (1)	Middle District of Florida	April 28, 2016	no Senate vote
	Lammens, Philip R.	Northern District of Florida	April 28, 2016	no Senate vote
	Pan, Florence Y.	District of Columbia	April 28, 2016	no Senate vote
	Rodriguez, Regina M.	District of Colorado	April 28, 2016	no Senate vote
	Timmons-Goodson, Patricia A.	Eastern District of North Carolina	April 28, 2016	no Senate vote
	Traum, Anne R.	District of Nevada	April 28, 2016	no Senate vote
	Qureshi, Abid R.	District of Columbia	September 6, 2016	no Senate vote
	Gujarati, Diane	Eastern District of New York	September 13, 2016	no Senate vote

Donald J. Trump (2017-present)
Congress	Nominee	Court	Nomination Date	Outcome
115th (2017-2019)	Stras, David R. (1)	Eighth Circuit	May 8, 2017	no Senate vote
	Farr, Thomas A.	Eastern District of North Carolina	July 13, 2017	no Senate vote
	Goodwin, Charles B. (1)	Western District of Oklahoma	July 13, 2017	no Senate vote
	Norris, Mark S., Sr. (1)	Western District of Tennessee	July 13, 2017	no Senate vote
	Ray, William M. II (1)	Northern District of Georgia	July 13, 2017	no Senate vote
	Richardson, Eli J. (1)	Middle District of Tennessee	July 13, 2017	no Senate vote
	Axon, Annemarie C. (1)	Northern District of Alabama	July 19, 2017	no Senate vote
	Burke, Liles C. (1)	Northern District of Alabama	July 19, 2017	no Senate vote
	Brennan, Michael B. (1)	Seventh Circuit	August 3, 2017	no Senate vote
	Juneau, Michael J. (1)	Western District of Louisiana	August 3, 2017	no Senate vote
	Teeter, Holly L. (1)	District of Kansas	August 3, 2017	no Senate vote
	Beaverstock, Jeffrey U. (1)	Southern District of Alabama	September 7, 2017	no Senate vote
	Bounds, Ryan W.	Ninth Circuit	September 7, 2017	no Senate vote
	Branch, Elizabeth L. (1)	Eleventh Circuit	September 7, 2017	no Senate vote
	Kacsmaryk, Matthew J.	Northern District of Texas	September 7, 2017	no Senate vote
	Marks, Emily C. (1)	Middle District of Alabama	September 7, 2017	no Senate vote
	Mateer, Jeffrey C.	Eastern District of Texas	September 7, 2017	no Senate vote
	Moorer, Terry F. (1)	Southern District of Alabama	September 7, 2017	no Senate vote
	Talley, Brett J.	Middle District of Alabama	September 7, 2017	no Senate vote
	Petersen, Matthew S.	District of Columbia	September 11, 2017	no Senate vote
	Nielson, Howard C., Jr.	District of Utah	September 28, 2017	no Senate vote
	Ashe, Barry W. (1)	Eastern District of Louisiana	October 2, 2017	no Senate vote
	Domenico, Daniel D.	District of Colorado	October 2, 2017	no Senate vote
	Duncan, Stuart K. (1)	Fifth Circuit	October 2, 2017	no Senate vote
	Englehardt, Kurt D. (1)	Fifth Circuit	October 5, 2017	no Senate vote
	Giampietro, Gordon P.	Eastern District of Wisconsin	December 20, 2017	no Senate vote
	Bounds, Ryan W.	Ninth Circuit	January 8, 2018	withdrawn by president June 24, 2018
	Domenico, Daniel D.	District of Colorado	January 8, 2018	no Senate vote
	Farr, Thomas A.	Eastern District of North Carolina	January 8, 2018	no Senate vote
	Kacsmaryk, Matthew J.	Northern District of Texas	January 8, 2018	no Senate vote
	Barker, J. Campbell	Eastern District of Texas	January 23, 2018	no Senate vote
	Truncale, Michael J.	Eastern District of Teas	January 23, 2018	no Senate vote
	Vitter, Wendy	Eastern District of Louisiana	January 23, 2018	no Senate vote
	Berger, Wendy W.	Middle District of Florida	April 10, 2018	no Senate vote
	Brady, Holly A.	Northern District of Indiana	April 10, 2018	no Senate vote
	Brasher, Andrew L.	Middle District of Alabama	April 10, 2018	no Senate vote
	O'Connor, John M.	Eastern, Northern, and Western Districts of Oklahoma	April 10, 2018	no Senate vote
	Winsor, Allen C.	Northern District of Florida	April 10, 2018	no Senate vote
	Wyrick, Patrick R.	Western District of Oklahoma	April 10, 2018	no Senate vote
	Arias-Marxuach, Raul M.	District of Puerto Rico	April 12, 2018	no Senate vote
	Barker, Pamela A.	Northern District of Ohio	April 12, 2018	no Senate vote
	Bell, Kenneth D.	Western District of North Carolina	April 12, 2018	no Senate vote
	Clark, Stephen R., Sr.	Eastern District of Missouri	April 12, 2018	no Senate vote
	Katchen, Jonathan W.	District of Alaska	April 12, 2018	no Senate vote
	Matey, Paul B.	Third Circuit	April 12, 2018	no Senate vote
	McElroy, Mary S.	District of Rhode Island	April 12, 2018	no Senate vote
	Morales, David S.	Southern District of Texas	April 12, 2018	no Senate vote
	Morrison, Sarah D.	Southern District of Ohio	April 12, 2018	no Senate vote
	Altman, Roy K.	Southern District of Florida	May 7, 2018	no Senate vote
	Barber, Thomas P.	Middle District of Florida	May 7, 2018	no Senate vote
	Ruiz, Rodolfo A. II	Southern District of Florida	May 7, 2018	no Senate vote
	Smith, Rodney	Southern District of Florida	May 7, 2018	no Senate vote
	Wetherell, T. Kent	Northern District of Florida	May 7, 2018	no Senate vote
	Brown, Gary R.	Eastern District of New York	May 15, 2018	no Senate vote
	Gujarati, Diane	Eastern District of New York	May 15, 2018	no Senate vote
	Komitee, Eric R.	Eastern District of New York	May 15, 2018	no Senate vote
	Kovner, Rachel P.	Eastern District of New York	May 15, 2018	no Senate vote
	Liman, Lewis J.	Southern District of New York	May 15, 2018	no Senate vote
	Maze, Corey L.	Northern District of Alabama	May 15, 2018	no Senate vote
	Sinatra, John L., Jr.	Western District of New York	May 15, 2018	no Senate vote
	Vyskocil, Mary K.	Southern District of New York	May 15, 2018	no Senate vote
	Wolson, Joshua	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	May 15, 2018	no Senate vote
	Gallagher, Stephanie A.	District of Maryland	June 11, 2018	no Senate vote
	Immergut, Karin J.	District of Oregon	June 11, 2018	no Senate vote
	Pacold, Martha M.	Northern District of Illinois	June 11, 2018	no Senate vote
	Alston, Rossie D., Jr.	Eastern District of Virginia	June 18, 2018	no Senate vote
	Baker, M. Miller	Court of International Trade	June 18, 2018	no Senate vote
	Murphy, Eric E.	Sixth Circuit	June 18, 2018	no Senate vote
	Nichols, Carl J.	District of Columbia	June 18, 2018	no Senate vote
	Readler, Chad A.	Sixth Circuit	June 18, 2018	no Senate vote
	Reif, Timothy M.	Court of International Trade	June 18, 2018	no Senate vote
	Rowland, Mary M.	Northern District of Illinois	June 18, 2018	no Senate vote
	Seeger, Steven C.	Northern District of Illinois	June 18, 2018	no Senate vote
	Leichty, Damon R.	Northern District of Indiana	July 17, 2018	no Senate vote
	Younge, John M.	Eastern District of Pennsylvania	July 17, 2018	no Senate vote
	Miller, Eric D.	Ninth Circuit	July 19, 2018	no Senate vote
	Ranjan, J. Nicholas	Western District of Pennsylvania	July 24, 2018	no Senate vote
	Bade, Bridget S.	Ninth Circuit	August 27, 2018	no Senate vote
	Rushing, Allison J.	Fourth Circuit	August 27, 2018	no Senate vote
	Boulee, Jean-Paul	Northern District of Georgia	August 28, 2018	no Senate vote
	Cain, James D., Jr.	Western District of Louisiana	August 28, 2018	no Senate vote
	Bianco, Joseph F.	Second Circuit	November 13, 2018	no Senate vote
	Blumenfeld, Stanley	Central District of California	November 13, 2018	no Senate vote
	Buescher, Brian C.	District of Nebraska	November 13, 2018	no Senate vote
	Bumatay, Patrick J.	Ninth Circuit	November 13, 2018	no Senate vote
	Collins, Daniel P.	Ninth Circuit	November 13, 2018	no Senate vote
	Corker, Clifton L.	Eastern District of Tennessee	November 13, 2018	no Senate vote
	Halpern, Philip M.	Southern District of New York	November 13, 2018	no Senate vote
	Lee, Kenneth K.	Ninth Circuit	November 13, 2018	no Senate vote
	Marcelle, Thomas	Northern District of New York	November 13, 2018	no Senate vote
	McFarland, Matthew W.	Southern District of Ohio	November 13, 2018	no Senate vote
	Park, Michael H.	Second Circuit	November 13, 2018	no Senate vote
	Rosen, Jeremy B.	Central District of California	November 13, 2018	no Senate vote
	Scarsi, Mark C.	Central District of California	November 13, 2018	no Senate vote
	Rao, Neomi J.	District of Columbia Circuit	November 14, 2018	no Senate vote

Judges

Biographical Directory of Article III Federal Judges
Bankruptcy Judgeships
Magistrate Judgeships
Diversity on the Bench
Judicial Salaries
Unsuccessful Nominations and Recess Appointments
Impeachments of Federal Judges

Federal Judicial Center

You are here

Unsuccessful Nominations and Recess Appointments

Judges