| JUSTICE | FROM | TO |
| Bushrod Washington | 4-29-1802 | 3-2-1803 |
| William Paterson | 3-3-1803 | 9-9-1806 |
| Henry Brockholst Livingston | 3-9-1808 | 3-18-1823 |
| Smith Thompson | 9-1-1823 | 12-18-1843 |
| Samuel Nelson | 3-5-1845 | 11-28-1872 |
| Ward Hunt | 4-28-1873 | 1-27-1882 |
| Stephen Johnson Field | 1-30-1882 | 4-2-1882 |
| Samuel M. Blatchford | 4-3-1882 | 7-7-1893 |
| Horace Gray | 7-15-1893 | 4-1-1894 |
| Henry Billings Brown | 4-2-1894 | 2-2-1896 |
| Rufus Wheeler Peckham | 2-3-1896 | 10-24-1909 |
| Horace Harmon Lurton | 1-10-1910 | 1-8-1911 |
| Charles Evans Hughes | 1-9-1911 | 6-10-1916 |
| Louis Dembitz Brandeis | 6-12-1916 | 3-15-1925 |
| Harlan Fiske Stone | 3-16-1925 | 10-13-1941 |
| Robert Houghwout Jackson | 10-14-1941 | 11-12-1945 |
| Stanley Forman Reed | 11-13-1945 | 10-13-1946 |
| Robert Houghwout Jackson | 10-14-1946 | 10-9-1954 |
| Stanley Forman Reed | 4-26-1954 | 11-21-1954 |
| Felix Frankfurter | 11-22-1954 | 4-3-1955 |
| John Marshall Harlan | 4-4-1955 | 9-23-1971 |
| Felix Frankfurter | 6-24-1957 | 10-13-1958 |
| William Joseph Brennan, Jr. | 6-29-1959 | 4-1-1962 |
| Thurgood Marshall | 9-24-1971 | 9-30-1991 |
| Anthony McLeod Kennedy | 10-1-1991 | 10-31-1991 |
| Clarence Thomas | 11-1-1991 | 9-29-1994 |
| Ruth Bader Ginsburg | 9-30-1994 | 9-18-2020 |
| Sonia Sotomayor | 11-20-2020 | present |