The Bakelite case involved a petition to bar the Court of Customs and Patent Appeals from hearing an appeal from a decision of the Tariff Commission because the matter was not a case or controversy within the meaning of Article III of the U.S. Constitution, and was therefore non-judicial. The Supreme Court held that the Court of Customs and Patent Appeals, along with other specialized courts such as the Court of Claims, was a legislative court established under Article I, and was therefore not limited in its jurisdiction by the parameters of Article III. Therefore, Congress could constitutionally delegate the review of tariff decisions – a legislative function – to the court. In 1958, Congress declared the court to have been established under Article III, thereby giving its judges tenure during good behavior and protection against having their salaries diminished.
See also:
Cases that Shaped the Federal Courts: Glidden Co. v. Zdanok (1962)